PFD Preachers

I don't quite understand that one, being the comment about the 2 year old rescue. What could have been done besides jumping in after him? I ask because I did the same thing, but for my son. Give or take when he was 3 I instructed him to hold onto the railing while walking off the dock. Imagine this - he didn't! I lost a cell phone to water damage that day.
 
quote:

Originally posted by rommer

quote:

Originally posted by cwms

When I was a teen, about 17-18 years old, the son of the marina owner, went overboard on the gas dock, not more than 10 feet from his dad. His dad momentarily frooze while I ran past him, jumped in the water to rescue the boy. Age of the boy...2. No life jacket.

Enuff said.






Not to be a PITA but what you did was wrong. Water life saving courses teach that diving/jumping in is a method of last resort. Glad you saved his life but impulsive saves can get one hurt.








Sorry I saved his life by doing it wrong.

No, I've never taken a life saving course and I reacted on pure instinct. I was very familiar with both the dock I was standing on and the water where the dock was located.
I ran to the end of the dock where the boy fell and didn't just jump, but came to a quick halt before jumping so I wouldn't jump on top of him or way past him but went into the water feet first right next to the boy. It was maybe 3 feet from the dock to the water. I was able to grab him and get him up high enough out of the water where his dad could reach down, grab him and pull him onto the dock. Tragedy averted.

So, for future reference, what should I have done?
 
Rommer, I also would like to know what the current teaching is. I was a life guard and WSI instructor many many years ago, and I would have done the same thing.
 
In the know, if you are really, "in the know" you should know that tragedies occur in the blink of an eye.
And I'm sorry there are complete strangers walking our streets that actually care for the safety and well being of your child.
 
Reading the age of the child, brought to mind that I read in todays paper that a Senator ran over his 2 year old grand daughter yesterday. Her grandmother left the room for a minute and she ran out and was hit by the car. Unless a child that age is on a leash, they can be gone in a wink of an eye....
 
I'm with ITK and others on this.

I suspect the people that go out of their way to remind you what you should be doing stick their nose into people's business in other areas as well and justify it under being a good citizen.

I don't buy it.
 
quote:

Originally posted by cwms

When I was a teen, about 17-18 years old, the son of the marina owner, went overboard on the gas dock, not more than 10 feet from his dad. His dad momentarily frooze while I ran past him, jumped in the water to rescue the boy. Age of the boy...2. No life jacket.

Enuff said.






Enuff said??? You have a sample of exactly one incident and that is supposed to be the final conclusion?

My uncle died when he flipped his convertible over. Based on your logic of one example - I vote we ban all convertibles in the world.

At the end of the day, you politely telling me changes absolutely nothing. The wearing of the PFD is at my (and Mrs. Knows) discretion and I have never seen a child drown in a parking lot. If I feel it is not needed walking down the dock, it will not be worn. Likewise, if I feel that while sitting in the cockpit of a Blackfin 38 while tied up at the slip, a pfd is not warranted, it will not be worn.

You may not like it, but people still have choices in this world.

Radioactive is 100% correct. Our methods may not be the same, but parenting belongs to the parents.
 
ItK, I'm with you. He crossed the line. You don't tell folks how to deal with their kids.
 
An interesting discussion, when traveling in the Mediterranean we never heard anything like what has been described above about our then 4 year old, not until we arrived back in the states did I hear anything from the PFD want-a-be police. Now normally I give them the bird, if I speak to them at all is is usually to tell them to FO. But on occasion I will let the offending person know that our (now) 5 year old has more miles at sea under her than most will ever experience and if I wanted to hear their dribble I would ask.

Sorry people but keep your PFD opinions to yourself, we do not want to hear them and really it is none of your Fing business.

SeaQuest OE
 
My incident was not meant to be a final conclusion.

My point, as Stephen and Thataway4 backed up with other incidents, tragedy happens in the blink of an eye just as your uncle found out. And usually, the blink of an eye isn't enough time to put on a PFD or seat belt, or helmut, etc.

Just maybe, if you had been the one to fish that 2 year old kid out of the water when you were a teen, you just might have a different attitute regarding PFD's while walking your 2 year old down a dock. I do agree that a PFD in the parking lot isn't really necessary.
 
I'm with the side that says all young children should wear a PFD anytime that are on the dock.
I have absolutely no use for any parent who would risk their child's life simply because they're too ignorant to understand how quickly a small child can disappear under the water.
 
Adrift,

While I am in general agreement with you and others about the PFD issue it is really no one's business to "inform" someone else what to do or not to do, if you or anyone else believes a crime has been committed then call the police.

Sitting here in Ft. Lauderdale on the hard and have the PFD want-a-be police tell us our child needs to be wearing a PDF when we are several hundred feet from the water is beyond imagination to me.

SeaQuest OE
 
quote:

Originally posted by Adrift

I'm with the side that says all young children should wear a PFD anytime that are on the dock.
I have absolutely no use for any parent who would risk their child's life simply because they're too ignorant to understand how quickly a small child can disappear under the water.






Good, stay adrift and our paths will not cross.

So a small child can disappear under the water faster than an adult? Why not require by law PFD's for everybody?
 
I try not to go out of my way to point out things other people are doing wrong. If I did I'd have no time to do anything for myself! But...

We required our youngest to wear a pfd from the parking lot to the boat, and at all time she was in the cockpit, until she learned to swim. Now, as a fairly good swimmer, she can walk holding our hands to the boat w/o a pfd. I wear a pfd most of the time, but not all of the time. I TRY to set a good example and wear one anytime a risk is recognizable.

Around docks even adults can drown. Our neighbor lost the last grandparent in their family to drowning. The family all came back in from the lake their parents had a lake house on. Some wanted to go back out but the grandfather decided to stay and fish from the dock. A while later they all came back and no sign of grandad. Just his cigar floating in the water. Seems he slipped and fell in, probably hitting his head on a docked boat. Would a pfd have saved him, maybe, maybe not. Would a pfd have increased his chances, certianly.

Many people drown each year jumping in to save someone else. In some cases three people have drowned trying to save one. Does this mean the next person should just stand by while a two year old drowns... no. But it does happen.

I cringe when I see a parent with a front airbag going down the highway with a young child in their lap. I cringe, but I do not pull them over.

What is right between adults is usually best communicated by setting an example. Trying for force your view seldom works.

When in doubt, try to do what seems right.

There is no true winner in a debate like this, but its main value is that it makes you think. For this reason I'm glad I've read this thread!

Thanks to everyone for your point of view. They are all of value.
 
ITK and all the others who think the same: you make me sick. You put your pride ahead of the safety of your young child. You make me sick. I pray nothing happens to your child, for your child's sake. Not for yours. You all make me sick.
 
Flutterby,

If you are so sick maybe you should see a doctor or perhaps a psychiatrist? I am sure some Thorizene will be of some help.

SeaQuest OE help
 
When you are my marina, children are not permitted anywhere past the gateway leading down to the water without PFD's on. This is a club rule, and if people don't like it, they are not welcome at the club. Not all people are PFD police, but it sounds like you are experienced, and don't need to be reminded about safety. Most people meeting you for the first time, may not know that you and your kids are very knowledgeable as to when they should have PFD's on. Back off a little, and thank them, because they care. I worked in high rise construction for a long time and the old timers can tell you, the know it alls are the ones that fall off the buildings because they thought they knew better than anyone, when they should be belted.
 
quote:

Originally posted by SaltyCam

When you are my marina, children are not permitted anywhere past the gateway leading down to the water without PFD's on. This is a club rule, and if people don't like it, they are not welcome at the club. Fair enough we have NEVER attended any club or club event, nor do we belong to any club and have no desire to do so. Not all people are PFD police, but it sounds like you are experienced, and don't need to be reminded about safety. Most people meeting you for the first time, may not know that you and your kids are very knowledgeable as to when they should have PFD's on. Back off a little, and thank them, because they care. Illrelevant, it is no ones business to butt into anyone else's business if you believe a crime has been committed then call the police otherwise mind your own business. (Nothing personal SaltyCam just a general statement) I worked in high rise construction for a long time and the old timers can tell you, the know it alls are the ones that fall off the buildings because they thought they knew better than anyone, when they should be belted.






SeaQuest OE
 
quote:

Originally posted by Flutterby

ITK and all the others who think the same: you make me sick. You put your pride ahead of the safety of your young child. You make me sick. I pray nothing happens to your child, for your child's sake. Not for yours. You all make me sick.






What makes me sick is people interjecting themselves into my business, in essence, insulting my ability as a parent.

What makes me sick is non officers of the law using words like "by law..." when they are dead wrong

please tell me, in the cockpit of a 38' Flybridge convertible tied at the slip, with 2 adults sitting on the transom, and 1 adult on each gunnel - where are the kids going to go?

Perhaps you and others need nanny laws that you perceive to protect our children, I however believe in choice and parental rights to choose for their children.
 
I guess the reason why we have an over-abundance of "preachers" whether it be PFD's, seatbelts, helmuts, or anything else....is because there is an over-abundance of idiotic parents who don't have a clue how to raise kids.
 
Back
Top