PFD's

MBPCPA

Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2004
RO Number
15652
Messages
2
I recently purchased a used cruiser. The boat has 9 old type II pfd's, the cheap orange ones. I want to upgrade at least two of them, and am debating on what type to get. Inflatable ones look very comfortable, but are more expensive.

What type of pfds do you have, or recommend. I cruise off the California coast and need type II's

Thanks
 
If you are replacing anyway why not go with Type I offshore. Of if you can enforce it, inflatable life vests worn each trip. Regardless, get strobes and whistles for each one. Regards
 
I'm with Firecracker on the Type I's. If you should ever need them you would certainly want the very best, & I believe only the type ones will best help keep your head out of the water when you are unconscious or exhausted. After you get those, the Mustang Bomber jackets are really comfy/terrific when it gets at all nippy & everyone loves to wear them. There are newer comfortable "vest"-looking PFDs also with fleece collars and a bunch of pockets you might consider. Inflatables MUST be worn to be counted as on-board PFD's. That's probabaly a good thing but many find them quite uncomfortable and will not wear them.
 
Whistles and strobes - an absolute must. It's harder than you'd think to find people in the water, even with a PFD.
 
I can only add one thing to this. Your coment of:

"Inflatable ones look very comfortable, but are more expensive."

They are only more expensive, untill you need them, then the cost of them suddenly becomes unimportant, and it only matters that they work. God forbid you will ever need them, but when you do, would you not want only the very best? Really think about that...............D.............
 
Les, for someone like me who has no familiarity with inflatables it is hard to see the difference from one to the other as posted on your list.

My wife is VERY uncomfortable on the water. I am very seriously considering seeing if she would were one of these automatic inflatables and possible be more mentally comfortable.

To get her to wear it, physical comfort is obviously required. How do I go about determining which one would be best?

George
 
We carry 2 type I's and also have inflatables for the quick going out when it gets a little nasty. I also carry type II's to make enough for any guests. All with the necessary gear attached.
 
Inflatable makes a big difference in hot weather. In CGAux we have to wear PFD at all times aboard, even to step onto the boat. A lot of us have the 3031.
WEAR IT!!! The statistics in your favor go way up!
 
Just a reminder, inflatables only count towards your PDF requirements when worn on your person.
 
It is a no brainer: get inflatables and wear them. Take your wife shopping and have her try them on and pick the one she is most comfortable wearing. Only let her try on those which meet requirements for the area you boat. Cost? H#ll, you'd spend more money on a new "toy", why not spend it on a life saving device? Cheap insurance!

I have an inflatable, a qualified float jacket for windy winter days, and a PWC type for playing in/on the water. I also have the cheap one to meet requirements for guests.
 
Im with Flutterby. You could ask the sales clerk if your wife could wear them around the store for a while to check comfort over 20-30 minutes. Remind her that every Marine Fire-Rescue, Law Enforcement and many Coast Guardsmen (and women) wear them. Many fishing guides do also.
 
And now bass tournament participants are required to wear them too. Also go-fast boats often choose to wear them. To me it is a no-brainer. How many bodies have been recovered wearing a PFD?

IMHO, every person who chooses to buy/wear an inflatable should take a test plunge into the water while wearing it. They behave very differently then the traditional ones and it is better to know what to expect before an emergency arises. Swimming with one inflated is very different. I had to reduce the inflation before I could get my arms working effectively. Your mileage may differ.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Flutterby

And now bass tournament participants are required to wear them too. Also go-fast boats often choose to wear them. To me it is a no-brainer. How many bodies have been recovered wearing a PFD?






To which bass tournaments do you refer? I have fished many a tournament and have NEVER been required to wear a PFD. Rest assured, any tournament that requires me to wear a PFD, will not get my entry $$.

With respect to the go-fasts, that is an interesting observation as I have never seen a boat wear a PFD.
 
Somebody please help me out here. The following is MBCPA's post quoted inits entirety:

"I recently purchased a used cruiser. The boat has 9 old type II pfd's, the cheap orange ones. I want to upgrade at least two of them, and am debating on what type to get. Inflatable ones look very comfortable, but are more expensive.

What type of pfds do you have, or recommend. I cruise off the California coast and need type II's

Thanks"


Flutterby, Firecracker, and Hyperfishing all make reference to MBCPA's "wife" in their posts. How do they:

1) Ascertain that MBCPA is male;

2) What is the point of bringing their potential/possible spouse into the equation when there is zero, as in nada, zilch, reference to a spouse in the original post?

Somebody, anybody?
 
"Just curious how we got from A to C, that's all."

LOL ITK....I think A to C is pretty much the norm nowadays , If anything, it’s much more efficient, who needs those extra letters anyway? Hope the hand is healing well. Is your young un still setting booby traps for you?

Got to wear PFD's when motoring around in Bass Tournaments in Oklahoma:

http://greenwoodfishing.com/fishing.htm

(19) SAFETY: Life Jackets, Kill Switches, and Working Bow and Stern Lights are MANDATORY. Safe boating and fishing practices must be observed at all times. Life jackets and kill switches must be worn when boat is on plane.

George,

I was blessed with a wife who adapted well to wearing PFD’s, the old bulky ones and old ski vests; of coarse the new baby we had (18 years ago) was a pretty powerful distraction. PFD’s were not as advanced then as today (heck, there wasn’t even cell phones-just good ole VHF). There are some outstanding ideas in this thread that I didn’t know existed. PFD’s have come along way over the years. Being mentally comfortable on the water is a crucial step towards enjoying boating.

I am interested in which style you fine best; with our son coming less and less to the boat as his life evolves, we have more non-boating experienced friends coming to the visit. I had totally forgotten that not all people can relax and enjoy the water as much as my wife and I. Comfort for them will make or break having a good time for all.

Great thread!

Stan
 
quote:

Originally posted by gcolton

My wife is VERY uncomfortable on the water. I am very seriously considering seeing if she would were one of these automatic inflatables and possible be more mentally comfortable.

To get her to wear it, physical comfort is obviously required. How do I go about determining which one would be best?





ITK----LOL, I am quoting "B" above......I guess my mind combined posts by two different ROs and made one post for them! Sorry if that confused you......as you can see, my mind is more easily confused as time passes.
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

Somebody please help me out here. The following is MBCPA's post quoted inits entirety:

"I recently purchased a used cruiser. The boat has 9 old type II pfd's, the cheap orange ones. I want to upgrade at least two of them, and am debating on what type to get. Inflatable ones look very comfortable, but are more expensive.

What type of pfds do you have, or recommend. I cruise off the California coast and need type II's

Thanks"


Flutterby, Firecracker, and Hyperfishing all make reference to MBCPA's "wife" in their posts. How do they:

1) Ascertain that MBCPA is male;

2) What is the point of bringing their potential/possible spouse into the equation when there is zero, as in nada, zilch, reference to a spouse in the original post?

Somebody, anybody?






MBCPA's profile lists "Male" so I'd think that would narrow down the possibilities.
 
Back
Top