Piling heights

PascalG

Moderator
Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2003
RO Number
12212
Messages
12,221
they are replacing some pilings in my city owned marina...

you'd think they'd learn the lessons of past hurricanes and replace the pilings with taller ones ?

of course not. but it gets better... the new pilings are about 4 to 6 foot taller than the old ones when they are installed, but then they cut them down with a chainsaw !

is it because taller pilings woudl need to driven down deeper to make up for the extra leverage ?
 
higher pile=more leverage when tide level increases=pile failure. Move your boat to a harbor of safe refuge during a hurricane. You'd think they'd learn the lessons of past hurricanes!
 
yeah but higher pile means boats don't ride on top of the pilings.

there are no harbor of safe refuge in south florida, you have like 1 spot on the hard for 1000 boats... the only option is too move out of the strike area, which is what i do, but unfortunately there is no safe harbor.
 
Gota love those engineer types.... what are they thinking ..... DOH
 
Coulda saved a lot of $$ by simply buying shorter pilings, but I don't guess that was the plan.
 
It does seem common to drive the pilings as far as they will go then cut off to limit the leverage.
 
Could it have something to with getting a line over the piling? I don't know...always been in floating docks.
 
Wood Piles driven with a hammer tend to "mushroom" at the end struck repeatedly by the hammer. This spreads and opens the fiber structure of the pile. Rain water will pool in theopen areas and rot gets a faster start. Trimming the top removes the damaged section of pile and assuming the contract calls for capping the pile with sheet metal or copper, water will be directed away and rot delayed.
 
It's not a leverage thing, its a tidal height, storm surge, thing.

The point is that the higher the piling, the less the chance that the docks, along with the boats, will ride up and over the tops of the pilings, usually with a catastrophic rusult.

The extra length is to facilitate for the higher tides usually associated with such storms.

There was a marina built "near here", very well built in fact, with the best of everything. The pilings were driven just as one normally would expect with lots of extra height to facilitate for the high tides experienced with some of the big storms. Then came the "expert" who ordered that the extra height of these pilings be cut down -- for no apparent reason.

Then came Hurricane Bob. The area in which this marina is located took the brunt of the storm surge, and let's just say that the extra height would have saved lots of damage, not to mention that the pilings were removed shortly thereafter and replaced with extra length ones.
 
Any person foolish enough to keep a boat moored in a boat slip, in an marina during a Hurricane deserves exactly what occurs. If you think a few extra feet of a single wood pile is going to prevent damage in a hurricane, dream on my friend. High winds will cause the boat to chaffe against the piling and eat through the thin layer of GRP that is sold as a hull these days and sink the boat long before the high water of the storm surge arrive. Have you ever seen boats, post hurricane, driven hard aground with the mooring lines still attached to piles that were pulled out of the earth's surface?

Remembering 8.17.69 and 8.29.05
 
Dear Mr. L.Keith,

Please accept my apology. I thought that this thread was about piling heights when all along it's about "moving your boat to a harbor of safe refuge during a hurricane". I just musta-missed that part and responded as if we were (still) talking about those stupid pilings. You see, where I come from, higher pilings have always made sense and just seems normal to me.

"Remembering 8.17.69 and 8.29.05" -- by the way, my friend, you're not mocking me, are you?

Perhaps when Pascal gets back to this thread, he can comment and clarify exactly what his intent here is.
 
my original question was to understand why woudl they install tall piling then cut the top 6' ! i suspected a leverage issue but i'm not convince. Water getting caught on top, where they bang it into the bottom, makes sense although they could just cut the top 6" and put a cap on it.

About hurricane tactics, it's easy to say "move to a safe harbor" but it's a little harder to actually define "safe harbor" and much harder to actually find one, at least around here.

maybe up in the Northern Gulf you have fewer boats and many holes up the bayous and bays but here we don't. We've also lost something like 50% of boat yards in the past 5 to 10 years so there are few spots to haul out...

so best option is to move the boat out of the danger area. It requires some planning but mostly good timing. you have a very narrow window to get moving between the time where you can make the North/South decision and when bridges are locked down for evacs. In most cases, you dont' need to very far, 50, 75 miles is more than enough to be away from the dangerous core of a storm. I've done this a few times in the past and its the best option. However there are some instances where you have nowhere to go, like in case of a storm coming from the south along the coast...

If you have no choice but keeping the boat in its slip, there are a number of factors that can help minimize the risk and damage.

- multiple lines, chaffing gear, and spreading the loads on multiple cleats and pilings.
- wide slips so that the boat will not bang into the pilings.
- tall pilings to eliminates the chances of the boat coming back down on the pilings...

I didn't make this up, it's not just common sense but the recommendation with everyone with experience starting with insurers who have a lot of experience in observing what works and what didn't

Katrina and Wilma were minor storms and i stayed on board. During wilma (highest recorded gust a few miles from here was 97kts) i got a few scratches below the rub rail because the pilings didn't even extend to the rub rail at the peak of the storm surge. If that piling had been a little higher, i woudln't have had any damage at. In another spot, i got a small section of bent stainless steel rubrail because the piling caught it underneath. Minor stuff but if the slip had been a foot wider and the piling taller i woudnt' even have gotten a single scratch.

there were a number of boats with rub rail damage in the marina, some with holes, but in most cases the damage came from the pilings catching the rub rails from underneath, not from the rubbing although i agree that even the toughest rub rail will not last forever while rubbing against a piling. However, a hole at the rub rail is much better than a hole below waterline which one of cause of totalled boats in their slips.

so i found it surprising that they'd cut the top 5 or 6' of new pilings...

as to boats being washed ashore with with the pilings still attached, no.. havent see that in person... but i've seen boats damaged because one piling failed or boats where the owners had to run the engine to stay off the dock after one of their only two pilings failed. Thats why i was wondering about leverage... and again, this is where slip layout is important... and why blanket statement like " Any person foolish enough to keep a boat moored in a boat slip, in an marina during a Hurricane deserves exactly what occurs." is just plain stupid. Some slips are safer than others.

if you have only one pair of pilings at the bow, you're at risk. If you have a total of 3 pairs of pilings, one at the bow and two amidship, you can spread the loads and divide the stress on the pilings, lines and cleats by 3.

you don't have to be a rocket scientist to see that your odds are much better...
 
It is quite possiable that they were not able to either drive or jet the pilings in all of the way, thus cut them off--it does not make sense. The piling is very expensive, and having to drive them down further takes more time and is more difficult. Of course it would be "unsightly" to not have all of the pilings the same length. When the pilings are ordered, they are in 5 foot incirments. So if the water is shallower, they should have ordered a shorter piling. We epoxy the top of the pilings and then paint the epoxy to avoid IV detiorration to prevent rot from the top.

I would ask the marina management and find out what is going on.

In my own dock, we have "stand off Pilings" which are 30 feet long. They are jetted in/driven as far as possiable and extent at least 12 feet above mean water. These are not attatched to the dock, so that even if the dock lifts (which fixed docks do with wave action) the stand offs will keep the boat from going over the dock pilings and damaging the hull. We depend on anchors, trees, or deep set pilings to keep the boat in place: not cleats on docks or small pilings. Well set plings are more difficult pull out--they can break off. Pilings should be driven butt (Larger diameter) down. This makes them more difficult to pull up. But it is easier to put pilings in small diameter down and unfortunately that is the way that many contractors put them in.
 
Pascal,

When we had our dock installed, they drove numerous piles at super lengths. They cut them off at the same height after they hit a certain resistance with the pile driver (ie they didn't go down any further). Each pile was cut off at different lengths, but my guess was they threw away an average of 4 to 6 feet from each pile.

PS After Charlie, they had to replace dozens. They still have not replaced the piles into "Safety Harbor" on North Captiva.
 
All the marinas around Charleston are floating docks. I know that the main of Hugo hit 30 miles north in McClellanville. I can't find a single marina that wasn't totally rebuilt after Hugo. I know there are lot's of rivers and creeks in my area. We also have a limited number of haul out options. I don't trust my skills as far as taking her up a creek and trying to secure her. We've found a maeina in as much of a lee as possible. If we're aimed at by a storm, I'm tying off to both fingers with all the lines I have, applying all the chafing gear, un-pluging my LCD TV, loading the car and truck,crossing my fingers and heading inland.Outguessing a storm in a 10 MPH boat isn't my first choice.
 
Man, Pascal do you charge by the word? You guys do what you wish in a storm. Maybe if you say it enough times on the internet it could become the truth. Widen a slip just before a storm? Maybe difficult, but hey, try it. Increase the height of the piles the day before landfall, does Worst Marine sell an adaptor for that purpose? Extra lines, chaffing gear and spreading the load, nothing wrong with that, but what about the boat in the next slip that shares the piles with you. Next renewal time for your hull insurance, just tell your underwriter that your hurricane plan is to sit it out in the local exposed marina. And you wonder why your insurance has been canceled or greatly increased in cost. Miami has been lucky the last few years and I hope that luck holds. Billy, do a google on the dates in my last post to see what they represent. My opinions are based on experience in storms a little stronger than 97 knots.
 
i'll ignore the sarcasm, and ask again : try finding a safe harbor in southeast florida...

i live in the real world... not in lala land... we dont' have safe harbor so the nr 1 option is to move the boat away.

obviously, slip design can't be changed but it is a fact that wide slips with multiple tall pilings protect boats better. One such marina on biscayne bay had near 0 losses during andrew.

I agree about one thing, we've been lucky since 92... recent storms were nothing but a taste of what could come.
 
Safe harbor's do not have signs, you have to seek them out. Where does the USCG send their 87' Patrol Boats for storms? Follow them. Commercial fishing boats tend to know where to go. Take a case of "Ole Mil Dew" and go talk to the guys in the white boots, they will be glad to help out.

The US Navy recommends the upper Keys, the following is from the Hurricane Havens Handbook for the Atlantic Coast.

4) Alternative Anchoring and Mooring Practices. Vessels unable to occupy the berths recommended above may, with foresight, be able to take advantage of the shelter offered by the reef to the north of the main Keys -- known locally as the "Backcountry". The following extract from the U.S. Coast Pilot 4 (1979), Cape Henry to Key West -- is relevant:

"Hurricane Moorings - small boats should seek shelter in a small winding stream whose banks are lined with trees - preferably cedar or mangrove. Moor with bow and stern lines fastened to the lower branches; if possible snug up with good chafing gear. The knees of trees will act as fenders and the branches, having more give, will ease shocks in gusts. Keep clear of tall pines as they have shallow roots and are more apt to be blown down."
Fishing vessels possessing the necessary local navigational knowledge employ these methods among some of the uninhabited mangrove-covered keys.

Maybe I'm wrong, but in lala land I would think you sit around and say, "Nothing we can do". In the real world where people take care of themselves and protected their property you seek out and find a safe mooring.

I will also ask again Why keep a boat in a known hurricane high risk area and not have a plan in place to protect that boat.
 
I NEVER said "nothing i can do"... I said there are no safe harbor in SE FL therefore the best plan is for the boat not to be in the area directly affected by a hurricane... that is typicaly a 75miles area.

indeed in the florida keys, many of the commercial guys tie up in channels in the mangrove. The upper keys are 40 miles from here so... if I'm going to head south, it is because of storm coming up here not in the keys, so i'll be fine anchored out or docked in the midlekeys... I'm not going to head south to the keys for a storm threatening the keys which will have minimal impact up here.. one major problem with mangrove channel is the domino effect. One guy gets loose and everybody ends up sunk an the end of the channel...

most of the commercial fishermen next to my dock tie bow first on some of the spoil islands... that's fine for a glancing blow, not for a direct hit as the wind shift will drive them on these islands.

others go up the river and tie alongside freighters and other fishing boats... not an option for a pleasure boat unless you want to have to repaint the entire boat afterward...
 
Back
Top