my original question was to understand why woudl they install tall piling then cut the top 6' ! i suspected a leverage issue but i'm not convince. Water getting caught on top, where they bang it into the bottom, makes sense although they could just cut the top 6" and put a cap on it.
About hurricane tactics, it's easy to say "move to a safe harbor" but it's a little harder to actually define "safe harbor" and much harder to actually find one, at least around here.
maybe up in the Northern Gulf you have fewer boats and many holes up the bayous and bays but here we don't. We've also lost something like 50% of boat yards in the past 5 to 10 years so there are few spots to haul out...
so best option is to move the boat out of the danger area. It requires some planning but mostly good timing. you have a very narrow window to get moving between the time where you can make the North/South decision and when bridges are locked down for evacs. In most cases, you dont' need to very far, 50, 75 miles is more than enough to be away from the dangerous core of a storm. I've done this a few times in the past and its the best option. However there are some instances where you have nowhere to go, like in case of a storm coming from the south along the coast...
If you have no choice but keeping the boat in its slip, there are a number of factors that can help minimize the risk and damage.
- multiple lines, chaffing gear, and spreading the loads on multiple cleats and pilings.
- wide slips so that the boat will not bang into the pilings.
- tall pilings to eliminates the chances of the boat coming back down on the pilings...
I didn't make this up, it's not just common sense but the recommendation with everyone with experience starting with insurers who have a lot of experience in observing what works and what didn't
Katrina and Wilma were minor storms and i stayed on board. During wilma (highest recorded gust a few miles from here was 97kts) i got a few scratches below the rub rail because the pilings didn't even extend to the rub rail at the peak of the storm surge. If that piling had been a little higher, i woudln't have had any damage at. In another spot, i got a small section of bent stainless steel rubrail because the piling caught it underneath. Minor stuff but if the slip had been a foot wider and the piling taller i woudnt' even have gotten a single scratch.
there were a number of boats with rub rail damage in the marina, some with holes, but in most cases the damage came from the pilings catching the rub rails from underneath, not from the rubbing although i agree that even the toughest rub rail will not last forever while rubbing against a piling. However, a hole at the rub rail is much better than a hole below waterline which one of cause of totalled boats in their slips.
so i found it surprising that they'd cut the top 5 or 6' of new pilings...
as to boats being washed ashore with with the pilings still attached, no.. havent see that in person... but i've seen boats damaged because one piling failed or boats where the owners had to run the engine to stay off the dock after one of their only two pilings failed. Thats why i was wondering about leverage... and again, this is where slip layout is important... and why blanket statement like " Any person foolish enough to keep a boat moored in a boat slip, in an marina during a Hurricane deserves exactly what occurs." is just plain stupid. Some slips are safer than others.
if you have only one pair of pilings at the bow, you're at risk. If you have a total of 3 pairs of pilings, one at the bow and two amidship, you can spread the loads and divide the stress on the pilings, lines and cleats by 3.
you don't have to be a rocket scientist to see that your odds are much better...