PLB or SPOT?

Monobill

Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2005
RO Number
19543
Messages
10
Hey guys, question. For several years I have been renting a PLB (McMurdo) when taking vacation and going fishing off shore. Rented because of the $+700 price. Now I see there is a product, SPOT satellite messenger that looks to have the same abilities.

I am looking for comparisons in the two units. You do not need to tell me, ……if you're bobbing in the ocean the $700 would not be questioned. But considering we only go out in the best of conditions and then only a couple days a year I am thinking about owning the $150 SPOT as the better option. Not to mention renting the McMurdo option is no longer avalible.
 
I do not have a PLB but I do have a SPOT and a ACR EPIRB. I find the two devices to serve totally different purposes in my case. The EPIRB is clearly a rescue device. When the going get's tough; activate the EPIRB and get in the raft. AS far as the spot I use it as a way to let people on shore know that things are alright. Almost like an electronic float plan. I have the optional tracking service that allow anyone on shore to go to a webpage and see where we are; really nice for fishing and cruising.

For some reason I do not have the same confidence in the SPOT as I do my EPIRB; but at the same time it has never failed and works as advertised every time I have used it; at the same time I have no idea of my EPIRB actually works. I assume it does but the idea of testing it and getting the coast guard instead if I don't do it correctly does not sound like that much fun.

I hope this helps.
 
I don't have SPOT on my boat, but I did have a Globalstar sat-phone and it was terrible very intermitant service. I do understand SPOT works different than their sat-phones. I know people using SPOT and it appears to work fine. I carry 2 EPIRB's and 2 PLB's. I have more confidence in the EPIRB's database and it is specifically for emergencies with all the contact information that is needed in an emergency at the proper authorities database. My wife and I each have the PLB's on our Mustang life vests along with a waterproof VHF radio. One EPIRB is at the helm and the other with the life raft. We feel relatively safe with the combination. One other point the EPIRB's and PLB's do not require a subscription fee, SPOT does require a fee.
Bill
 
I think all of you are correct. From the research I have done and review from owners the quality and most important dependability of the SPOT is in serious question for an emergency device. I don’t need it for just letting people know where I have been. Need it most when all the backups have failed fails and it is time to swim or climb up into the raft!

Looks like the PLB is a minimal and EPIRB would even be better. The fine company Liferaftrental.com whom I have rented from in the past is no longer renting either. Must say they gave excellent service in the past three years, very sorry to learn they are no longer renting.

Any recommendation of dependable company where PLB can be rented for a couple weeks? The reason I have never purchased one in the past is because the batteries have a shelf life of 5 years (don’t think replaceable?) and as I said at best only need it couple weeks a year.
 
We have a PLB in the Ditch bag

You can get a ACR RESQFIX PLB 406 WITH GPS at BoatFix for less than $560.

Spot seems like a nice to have where as EPIRB or PLB is a must
 
Back
Top