portable generator concerns

TIC

Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
RO Number
29813
Messages
295
Our boat is a Glastron GS-259 "pocket cruiser" that has AC and reverse cycle heat, microwave, stovetop, fridge etc. etc... No generator option and no room in the engine compartment to put one so we bought a honda 2000 portable that will run the heat/ac and I've been bungie cording it to the swim platform.. We do have a CO detector in the V-berth but I'm wondering how "safe" the practice of using a portable generator is.. Any comments, suggestions or real world experience is welcomed.. Typically with the generator on the swim platform and the camper canvas up I think we are pretty isolated from any CO concerns but I'm just a little nervous about staking our lives on the wind direction and the CO detector... When you have a dedicated genset in the engine compartment, is it that much "safer" than what we are doing?
 
TIC ... I use the Honda 2000 as well, however I do not run it while we are asleep ... I get the cabin as cool as I can before going to sleep, then shut it down and use a 12V fan to move air. Also do not allow anyone to swin near the swim platforn when the generator is running. That's my 2 cents worth, I'm sure there will be many who will say it's OK to run them all night on the swim platform.
 
We do the same thing, but would never take the chance of running it all night.
 
I've had my Honda 2000 for years and also put it on the swim platform without any problems. I will not use it at night when sleeping. It's nice to have during the day when we are on the hook.
 
We also use a 2000 although it won't handle our A/C. Most would suggest not running it during the night while sleeping. Also redundant CO detectors are a good idea. I think if you keep it on the swim platform and only run it at anchor or on a mooring when you will generally head up into a breeze it is safe. But you'll find a lot of folk on this board who will disagree.
 
Anyone have a picture of how they place and secure the Generator on the swim platform?

Joe
 
I don't have any pics but I'll get some next time we are out.. Basically just two bungie cords going through the handle of the Honda 2000 and around the Stainless handle on the transom used for getting out of the water via the swim ladder.. It seems very secure and the generator has nice shock absorbing rubber feet, very little vibration comes through the boat.. I was thrilled when I found out this little generator WILL run our heat/AC. The generator can't operate in quiet mode to do this and the starts bog the engine a little but it's yet to stall or shut itself off in protection mode.. The generator cost around $875.00.. When I see the price of factory installed gensets,I'm actually very happy for the small inconvenience of having to lug the portable around. We have not let it run through the night and I don't think it would run all night anyway, it would run out of gas. I believe it will run around 4 hours on a gallon of gasoline, which is what it holds.
 
I'm certainly not an expert on this subject. My marine generator's exhaust is the same as my outsite starboard motor's exhaust, under the swim platform. There is alot of freeboard between the swim platform and the inside deck of the boat.
 
Be careful of traveling with it on the platform. A quick stop or a following sea will swamp it easily making it virtually "junk"
 
Hello,

I too would like to see if a Honda 2000 or a pair of em could run my AC that would be awesome. Is there a plug that goes from the Honda portable to your shore power cord recepticle, and then the AC then thinks it is on shore power? Is that how that works. I would not recommend sleeping with that thing either (and you indicate you wont and cant due to the limited amount of gas). I would just use it to bring the temp down every couple of hours or to use the microwave. I know alot of people on the board dont like the honda but for some it the only feasible economical option. Please be safe and check the wind and keep the CO monitor in the right place.
 
There have been deaths using this machine and ones like it. Deaths proximately related to the installation.

One death incident we have first hand knowlege of here caused by a raft up that trapped/funnelled the fumes between boats (thus the prevailing wind was disturbed and also the boats could not swing naturally). At Night. Inop/missing CO monitors.

Another we heard of here first hand that was a close call due to station wagon effect (running). Inop/missing CO monitors.

Another near miss related to running one on a dock, at night. The boat not able to swing in the wind.

A number of instances where CO monitors did not function properly (though there were no incidents as a result). Sometimes failed batteries. Sometimes failed detector itself.

Bottom line, for many like you there may not be opportunity to boat without one due to the heat. While I have been on the "do not do" end of using non-marine gas generators, I think it can be safely done IF you plan for wind direction and IF you have working CO monitors and IF you don't rely solely on the devices but also use the fuzzy grey matter between your ears. I'm also convinced that most people these days have become accustomed to safety being a "built in" feature of every device in modern living and are often unable to devise their own safety plan if the device does not do it for them. For this reason, my generic response to these devices is "They are not safe", even if someone asked me the question while I happened to be duct taping one down somewhere for myself.

I would never recommend sleeping with one.

So use appropriate judgement, based on the fundamentals of CO and its danger points.

Don't listen to any advice just because they used the line "I've done this a million times and never had a problem" (you only need to have a problem once and just because it has not happened yet does not mean it won't or couldn't).

Don't breed a false sense of security by comparing your success from one set of environmental variables to another you have not experienced previously.

Don't sleep with one.

Have a plan to avoid station wagon effect and means to detect it.

Have a plan to avoid sleeping while running (people sleep in the daytime too).

Have a plan of what to do when there is NO wind to ventilate the area and a means of detecting the problem.

Have a plan for knowing whether your CO monitors are working.

It's your families lives at risk for a recreational activity. Set your risk level accordingly.
 
A while back I read a post (can't find it) that had a link to a national database describing by state deaths that have occurred using portable or engine compartment generators. The latter causing the most fatalities when people in water or on swim platform when running either generators or engines. What was startling was the number of and fact it only take about a minute or two to be overcome.
 
Well,this is why I posted.. I know a portable generator is nothing to be taken lightly when it comes to enclosed spaces. I appreciate all the feedback..
 
I use my portable generator on a 27' boat through the night.
That being said.I lock and tighten all windows and button up the cabin.I always test my marine CO detector.The marine co detector is not as sensitive as a home unit,so I also have two of these on board V berth and aft cabin,the home units are extremely sensitive.The direct wired unit is in the middle.I take every precaution,including facing the exhaust down wind.I have never had an alarm go off or any other issues running it at night.
You can also buy an extended run fuel tank which will run for many hours.The EU 2000 will run about 6 hours on econo mode without an extended fuel tank.
 
I just had the generator replaced in my boat. Westerbeke has a nice 3.0 kw with a very small foot print. After further investigation I had room for a 5kw. Check out the dimensions. You may be able to fit one in after all. Honda also offers a portable 3000 model which I considered myself.Very interesting topic. I cant believe how much I have learned on this site.
 
We often run our generator all night to power the air conditioner on our cuddy. The generator is the red unit (with blue splash cover) on the stern.
IMG_1465.jpg


I like the CO detectors that have a digital readout so you can see even the slightest amount of CO rather than just waiting for an alarm.
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0007ZYU7C?smid=ATVPDKIKX0DER&tag=pricegrabber2-tools-20&linkCode=asn
 
While this is a usually a much debated topic on here here is what I have done for 3 years.

I have a 250CR Crownline.I have a 7500BTU ac/heat.I also run the 2000 Honda.It runs everything at once except the water heater(never use it anyways) on ECO mode.When the AC cycles on it will bump the Honda up a second then level off to just above idle.I can set my AC to cycle every 10- 15 minutes or so and it will run for about 8-10 hours easily on one tank along with the batt. charger and fridge.It's hot down here when I use the AC.Usually 80 plus at night and humid.

I'm not sure how you run a full tank of gas out in 4 hrs but the little Honda will run 5-6 hours wide open on a full tank.You might want to check into that 4 hour thing.

I mount mine a little different.I hang mine from the bow pulpit railing and run my shore power cord down the rail to my dock outlet.I use 4 of those heavy black rubber straps wrapped around the handle and hooked to the railing.You can try all you want to move it but you won't.I wouldn't drive the boat of course like this.Only time I use the Honda is on the hook.

I have a Co in front berth and aft cabin mid to low height and all windows closed.Even so the Honda is nowhere near a pocket area or vent entrance.Plus I keep the AC mode set to have the fan constant.

It's a little tricky to set-up but far from hard.When we go out we are there for 3-4 days without moving.It is out of the way and runs perfectly in all weather.I also hang my 5gal off the rail away from the Honda.Zero vibration of course is a bonus.It is off the deck by about 6-8 inches.
 
I stand corrected on the fuel consumption of the honda 2000 as well as the output... Running some quick math shows it should NOT run the heat/ac in eco mode but I'll certainly try it if it works for others! Does it automatically ramp up to full throttle when the AC starts?.. I ballparked the fuel consumption but I'll aslo take 5-6 hours over 4 hours!... In any case, it's a great little unit.. If it runs our AC in eco mode I'll be thrilled as eco mode is MUCH quieter!
 
Just got my Honda 2000 this week. Was going to use it to run the A/C while on the hook but now i am having second thoughts. I figure that with 2 wired CO detectors and 2 portable that would be safe along with the generator on the swim platform. Now I am thinking would it be safer to leave the generator on my raft, floating behind the boat. We anchor in a totally protected cove no waves or swell at all. What do you think is this a bad idea.
Al
 
Back
Top