Portable GPS

Rugger8

Member
exMember
Joined
Dec 4, 2006
RO Number
24444
Messages
231
Just starting to look into this now, but figured there are likely some experienced hands with this. I am trying to find a portable GPS/Chartplotter that I can use both on the water, but also on land in a car. Additionally, I would like one with the capability to access info for roads in Canada, Mexico, and the US, but also for Europe. Does anyone have any suggestions for this and is there a model that can do all of this in one unit?

Thanks,
 
We have a Garmin 276 and love it (now the backup on the boat and used in the car). It's newer equivalent is the 476 I believe. Will do charts and raod maps.
 
I do it with a PDA. I use ALK CoPilot Live with Bluetooth GPS on the road. They sell Canadian and European licenses also. I then use Maptech Pocket Navigator loaded with the Maptech Boating Chart DVD for on the water. The ALK hardware and software is about $250 and European package an extra $50. The Maptech is $39 for Pocket Navigator and $39 for chart DVD. The Bluetooth GPS head works for both. Of course you've got to buy the PDA if you don't have one, but I use it for email, compass deviation spreadsheet, RPM and fuel management spreadsheet, and other stuff also.
 
I have the Garmin 478, works for both land and coastal. It has been great, but it is much more complicated to use on the road than a simple auto nav unit is. Might want to consider a dedicated unit for the car -- they are so brain-dead simple to use.
 
I agree with JoeBTB - you're better off with separate units.

Garmin makes a combo unit, but the screen is really too small to be useful on a boat (speaking from experience - not just theory). There are too many buttons to make it easy to use in the car (lots of distractions) and are just not as capable as newer dedicated car units.

I have a Garmin 4208 for my boat, and just bought a Garmin nuvi 660 for my car. IMO, a decent screen size is critical for a useful device on a boat. .

I went with the nuvi 660 model because it will provide traffic alerts and reroute you to avoid problems. The nuvi is really very, very easy to use and fully featured for land-based navigation. The touch-screen capability is key to it's simple operation. The 660 is pre-loaded with North American maps and points of interest; you can buy additional maps for other regions. Or the nuvi 670 is the same hardware but is pre-loaded with both North American and European data.
 
How do you like the 4208 versus earlier Garmins? I'm considering replacing my 2010C with a 4212.

(And I agree with separate units for boat and car - the demands are just too different.)
 
I also have a Garmin 478. I was disappointed last week to discover that the "preloaded" charts DO NOT include much of Canada. I called Tech support to confirm that since this is my 3rd Garmin, I will have to purchase those elec charts AGAIN to unlock them on the 478. (doesn't seem right?)

I use it in the car as well, but I agree, it can be a distraction. I mostly use it for ETA info and for re-routing me around construction zones.
 
Alright everybody, that helps alot. I will look into the separate units, just figured before I did that I would see if it made sense to do a combined GPS. Time to go shopping.
 
A brief dissent. We have the Garmin 478 and use it in the car regularly. I think it does a good job with directions and is fairly easy to program/use. The voice commands are pretty well thought out too, meaning they give you enough advance notice to plan for turns etc. We just spent a weekend on our boat with it and it was fine. Admittedly, we have a 23 footer so a couple hour trip is the limit, but on the dash in front of me the screen is fine and it very clearly delineates the channel, if I am in it, provides other detail if requested. I think the 478 is down under $800 at this point, so to get both a car and marine unit for that seemed like a good deal to me.
 
Let me clarify: I'm certainly not unhappy with my 478, in fact, I love it. The screen is small, but definitely adequate for how I use my boat. I especially love that I can move it between helms without turning it off. It came with multiple mounts, so I can pop it in a mount at either helm or in the car without a problem.

My suggestion for considering the separate car unit is because I think they're inexpensive, and the one I saw had a super simple touch screen that is easier to use than the 478 for auto nav. But 4roys is right, the voice commands, mapping, etc on the road are all nicely done.
 
lol I was going to post the same thing!

I'm not at all unhappy with my 478 and it's been very useful in the car. However, my bro-in-law recently bought a Nuvi and for automotive use, the Nuvi has a decided edge.
 
Back
Top