Power Winch Setup

seagazan

Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2007
RO Number
28612
Messages
7
I realize that most people favor bunk trailers, but I have a 25 ft roller trailer with a Power Winch. The boat weighs 5,150 lbs dry.

Recently, my 5 year old cable snapped just after I connected my safety chain. Although I'm not sure how common a broken cable is, I really don't want this to happen again. I've started brainstorming if there is anything preventative I can do by searching the Internet and checking the Power Winch installation manual. Here are three areas that may help, but I'm not sure how much impact they might have on relieving the stress on the cable and winch. I am very interested in collecting the thoughts of others on these topics.

1) The Power Winch is about 7 inches from the bow eye and my bow eye is pulled snug against the bow roller when fully loaded. The winch installation manual says that it should be no less than 12". In order to get 12 inches, I'll need to extend the bow roller arm a few inches, which will push the boat back on the trailer, lessen the tongue weight, and leave the bow eye a few inches below the bow roller. Will the extra 5 inches be worth it and buy me more safety in towing and/or less stress on the cable?

2) The boat weight and size are within the range of the winch and cable. I have a single line pull set-up. A double-line set-up would double my line pull capacity and probably ease the stress on the cable and winch. In order to do this I would need to get at least the 12" I discussed in item #1 to have space for the pulley. Will there really be a significant difference in safety and stress by moving to a double-line pull?

3) I use the Power Winch cable and safety chain to secure the boat at the bow. I also have transom tie-down straps. The Power Winch manual says that I should have a bow-tie down strap to secure the boat so that I can remove the cable for trailering. I just can't imagine that a 2" tie-down strap is going to be better than the cable so it seems that I would be sacrificing safety on this one. Do others use a bow-tie down as the primary device to secure the boat or do most use the cable as the primary means?

Basically, before I replace the cable I'm trying to decide if I make any changes to the Power Winch setup or not. Of course my goal is to load the boat and trailer easily with optimal saftety.

Thanks.
 
the last time i used a powerwich on a trailer has been many many years...so bear with me.

we used to always...always keep the cable greased. we used to go 10+ years on a cable. we would always take the tension off the winch once up the ramp. basically a line from one bow cleat around the trailer to the other bow cleat was common practice.

i have also seen alot of folks switch to the strap instead of cable, i do not have a powerwinch but use a strap on my hand winch for my little boat ...25' mako.
 
I have only had cable and rope (yes that long ago!!). If I had my druthers, I would go to a strap on the winch. I prefer them, only because after being on the water all day, any fray in the cable is going into your hand and those damn things hurt! A good size eye bolt through the winch stanchion with a short ratcheting tie down strap should allow you to keep it snug. This would be in addition to your safety chain. The setup would allow you to take a bit of tension off the winch while underway or in storage.
 
After I attach the bow tie-down strap, I release the tension (but don't unhook) the winch strap/cable, so there's no stress on it when traveling. I still leave the bow eye snap attached, so the winch can be a "back-up" in case the tie-down strap fails for any reason.

On a side note --If you don't need the 30 or 40 feet of cable that comes with the PowerWinch, you can get more power out of the winch by replacing your long cable with a shorter one. As a cable gets wound in more and more, the spool of cable gets fatter and fatter, and the winch has less mechanical advatage as the spool gets fuller and fatter. A shorter cable will fatten the spool by a smaller amount, and your winch will have more mechanical advantage if it is less full of cable, and therefore has less effective diameter.
Also, the optional pulley block system should nearly double the winch's pulling power. These methods, howerver, do not increase the strength of the cable itself. Only helps the winch motor's pulling ability.

I wouldn't mess with changing the boat postion/tongue weight, unless it needs to be changed anyway. Probably can't use the pulley with the close winch stand. I have the same problem. -- Bow too close to winch stand.
 
I use a Power Winch on a 6000lb Formula. I get the boat within a foot or so of the stop with power, then crank the rest of the way by hand. I just don't like the sound of the motor cranking up that last foot. And with a large winch handle, manually finishing the job isn't too bad.

Once ready to tow, I leave the Power Winch cable snugged tight until I reach my destination. The boat bounces around if I simply rely on the safety chain. Once at my destination I release tension on the cable until I'm ready to trailer again.

I have used this system for the past ten years and it has served me well. If Power Winch offered a strap for my application I would certainly consider it. Was the chain rusted before it broke? When mine got a little rusty I changed it. The idea of a shorter cable intrigues me. I may try that, too.

Peter
 
You may want to try adding pieces of white plastic 1/2inch thick by 2 or 3 inches wide (recycled milk cartons I think) to the front portions of your bunks. I did this and it really helped reduce the friction of pulling on my 31 foot boat. After installing it I find I can pull it right up to the bow stops with a hand winch. The plastic is available from trailer supply stores and is very inexpensive. Tom
 
I used a power winch for years, never a problem.

Used the double line pull, as it was easier on the winch.
Always used a ratchet strap to snug the boat up against the stop, never relied on the winch to hold it fast.

And I was more worried about how the boat was loaded not how far the winch was from the stop.

Good Luck.

Jim

2004 420 DA
 
IMG_2075.jpg
 
I resently switched from a power winch ST712 (strap) to an RC30 (cable). The ST didn't have quite enough power to completely pull in a 4500 lb boat on a roller trailer at the ramp we use.

Strap PROS- no wires to fray

cons- its a special strap (expensive) only available from power winch.Can't be used with a pully. I've replaced it.Its not easy.

wire PROS Cheap and easy to get anywhere.
can be used with a pully.
easier to replace.

cons - can fray.

If the strap gets twisted and gets a crease in it. It has trouble laying flat as it winds in.

Anyone intrested in a used ST712 ???

If there is a chance that you may need more pulling power, then the cable gives you that option. If the ST712 is good enough, then the strap is easier on the hands.

I also leave the winch tight and use a rachet tie down. The rachet alone will let the bow bounce some. It will never hold it as tight as the winch.

Just what works for me.
 
SvedasFish

PLease give us more details about your ST712 - condition, age and asking price?

Thanks

DC
 
dc_gentry

I'll take some pix of it and send them to your email. I think the forum is not supposed to be used for posting items for sale.

Bill
 
I really appreciate everyone's comments.

After some consideration and speaking with a trailer shop and Power Winch service dealer, I decided to make three general adjustments.

First, I left the boat in its present position on the trailer and moved the bow roller down(bolt holes for two different angles were available) and winch stand forward on the trailer tongue to get two more inches between the bow eye and the winch.

Second, after loading the new 50 foot cable, I installed a dual-line pulley leveraging the instructions I got from the service dealer. Interestingly, the trailer shop told me to do a dual-line pull and wrap the end of the cable around the base of the winch stand creating a large angle between the two lines. The service dealer and installation manual said that the cable should be as close as possible to parallel. I ignored the trailer shop's advice and ran the cable through the bottom of the winch itself and looped it around the top of the winch stand. The end of the cable is now hooked at the top of the winch stand near the safety chain.

Third, I purchased a ratchet tie-down and connected it from the bow eye to the base of the winch stand.

Though I didn't have any problems for four years, I'm probably just lucky. I didn't lubricate the cable at least annually per the manufacturer's guidelines. I had a single-line pull when I likely exceeded the strength of the winch. Lastly, I relied on the winch's clutches too much with respect to keeping the boat secure on the trailer.

I'm looking forward to going out again to see how much difference these changes will make when loading and trailering the boat.

Thanks.
 
Back
Top