Problems Bedding Portlights

douglee25

Member
Joined
Jan 9, 2008
RO Number
29196
Messages
337
About 3 - 4 weeks ago I rebedded 3 windows on my boat. I used 3M 4200 which cost me damn near $20 bucks per tube. Nevertheless, on 2 out of the 3 windows, the sealant has actually pulled away from the window causing them to leak. Usually with bedding adhesive, one would screw the window in say 85% of the way, let the sealant dry, then tighten the screws then rest of the way. This method can't be used on this style window though. The way these windows are designed, they bolt in from the inside and then on the outside the sealant is just applied between the window and the outer trim ring.

Has anyone ever experienced this? Is it possible that the tube of sealant was sitting on the shelf for a while and has gone bad?

I resorted to regular silicone caulk on one window as a test this evening. Will it last since it's above the water line? Buy a new tube of 3M 4200 and redo them all again?

Any advice would be great. Thanks again.

Doug
 
if they has silicone originally nothing else will stick, it is terrible stuff
 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

if they has silicone originally nothing else will stick, it is terrible stuff






The originaly stuff I pulled out appeared to be 4200. Why would nothing else stick if silicone was used originally?

Doug
 
Cause nothing absolutely nothing except silicone sticks to silicone.
 
I did remove all the original adhesive plus I used some sandpaper to roughen up the surfaces before I used the 3M 4200.

Doug
 
very hard to get off.
if you spray water on it you will see where it doesn’t stick
 
That's one of the problems with using silicon sealants: enough remains behind to keep anything from sticking there again unless you are very careful to get all of the old silicon off. I like using polyurethane sealants and adhesives on the boat like Sikaflex 291LOT and 3M 4200/5200. Sikaflex 291LOT is a long time favorite of mine. It doesn't shrink very much and I've used it on just about everything without primers.

I looked up the data sheet for 3M Marine Adhesive/Sealant Fast Cure 4200. 3M suggests priming some metals with Scotch-Weld Structural Adhesive Primer EC-1945 B/A prior to using 3M 4200. 3M also recommends cleaning all surfaces with 3M General Purpose Adhesive Cleaner and prepping with 180-220 grit sandpaper prior to bedding with 3M 4200.

p.s. I've used Sikaflex 291LOT with success on wood, glass, paint, varnish, stainless steel, aluminum, copper, bronze, just about everything except fiberglass (which isn't on the boat).
 
quote:

Originally posted by yzer

That's one of the problems with using silicon sealants: enough remains behind to keep anything from sticking there again unless you are very careful to get all of the old silicon off. I like using polyurethane sealants and adhesives on the boat like Sikaflex 291LOT and 3M 4200/5200. Sikaflex 291LOT is a long time favorite of mine. It doesn't shrink very much and I've used it on just about everything without primers.

I looked up the data sheet for 3M Marine Adhesive/Sealant Fast Cure 4200. 3M suggests priming some metals with Scotch-Weld Structural Adhesive Primer EC-1945 B/A prior to using 3M 4200. 3M also recommends cleaning all surfaces with 3M General Purpose Adhesive Cleaner and prepping with 180-220 grit sandpaper prior to bedding with 3M 4200.

p.s. I've used Sikaflex 291LOT with success on wood, glass, paint, varnish, stainless steel, aluminum, copper, bronze, just about everything except fiberglass (which isn't on the boat).






Thanks for the advice. I too looked up the data sheet on 4200 prior to using it. I used acetone to clean the parts and followed up with sandpaper to scuff the surface. The trim ring is definitely stainless but I did not prime it.

Since the window is above the water line, do you see anything wrong with using a standard household caulk?

Doug
 
I've had good results with mastic tape (gorilla snot), the kind they use to bed automotive windshields. It's available almost everywhere and is cheap and it works. Once you get the port bedded on the stuff you can dress up the edges with 4200 etc. I once pulled a windshield out of a 1956 Crown Vic and the mastic they used to bed the windshield was just like new and stuck like a fly on a turd! Sorry, poor analogy but you get the idea.
 
Doug,

I would suggest that you go to www.marineformula.com and purchase some of their cleaner. Use as directed, including wiping with alcohol after cleaning.

After cleaning, I would suggest sealing with another silicone or polyurethane as yzer suggests. The only problem with 3M 4200 and 5200 is that they have poor UV stability.

Let me dispell the myth that you can't seal a joint with another type of sealant once a silicone is used. That isn't the case. You do have to make sure the silicone is completely removed or you need to use a primer. I've spent over 35 years working in the sealant and adhesive industry.

You didn't mention if the 4200 released from the window frame or the fiberglass. Also, does the window have a flange onto which the sealant can be applied. Is the 4200 bead a fillet bead only? Additional detail would help us to pinpoint the problem.

Bob
 
Rick: How do i find that stuff. The local store sent me to the zoo when i asked for gorilla snot.
 
Douglee25,

Is the trim ring held in place by the sealant? If so could the trim ring have be bent during removal and no longer fit the hull contour? That might explain why the sealant won't hold it flat against the hull. Just a wild shot but something you might want to check if you haven't already do so.

Steven
 
Are you sure its a sealant issue.

That style will leak if you did not caulk between the "ring" and the "portlight" The ring needs to be sealed "bonded" to the port light section that comes through the "hull". or it will leak.
 
You have all brought up some good points, although I have looked into much of them already.

To give you all a better understanding of the window setup on the boat, see the pics below. The trim ring is inserted and bonded prior to the window itself. The ring goes from the outside towards inside. Tabs are bent inwards and then they are screwed behind the cabin wall covering. These have not been touched so I'm sure they aren't bent or tweaked. When the window is inserted from the inside towards the outside, there is a 1/4" gap around the frame of the window and the stainless trim ring. The caulking material is then injected between the two surfaces and finally smoothed with your finger. The 4200 that I originally used sealed fine against the trim ring, but is pulling away from the plastic window frame.

Doug

7f2.jpg


d3d.jpg
 
One issue not mentioned above is that all of these sealants have shelf life, and many stores do not rotate stock adequately, this is especially true with silicones, as well as the polyurethanes. Read the label! Over-shelf-life silicone or silicone that has been subjected to a lot of heat will sometimes gun out OK, but never cure,,,

For cleaning where silicone has been or will be used, we prefer to use IPA (isopropyl alcohol) as it does not leave a film. This is after sanding the area to be bonded first.

Good Luck,
Fred
.
 
Doug,

Let's see if I have this right. You have a stainless trim ring that was bonded to the hull with 3M 4200. When you insert the window from the inside there is a 1/4" gap between the stainless trim ring and plastic window frame which has to be sealed with caulking, to effect a seal. The 4200 is releasing from the plastic frame.

Did the portlight manufacturer issue instructions and sealant suggestions? You might have an adhesion issue with the 4200 and the plastic window frame. Do you know the composition of the window frame? In most instances, when plastic is injection molded, a release agent is used as a mold release. This could be a potential problem.

The 1/4" gap that you need to seal is quite large for 4200 to be used effectively, in my opinion. The 4200 does not have sufficient elongation properties to hold up over time. You would be better off with a silicone.

I would find out from the manufacturer what the plastic window frame is made of, what products they suggest as a sealant, and if the frame needs to be solvent wiped prior to sealing.

Bob
 
quote:

Originally posted by BobV1

Doug,

Let's see if I have this right. You have a stainless trim ring that was bonded to the hull with 3M 4200. When you insert the window from the inside there is a 1/4" gap between the stainless trim ring and plastic window frame which has to be sealed with caulking, to effect a seal. The 4200 is releasing from the plastic frame.

Did the portlight manufacturer issue instructions and sealant suggestions? You might have an adhesion issue with the 4200 and the plastic window frame. Do you know the composition of the window frame? In most instances, when plastic is injection molded, a release agent is used as a mold release. This could be a potential problem.

The 1/4" gap that you need to seal is quite large for 4200 to be used effectively, in my opinion. The 4200 does not have sufficient elongation properties to hold up over time. You would be better off with a silicone.

I would find out from the manufacturer what the plastic window frame is made of, what products they suggest as a sealant, and if the frame needs to be solvent wiped prior to sealing.

Bob






Bob, you are 100% correct. I did check Bomar's website prior to install and they said consult 3M, Boatlife, etc for the correct sealant. I called Bomar just now and the tech rep said that it's possible that a polysulfide based product may attack the plastic portlight. They are going to have the technical sales rep call me tomorrow to see if he can provide some insight. I also checked 3M 4200's tech sheet and it states on there that it will not bond to nylon, polyethylene, vinyl, or EPDM rubber.

I also read this...

"Fast Cure 4200 is not recommended for the installation of glass, polycarbonate or acrylic windows that
are not also mechanically fastened. Inconsistent adhesion of these unprimed substrates, specific design
of the window and movement due to thermal expansion and flexing, may cause application failure."

http://multimedia.3m.com/mws/mediawebserver?66666UuZjcFSLXTtlx&EoXMtEVuQEcuZgVs6EVs6E666666--

Interesting.

DOug
 
Doug,

It sounds as though you're moving in the right direction.

If you decide to use a silicone sealant for your portlights, there are two predominant types of silicones available to the public (acetoxy or neutral cure). The neutral cure will usually cost a little more, but they will adhere better to a greater number of substrates, including plastics. The acetoxy cure smells like vinegar and will not bond as well to plastics. The manufacturers will list the type of cure on the label.

Bob
 
Doug,

An alternative to silicone sealants that I have found very useful for general marine caulking above the waterline and prefer to silicone are the silyl-modified polyurethanes. They seem shrink appreciably less than straight silicones over time, bond well to plastics and gelcoat as well as metals, and are as easy to use and clean-up. Two brands I have had success with are Life Seal (not caulk) from Boat Life and Bostik 960 SR.
 
Last month I installed this bomar portlight. It was recommended I use Boatseal. Made by BoatLife its a polyurethane/silicone blend with some of the benefits of both. So far it has worked well and I like the adhesive abilities over straight silicone.

IMG_0428.jpg
 
Back
Top