Progressive Insurance

jim conroy

Member
exMember
Joined
Mar 2, 2000
RO Number
59
Messages
162
We had a relatively new 40 ft Chris Craft sink at the dock this fall.

The cause seems to be that muskrats chewed through an exhaust connection.

This in itself is not too unusual, but now I hear that the owner is left holding the bag because Progressive Insurance won't pay. Seems that they have a clause excluding that type of damage.

Wow, bummer, the poor owner (I know if he had taken better care of his boat...started the engines, inspected it....)(perhaps there was a personal problem that kept him away) anyway his boat is trashed (although it was freshwater) and he is without insurance.

I'm checking my policy.

Jim

2004 420 Dancer
 
1) Be sure to read and understand your insurance policy. Not all are the same, and never ( rather, extremely rarely ) is "everything" covered.

2) Read (1) again.

3) Insurance is -not- a maintenance contract. It is intended to provide coverage for rare, unavoidable, difficult to prevent, catastrophic, loss.

4) Read (1) above, again.

--

Sorry to hear about his loss, however.
 
An exhaust connection ? Did the muskrat climb into the boat ? Into the sxhaust pipe ?
 
"

Posted - Dec 15 2008 : 21:25:21 Show Profile Email Poster Reply with Quote
We had a relatively new 40 ft Chris Craft sink at the dock this fall.

The cause seems to be that muskrats chewed through an exhaust connection.

This in itself is not too unusual, but now I hear that the owner is left holding the bag because Progressive Insurance won't pay. Seems that they have a clause excluding that type of damage."

Is this rumor or did the owner of the boat personally tell you that these are the facts? And explain any mitigating circumstances.

Bobalong's question is very valid.

G
 
quote:

Originally posted by bobalong

An exhaust connection ? Did the muskrat climb into the boat ? Into the sxhaust pipe ?






Oh yes. I have seen it happen on a number of occassions. They are very polite. They ask permission to come aboard, then either remove thier little muskrat shoes or put on footies. They are as cute as a Gecko....NOT!!

It is not uncommon for a snake or other creature to crawl in the exhaust of vessels where I am.

I agree bobalong's question is valid. If the boat came equipped from the factory as it was when it sank and met ABYC and NMMA standards, I don't see where progressive can deny a claim unless it is esplecit in the contract.

================================

EDIT ADD!!!!!!
I stand corrected.

Exclusions. Part IV para 9 subpara g: "insects, amimals, vermin or marine life."

Time to start shopping.
 
Muskrats are prime fur down here. There isn't many around where we boat.
Like most animals down here, if we don't eat them, we wear them.
When they see people, they haul a$$ so as not to be shot.
 
From what I am told by management of the marina and the service dept this is indeed fact.
I do know nor have spoken to the owner.

Muskrats climb in the exhaust system (on diesels) through the discharge port.
They work their way forward towards the warmer engines.
And chew through the 'rubber' connection.
And if this is below water level you sink.

I remember on a buddy's 55 Sedan Bridge you could hear them in the exhaust system from the engine room. So he regulary started his motors and drove them out.
Picture a furry rat swimming away coughing out clouds of diesel smoke.

Jim
 
Okay, that' it, I am going to shred my Captain and Tennille Muskrat Love CD!
 
quote:

Originally posted by Nibbs

Okay, that' it, I am going to shred my Captain and Tennille Muskrat Love CD!






That's good, it was a lame-a$$ cover of America's orignal anyways [^]:D[:-bigeyes2]

Tim
 
That is why I only have liability insurance. Either someone's else's insurance repairs my boat, I repair it or I leave boating altogether. I never count on any policy to pay up since there is so much fine print making practically everything disallowed. Save your money folks, unless you have boat payments and the bank insists you carry it.

Maybe if the guy had not had anything but liability insurance, he would have been more meticulous about caring for his boat!
 
I have to disagree with the part about taking better care of the boat. The muskrats at our marina have been seen entering the exhaust of one of the most frequently used boats in the marina. It happens to be a forty one ft. Chris.The boat goes out every week all season long. When I told the owner, he smiled and said they would leave when he started the engines. I don't now how you would stop the rats short of putting a grill on your exhaust.Fyi the boat has gas engines.I do agree with checking the boat and firing the engines, bringing them up to temp; checking exhaust flow,and the gauges.At least that might stop them from nesting their.
 
Another reason to have a dry exhaust system! If the insurance contract (policy) contains a specific exclusion for losses due to damage caused by rats or vermin the boat owner is out of luck. READ and UNDERSTAND any insurance contract you have (Boat, Home, Car). If you have questions, pay a competent attorney to review the contract with you and explain what is covered and most importantly what is not covered. Insurance Agents while nice people and sometimes good little league coaches are nothing more than salesmen working on a commission and may or may not give you good advice.
 
BoatUS is sending me a sample policy. They say they have no such exclusion. We'll see.
 
Makes me glad I don't have outdrives. If those sons of %&$#%^$# can crawl up the packing glands of my boat, they can have it! A forty footer with oudrives?????
 
quote:

Originally posted by Gregory Saracco

Makes me glad I don't have outdrives. If those sons of %&$#%^$# can crawl up the packing glands of my boat, they can have it! A forty footer with oudrives?????






Greg,

The sons of %&$#%^$# crawl into the exhaust of an inboard and gnaw at the connections between the muffler and the thru hull exhaust.
 
They are not outdrives they are talking about. The critter crawled up the exhaust of an inboard.
If it were a 40' outdrive boat, it would likely be lighter 40-footer like a go-fast that could go on a lift. No critters, no bottom paint, no corrosion.
 
My last boat was a Silverton 38X with side exhausts above water and 502's. I had to start the engines every two days in the spring to blow the swallows nests out.
 
quote:

Originally posted by jim conroy

From what I am told by management of the marina and the service dept this is indeed fact.
I do know nor have spoken to the owner.

Muskrats climb in the exhaust system (on diesels) through the discharge port.
They work their way forward towards the warmer engines.
And chew through the 'rubber' connection.
And if this is below water level you sink.

I remember on a buddy's 55 Sedan Bridge you could hear them in the exhaust system from the engine room. So he regulary started his motors and drove them out.
Picture a furry rat swimming away coughing out clouds of diesel smoke.

Jim






As I read your statement then it is just rumor that Progressive is denying a claim. Hopefully this rumor is incorrect.

G
 
quote:

Originally posted by gcolton

quote:

Originally posted by jim conroy

From what I am told by management of the marina and the service dept this is indeed fact.
I do know nor have spoken to the owner.

Muskrats climb in the exhaust system (on diesels) through the discharge port.
They work their way forward towards the warmer engines.
And chew through the 'rubber' connection.
And if this is below water level you sink.

I remember on a buddy's 55 Sedan Bridge you could hear them in the exhaust system from the engine room. So he regulary started his motors and drove them out.
Picture a furry rat swimming away coughing out clouds of diesel smoke.

Jim






As I read your statement then it is just rumor that Progressive is denying a claim. Hopefully this rumor is incorrect.

G








Either way, please keep us posted.
 
Back
Top