Prop Pitch- Explain?

Joeshoes

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
1967
Messages
601
I am buying a 19 x 17, 4 bladed prop. Can anyone explain what the second number means? How is it computed?

Very curious.
 
It is the theoretical movement through water with one revolution of the prop. Not allowing for slippage or other losses such as hull friction.
 
Yes, one revolution would move the boat 17" if there was no other external force as above.
 
I means with that for every revolution of the propeller, it tries to move you forward 17 inches. Theoretical, assuming no loss or "slip".
 
The angle of the blade with the hub is not constant on most props, because the outer blade has to move further than the inner part of the blade--Classically pitch is measured 3/4 of the way out on a blade. Most of the time it is measured on a set of "pitch blocks". Prop Scan is a computerized system which measures the pitch (and other perameters) very accurately--often within .001 inch. The prop can be balanced and pitched very accurately with this system.
 
Joe, It looks like you are doing your homework first. That being the case I have to question why this is an issue for you unless you are thinking about a prop with a different pitch than you currently have. I would assume that you are buying this prop based on replacing the existing prop or as a spare. if the prop you have now is working properly (generally tested by confirming that the engine just reaches redline at full throttle)then that is the prop size and pitch you want. if the existing one is not correct most prop shops will make a recommendation as to what you want based on answers to a few questions they ask you. If you are buying it in hopes that it will work but is not the same size and pitch I wish you a lot of luck as you will need it.
 
Anyway, think of the pitch as your 'gear'. high pitch=high gear; low pitch=low gear. If your engine is overreving you need a higher pitch. If you're not getting full rpm then you need a lower pitch.
 
Thank You! You guys are great.

HAPPY: You are correct I got information from Michigan on their web site and more information from a reputable local shop. They recommneded that I switch to this size.

Joe
 
Joe,

Do you know what the manufacturer of your motor recommends as the RPMs for wide open throttle? It is important to have a prop that allows your motor to operate at the correct RPMs. You can cause damage to your motor if it is running at an RPM higher or lower than is recommended by the manufacturer. The pitch on your prop will play an important role in contolling the RPMs. Find out what your recommended RPMs should be at WOT and then decide if you should change the prop.
 
Doug:

The manufacturer of my boat is out of business for over 25 years. I have chrysler 318's but I have no idea whom to call about the answer to your question on the 318's. Boat is very comparable to a 1975 Silverton.

Thanks for the feedback.

Joe
 
Recommended engine RPM doesn't have that much to do with the boat, it's all about the engine. There are a whole lot of 318's out there; post the engine year and model if you can find it; and someone can tell you what they're supposed to run at. Then you prop accordingly.
 
I am looking at upgrading the props for Saint Max.

You my want to consider purchasing the "Propeller Handbook" by Dave Gerr. It goes into tremendous detail about every aspect of propellers. I have just started it. Unless you are an engineer, you (OK, me :)) will get a headache just looking at the diagrams. However, reading the paragraphs associated with the diagrams, you come to find it is very well thought out for the layman.

Above all, don't forget the 20% rule that is in the book but no prop shop has mentioned to me to date. The economy is hitting them as well and they want to sell props. I know I have a lot of homework ahead of me.

HTH
 
quote:

Originally posted by JoeShoes

David:

While I wait for the book, what is the 20 percent rule?






The closer the prop is to the hull, the greater the vibration transferred to the hull. I have not learned about why yet. I checked the index to answer your question.

Paraphrasing page 83:

Simply (that's all us Rhode Islanders know) put, the maximum distance between the center of the shaft and the hull will give you the largest diameter prop you can put on your boat. Take 20% off that number and you are at the "best" size you can have for your particular boat. "Best" is tough because "best" is a compromise. The smaller the diameter (greater the distance from the hull) the less vibration. BUT diameter produces force and keeps you on plane. (So much for ski boat props at 1/2 the price!)

Remember to keep in mind the shaft is at an angle so the distance has to be measured from the leading edge.

HTH
 
KiDa- I've more often heard minimum 15% clearance between blade tip to closer the part of the hull, and it refers to 15% of the full diameter of the sweep of the blades . I.e., my props are 17" D so 15% is 2.55" and my actual measured min. clearance is about 2 3/4+" so that's on track . Water is an essentually incompressible fluid so the flow off each pass of the blade tips next to the hull results in a noticeable impact we recognize as vibration and sometimes considerable annoying hull noise. The farther the blade tip is from the hull the more the propwash tends to disperse, but smaller diameter props are usually less efficient for most boats so near 15% is considered a happy medium. Cupped props and other design features may have some beneficial effect in redirecting a bit more of the propwash aft and more blades with less pitch will often also both encourage blade wash rearward & smooth out the feel of the impacts and vibration by increasing the frequency.

I've mentioned this before but it's worth repeating because it's so darn slick. There is an extremely effective method of mitigating this prop-induced vibration, that works best on downeast diesels with large props and relatively slower cruise speeds than most planing boats. Just at the head of the prop cutout in the keel a thin (~ 1/2-3/4" x ~1+"(?)thick wedge ( home- or yard-made) perhaps 24" long side to side is attached tight to the hull curve perpindicular to the keel. 2 thru-hulls with seacocks are introduced in the hull maybe 6-12"(??) apart just aft of that transverse wedge. Inside the boat, the seacocks are attached to hoses running up to anywhere they can be secured well above the water line, often just stainless thru-hull type fittings at the very aft end of & flush with the cockpit sole or as far up as just under the gunwale as desired.

Once a critical forward speed is reached (well below cruise) the lowered pressure at the aft side of the wedge where the holes are draws air down and into the water through the thru-hulls , and this fairly tiny bit of air hugs the bottom of the hull and spreads out just above where the propwash strikes. Even that tiny layer of air IS compressible and creates an insulating barrier against the former shock , reducing vibration and associated noise amazingly. The air does NOT get to the prop to cause ventilation.

I have heard that some Hatterases have employed this so-simple technology and a gentleman named Peter Lowell experimented to perfect it on his lobster-type hull and he generously spread the word to many other grateful folks around here who quickly retrofitted with "miraculous results".

Very sorry for the topic tangent and long blahblah. I just love this vibration-attenuation wedge/hole trick.
 
Sandy,

15% is the minimum "acceptable" for prop shaft speeds in excess of 1000RPM. 20% is the norm for hi speed planing craft. Gerr refers to 25 knots many times. As I said, I just started reading the book. I do not know where he considers the high speed threshold to be.

I would like to see some diagrams of the wedge you describe. I am not familiar with some of the terms you use, but it sounds very interesting. Can it be done as a retrofit?
 
David- Ever since Dave Gerr wrote the April Fool's Day edition "Holey Props"article for Offshore Magazine about the technique of drilling holes in the blades of props for best efficiency, he has been one of my heroes. I don't think we are disagreeing and I have no expertise , just have talked to the head techs at a couple of the major interstate NE prop shops for hours about prop theory, design, & service , etc and have enjoyed a # of Gerr's great articles but haven't yet secured a copy of his legendary prop book. Of course I've forgotten 90%+ of what we had a lot of fun discussing, and the age thing isn't helping there.

The vibration attenuation wedge and hole setup can easily be done as a retrofit , as this is the way it has been applied in all the cases I've heard of around MV , Woods Hole and Nantucket, but personally I would not attempt this on a relatively speedy planing boat like your Sundancer or my Phoenix . I'm not sure the prop would be safe from ventilation in that case but who knows, but the bigger props of the slower downeast diesel boats have the greatest impact on the hull and resulting annoyance. I frequently am onboard a friend's Northern Bay 36 FB which now has this setup with the air source holes flush with the sole next to the transom . ( This is a 17kt boat, I'm not sure how well this would work on an 8kt boat, as the effect kicks in on this one at maybe 10-12?kts. with the thin wedge he uses.) Underway, if I walk back there and place my boatshoes over the holes, the really annoying/exhausting loud vibration (that we had always originally attributed to generic expected diesel engine vibe) would return in full force within seconds as that air cushion was expended. When I clear the air supply once again (& as long as they are open (above the critical speed ), the vibes would quickly( few seconds) decrease by at least 2/3 or more & I gather that has been the general consensus of owner's who have tried this. I think I've heard of people using fiberglass, PVC or vinyl strip as material for the simple wedges-anything that creates that slight low-pressure area will work to draw down the air and spread it slightly laterally above the prop. Even in hard reverse, I've never seen water come up through the air holes in the cockpit sole.

I think I have 3 pics I took of the NB36's wedge & holes I can e-mail you if you send me your e-mail address. I don't think I can attach them to e-mail through the B/Ed link. Not sure how visible the setup is but you can post them if you want.
 
Got the pix Sandy. Thanks. That's just too simple. If I had the money, I would do it on my boat just for giggles.
 
I had this same question when our props were reconditioned in November and the replies is how it was explained to me.

We have 17 X 16 so one full rotation should move the boat 16". So, if our boat weighs 11500 lbs and your boat weighs 25000 lbs, same props, how can it move both boats 16" in one full rotation? What am I missing here?
 
Back
Top