Pulling to starboard

rich356

Member
exMember
Joined
Apr 3, 2007
RO Number
25751
Messages
249
Just wanted to run this by everyone here. My brother-in-law has a '98 Carver Mariner, and it is almost impossible to drive it straight for long. It will track straight for a little while (about 5 minutes), but then it will turn to starboard without turning the wheel, and you really have to turn the wheel to port to get it back on course. It doesn't help that his rudder gauge seems to be broken (although it might not be given that it is all the way to starboard most of the time). He's used to it, but my '99 356 is much easier to keep straight so it drives me nuts when I drive his boat. Any ideas? Are the rudders getting stuck over to starboard? The engines appear to be synced. Just wanted to add that I was thinking it may be the trim tabs, but would it track straight then turn if the starboard tab was down further than the port tab? Could the rudders just be out of alignment?
 
The only real control you have to adjust stablity is rudder rigging. Most rudders are rigged trailing edge in 1/4- 3/8 inch, this has to be done out of the water. That said, 5 min. of straight going without any adjustment is along time. Alao you don't mention at what speed, does he have trim tabs.
 
Jim - I just edited the my post. Yes, he has trim tabs, but as I added with my edit, would the boat track straight for a while if one was down? It seems to happen at all speeds, but it's worse going slower.
 
Sounds like he may need a front end alignment or maybe its his front brakes?
 
If a trim tab would just pop up for some reason it could be them. Does it happen because the load shifts, or check up play in the rudder system. Other than that if your boat has the same rudders, measure the rudder rigging from above and see if you can find a difference.
 
I don't think that load shifts are the problem, but there is play in his steering. My boat turns with very stubtle wheel adjustments, but his takes much more of a turn to respond, and then once it gets turning it's hard to make it turn back the other direction. It's almost like you constantly have to over steer which ends up getting you to follow a zig zagging course which must waste a lot of fuel!
 
the first thing to check is the play, an easy check can be to have someone turn the wheel and observe the rudder mechanism from inside the boat...
 
It sure sounds like there's air in the hydraulic steering lines. Air will compress and allow the rudder to move without the wheel being turned, and also require greater turns of the wheel to get a response from the rudder. The system may need to be bled and topped off. For air to get into the system, there may be a leak somewhere. Many brands of hydraulic steering fluid are almost clear, so leaks can go undetected until the symptoms of spongy steering and wandering rudders appear.
The rudder indicator works off a small rheostat that's connected to one of the rudders. As the rudder moves, resistance in the circuit changes causing movement of the indicator. They can be adjusted to read correctly.
 
Rich, it might have something to do with your boat having a small keel on the bottom and the Mariners is non-existant if I recall and the transom of the Mariner is very flat.
 
Some interesting things to consider here. We'll definitely have to take a look at how the rudders respond when the wheel is turned. Dave that does sounds a lot like what's going on. Ray - never considered that, but I did see both out of the water and you're right. The Mariner is more flat and doesn't have a keep. Since he's had only Mariners in the past he may just be more used to the way it steers than anyone else that drives his boat. Just seems strange to me though that Carver would be OK with producing a boat that steers so loosely, but I guess they may not see it that way. All we can do really is rule out the mechnical possibilities, and if everything is fine it must be a design thing.
 
That's funny. I thought you meant keel, but I said keep in my response too because I thought I may have been unfamiliar with some nautical term for a small keel!
 
Back
Top