Question for Divers

speedo

Moderator
Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
RO Number
14386
Messages
534
I asked for Cozumel suggestions in NBR and a number of ROs recommended scuba diving. I'd love to learn (I'm a fish!) but I punctured my eardrum as a child and anything over about 10 feet hurts. Flying used to hurt, but I've learned to release the pressure.

Anybody have similar experience and still be able to dive? Can pressure be compensated similarly in water, even with a bad eardrum? Anybody know how this can be checked?

I'd really love to be able to learn scuba and dive deeper than 10 feet.
 
Speedo,

You should get it checked out by a doctor specializing in Diving Medicine. I have had punctured ears on several occasions, and although the eardrum is scarred, I have been diving for 20 years now without problems.

My problems with equalising where overcome with a simple, albeit unpleasant, eustasian tube clearing procedure and some gentle practice - but diving on the Barrier Reef made it all worthwhile.

Wayne
 
Wayne -

Thanks for the info. I just Googled "eustasian" (eustachian, btw) and the first hit was from a dive site. I'm going to check into this. If I can find a way around the problem, I'm going to have a new hobby! I've just assumed I was SOL all these years and never looked into it very far.

Did you have problems flying, too? Is the method the same for equalizing?

Thanks, again, Wayne!
 
I am assuming that you have tried clearing your ears at 10' when the pain starts?
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

I am assuming that you have tried clearing your ears at 10' when the pain starts?






[sheepishly] Uh, no, I don't think I have. I don't think it ever occurred to me to try it underwater. Is the technique the same for ascent and descent?

Would snuba diving to 10 feet be the same pressure-wise, or does the dome (isn't there a dome?) isolate you from the pressure? I'm just wondering if this would be a way for me to check my ability to equalize.
 
Okay - advice number 1 - consult a doctor and ask them that you need to be cleared for scuba diving and that you have a previous ruptured/punctured ear drum.

I ruptured an ear drum as a kid, and dive with no problems. While in the military I was told that 95-98%% of ruptured ear drums heal with no problems and they cleared me for dive school with 2 tests - a binocular microscope examination and a tympanogram. However, you may take this with a grain of salt given it was the military and I think because I had a pulse I would have been cleared for dive school.

As for clearing your ears - it is the same as for flying - close your mouth, squeeze your nose and exhale through your mouth while keeping it closed (I hope that is clear). When diving, even for experienced divers, clearing your ears every 5 feet is not uncommon.
 
Yes you can (probably) dive. It's unclear whether you should. The extremely simple task of clearing your ears must also be done by a knowlegeable individual who applied good judgement as to when and how to do so. Your problem is that you have injured your ears previously. If you apply an inexperienced or poorly disciplined approach you could potentially do yourself additional harm. Most of society is unwilling to learn anything with any degree of discipline. You need to learn how to dive WHILE expertly clearing your ears so as to not cause further damage. Buoyancy control takes time to practice, you may not have it.

BTW, everyone's ears hurt at the bottom of a swimming pool if they don't clear their ears. It means your normal. Its also the warning signal from your body that you are damaging your eardrum.

Snuba is exactly the same thing as scuba diving and suffers the identical risks.
 
Thanks for the information! I've checked out a number of sites and now that I understand what's involved a little better, I'm bummed I haven't checked this out before!

The eardrum I punctured is the one that always hurt, so I assumed it was all about the drum. Now that I see how the tube's involved, I see how I might be able to do this.

Ghost - If you've punctured an eardrum, you know how special that pain is. Rest assured, I will proceed with caution. . . and discipline, so as not to experience it again! I take it you'd recommend against trying snuba to see if I can clear my ears?

I'll check with my ENT for a dive referral.

Thanks, again. I'm encouraged!
 
Good advice above to talk to a physician who understands diving physiology. Novice divers make the mistake of not equalizing until they are experiencing considerable discomfort. I find if I equalize early and often, I have less problems.
 
Divers Alert Network (DAN) is a good resource for medical diving related questions.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Gregory Saracco

Good advice above to talk to a physician who understands diving physiology. Novice divers make the mistake of not equalizing until they are experiencing considerable discomfort. I find if I equalize early and often, I have less problems.






That's right. If you are a known ear sensitive person, you want to start clearing in the first 6 inches. BUT...if you do so agressively you will simply inflame the tissue and ultimately make it so difficult to clear the ears that you might not be able to do it. Most peoples valsalva maneuvers are too aggressive if they are sensitive. You need to use a dive bomber technique that is akin to swallowing. The first 10 feet is the worst, after about 50 feet its usually not a problem.

I didn't say snuba was bad, just that it essentially IS scuba diving. There are quite a few charletons that sell snuba as somehow being "safer" or less impact. It's nothing but a lie. Of course, finding good scuba instruction is nearly impossible anymore too. Very few teach real skills anymore.

Given you still have ear pain from the once ruptured eardrum, I would suggest seeing a "DIVING" doctor to look at your ears before doing anything, most definately including snuba. Don't waste your time with a doctor that does not specialize in diving medicine. Avoid like the plague doctors who think they specialize because "I'm certified and diving is my hobby". Those are the worst, almost as bad as the clowns at the recompression chamber. Those were the guys who wanted me to spell "Bulhman" for them.
 
I've perforated my left eardrum once and the right twice, and haven't had any problems diving beyond my right ear being more difficult to equalize than the left (and who knows why - might just be coincidence. I certainly don't know), but everyone is different.

Brett, did you end up going for a chamber ride?
 
Why yes Mike, it turns out that I am familiar with the inside of the ole stationary submarine. I finally twisted myself a few years back after some overly agressive deep profiles and opened up what I believe is a shunt that I believe was missed by my echocardiograph, but I havent been serious about diving since then to repeat with the better test where you swallow the probe to prove it. Maybe some day if I get back into it. That and no more repetetive 90 minute dives in 41 degree water. I found that decompressing got a bit tedious when your nuts were trying to snuggle up to your tonsils. The hang was a bear but the dive was enchanting!

But...I never actually ruptured an eardrum. Turned one all black and blue on two separate occasions and ended up walking around bouncing off walls for a week with no balance another time. Thought for sure that I was going to rupture one when I went diving with a cold and ended up with a reverse squeeze. THAT's scary. You get in the water and successfully equalize on the way down, but then your ears get full of crap and you can't equalize on the way back up. Given that I never did figure out how to breathe water, you know you have to come up eventually. Started hurting at 60, got really painful at 40 but I think it equalized just a tad, then at 20 feet with about 100psi left in the tank and the worst ear pain I've ever felt I finally heard the loudest squealing sound as my ears finally cleared. Might have brused the ole eardrums then too, but hey I was 16 then and a pretty quick healer.

My advice after 26+ years of diving is to take care of your ears. What? Huh?

Mike, maybe someday I'll put together my top 5 tips when going for a ride. Like #1, order out for some good food when it gets late, #2 bring a good book (I read my diver assistant verses about Beebe, Haldane and their bathysphere/chamber experiments, kind of freaked him out), #3 Always ALWAYS say you feel better when they ask after the second table 6 extension, unless the book is really good, but at that point your just going to want to sleep anyway.

bp
 
Back
Top