Radar Questions

tmal2

Member
Joined
Jan 18, 2004
RO Number
12663
Messages
92
I've taken the plunge and installed a Furuno 1623 on my boat. I'm new to radar and have a question I hope someone can help me with.

I understand the principle of how radar works. The question I have is about how gain works.
The 1623 has both a manual and automatic setting. Automatic mode has 3 options. Rough, moderate and calm.
If I'm in a tight area like a marina or narrow cove, I'm zoomed all the way in and I set the unit to any of the automatic settings the screen just goes mostly dark like I'm getting echoes from everywhere. If I put it into manual mode and adjust the gain myself I can dial it in and see targets on the screen. In more open areas this does not seem to be an issue.

Is this normal? Will I have to switch modes every time I go from an open area to a more confined one? I have a friend with a Furuno 1621 and he said he always leaves the unit in automatic mode and never has any problems.

Also, what is the "tune bar" on the antenna test results page? All the manual says is "The Tune bar shows radar receiver
tuning status."

What good is showing a status bar if they don't explain what it represents, whether the results are good or bad and what should be changed to improve the results?

I've tried to find the answer in the owners manual before posting here but the manual only gets into how to make the adjustments but not how I would want to set it up for proper use.

Thanks in advance for any help you can give.
 
I don't use auto gain much. I like to tune my sets manually. Get out into an open area where you can set the range on about 6 miles. Then pick a target out 4 -5 miles and start turning the gain up till you get the strongest return of that target with a bit of static/clutter on the display.

In old sets you adjusted the tuning the same way. Can you adjust your tuning? Or does it just display the statis of the tuning?

As you've seen auto does not work well, if at all, in close. You need to learn to tune it manually.

Many people try to tune their sets so there is no clutter at all on their screens. That is wrong. There should be a bit of clutter showing at all times at all but the closest ranges if you want to get good returns on small, weak and intermittent targets.

If your buddy never takes his unit off auto, he is not getting the most out of it. And more than likely not "seeing" small targets at longer ranges.

There are a couple of good books on radar out there. As well as a DVD radar course by Starpath that you should look into. http://www.starpath.com/catalog/software/1801.htm
 
Multiple Qs... I'll give it a shot.

Gain, stated differently, is the "receiver volume control". If you really crank it up, prominent returns will really blast in there ( and very likely turn from a point to a blob ), and less reflective objects will also begin showing up. If you start turning down "the volume", the highly prominent objects will still be displayed, and the less prominent objects will begin to "disappear".

The reason you have a gain control is that in calm, flat water, virtually all returns are "valid"; that is, something that you want to see is there. If, under there conditions, you lower the volume, you lose sight of objects that you want to see. Contrast this with working in a heavy chop. Waves produce returns. If you have the volume high, then your screen will display all of those waves ( and wavelets etc ), filling your screen with things that you do not wish to see. So, in this case you lower the "volume" ( gain ). This, means, of course, that you lose ALL of the "low strength returns", which might include crab trap floats, and/or logs etc. Thus, the engineer gurus gave you a gain control...

Obviously, constantly needing to fiddle with the controls can reduce the usefulness of the unit. If you are willing to trade off perfection for not having to fiddle with the controls, you can use the "auto gain" function. This is not perfect, and not suitable for all conditions, but often, this is acceptable. The auto-gain uses software routines to "interpret" the returns and adjusts the gain so that there are never "too many" returns. This method is imperfect, and does not suit all conditions. It is not uncommon for the auto-gain to lower the gain so far that you lose such things as buoys, boats and landmass.

For some vessels, since they always only go out under certain conditions ( only when calm, for example ) always leaving the auto gain set ( and to the same choice, such as "calm" ) this is ok. For most of us, some tuning is required and the unit will need to be adjusted whenever the environment changes. The degree to which you environment changes determines the degree you need to "fiddle" with the controls.

Note that a well tuned radar is a much better tool than one tuned using "auto functions". This is one of the reasons that many of us encourage others to always use the radar. The more practice you have using the equipment, the easier and quicker the adjustment becomes. With practice you won't even notice that you "tweaked" the tuning. Until then, it will seem like an awful lot of "messing with the blasted thing".

-edit-

The issue is actually quite complex, at least from a technical standpoint. I and the above poster have "glossed over" the ugly and mostly unneeded detail. The fact is, with practice, you will see the effects and knowing the underlying details becomes mostly unnecessary. So, keep on fiddling... :)
 
Thanks for the information. Looks like I've got a lot of learning ahead of me.
 
Just use it a lot in clear weather so you can get an understanding of what different targets look like.

But just remember to look up and around once in a while. :-)
 
Did you run down a canal or river and adjust for the length of the
cable between the radar and the display?
 
quote:

Originally posted by rduhon

Did you run down a canal or river and adjust for the length of the
cable between the radar and the display?






Not yet but I know that needs to be done. It's on my list.

Thanks
 
Back
Top