radar

If you must have a all in one, consider Furuno Nav Net, RayMarine C series or Garmin's latest. go with a 12" screen. Nonsense you don't have the room--you can put all sorts of displays on that Intrigue dash. I personally prefer a separate radar, and both of my boats have Furuno 1715, as Les suggested. I have different brand chartlotters--and the Navman will not interface with Furuno. Navman has radar, available for some of the displays. If the Navman is more than a year or so old, it will not work.

Furuno has the longest track record, and is prefered by commercial vessels because of its reliablity. "The best" means what will work the best for you--not some unit which is appropiate for a 150 footer. A 2 to 4 KW output with a 24" dome will work fine for that boat--and your applications. Go visit some of the marine electronics stores and look at the displays. Garmin is probably the easiest to learn to use, but I personally don't like their cartography. There are basically 4 types of cartography--Navionics, C map, Garmin and CD's with computers. The latter is ruled out. Also Lowrance has some very good units, but they have been slow with the intergrated Radar.

You have to learn to use the radar--as well as tune it. You will not get the most out of it, by just turning it on and putting it on auto tune. Buy some software, such as the Starpath Radar similator and trainer--spend a number of hours learning to use it. Then go out during clear conditions, and run the radar, identifying various objects visually, as you drive slowly along.
 
Whatever radar you choose be sure not to pick a day that's 100 degrees with a heat index of 106 to install it. I've been working on my new Furuno 1715 today and the heat has about killed me. It looks like a well built unit and is fitting my 26' center console really nice. I had to build some brackets to mount the little mast mount to the top of the cc frame. And now I've decided the display will have to go on top of the dash and not in a compartment as there is no more room. In fact, I think I'm going to move the sounder plotter on to the top of the dash too so I can see it better. They are supposed to be water resistant and I may just take the displays and store them inside my shop when the boat is just sitting on the trailer.
 
I use all Garmin chartplotters the 4212 at the helm and 3210 in my salon and a small 3205 also at the helm. I have it integrated with the Garmin XM weather receiver (GDL-30) and Garmin's digital Sonar (GSD-22). My radar is the GMR-41 by Garmin. You normally have to pick one manufacture if you want to network the equipment. Good luck I also boat in the same area. Regards Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by boatingfinatic

Does it make any sense to get color?






Not that I can see for radar (mine is monochrome radar), but for chartplotter, color scheme is nice - allows easy discrimination between land, shallow water, deep water, buoy/light colors, etc.. It tends to duplicate traditional charts. On fishfinder, it is a very nice feature.
 
Here is a link to a podcast that was produced by raymarine It is very informative/educational about radar. It explains what to expect from recreational radar, what to look for in radar and the limitations of radar. It is not promotional and doesn't not push their products but explains the available features to consider before purchasing a radar.

http://www.raymarine.com/raymarine/Default.asp?site=1&SECTion=43&Page=1614&Parent=43

Gary
 
With a single helm, there is no real need to spend money on a networked system. Again, radar is not like running a chartplotter. Proper use of radar requires knowledge and skill. Radar becomes important in the worst of conditions - fog, heavy rain, at night. At some point, you'll have a little low profile bowrider in front of you, probably with kids on board. If you have a 8" split screen, you will be looking at something about the size of a large cell phone screen - not something I would want to use to protect lives. If you have overlay, you'll have far too much data on the screen to effectively pick up tiny targets. You should also leave your radar on all the time for training purposes until you get to the point where you can pick out all the boats around you quickly and easily. When fog rolls it, that is not the time to be learning how to use your equipment.
 
Just make sure that once you get it, when ever you have the boat running, that you keep it on :D
 
That is why I network Les, I really have a single helm the Salon Chartplotter is used as a video monitor, for planning routes, recalling events, to watch weather patterns of the XM and an anchor alarm. I could but haven't used the radar at time intervals as a zone alarm from the salon. At the helm because I am networked I can use the whole 12" Display of the 4212 for the radar in bad weather (fog) and the 6" chartplotter for chartplotting. If I had the room there would be a pair of 4012's at the helm. Is there anything wrong with my current set up? Take care. Bill
 
Les is right about knowledge and skill. I used radar in airplanes for weather avoidance, so the topic was not unfamiliar. But, it did little to prepare me for using radar for either collision avoidance or navigation on a boat. After four months I am still on the steep end of the learning curve. It takes time and practice - a lot of both!

One reference I have found useful for learning to set up and use radar is the book, Radar For Mariners by David Burch. It won't make you any expert, but it will accelerate the learning process. It also has good section on performance, installation and selection -- all good to know when selecting a unit. You can check out the book as well as other learning aids at starpath.com. They even have a radar simulator useful for learning (the book comes with a limited use trial version).
 
you can't compensate lack of knowledge and skills with electronics... way too many boaters rely too much on their electronics and spend way too much time with their eyes glued to the screen.

Radars and plotters are obviously a must have if you run in fog or reduced visibility but the system needs to be simple and easy to operate.

I agree with Les about split screens and overlays, they may be cool but far from ideal. You want as much resolution, especially on the radar... if you overlay, what happens when you needed different resolution ? you may want to have your radar on 1/2 mile range and your plotter on lower setting to get the big picture.

color for the plotter ? absolutely... for the radar ? not so sure about it.

one feature i had on my previous boat (current had an older stand alone CRT Furuno) was the garmin GPS interfaced to the Ray radar allowing me to overlay waypoint on the radar. that was convenient to mentally merge both pictures. but that's as far as i want to go.

single displays also raise the issue of reliability and redundancy.. if you're in fog and loose your single display... good luck. If you loose either radar OR GPS you can still navigate.

it's a fine line between cool and distracting... And the best electronics will be useless if you have an electrical problem and dont' have any back up. If you need top of the line gear, don't forget to make sure you're not relying on a share battery bank which will dwindle to nothing if you just loose an alternator...
 
Yes. Sometimes. Usually. Most of the time.

He's ( Bruce ) talking about those -other- times.

Though I am a Raymarine kind of guy, Furuno makes excellent equipment. If you think their displays "look bad" you are thinking of high end home/ofc PC's rather than marine navigation equipment. Note that you can spend a very great amount of money on really pretty marinized displays, and in fact, you may even be able to display the info on a standard computer screen. But a computer screen ain't designed to be used as a navigation device ( even if it can be, and is, used as one ).

---

I get this horrible feeling that you are pulling our collective leg. But in the event that you are not, your best bet is to look at the equipment used by those who operate their boat in the same location/fashion. Then study the manuals ( usually available online ) to see if your needs will be met.
 
Back
Top