RADAR!?!?

JAYROCK

Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2007
RO Number
28607
Messages
272
I wanted to know what brand and size radar I will need for a 29ft cruiser? I like the lcd monitors because of the size. Color? Monochrome? crt? what do i need? Thanks Jay Causey
 
Depends on what you need it for. What type of boating do you do?
 
River? Lake? Commercial, navigable river? Small shallow winding "cozy" river? 70nm offshore?

As always, we will be glad to make suggestions, but also, as always, more info gets more useful answers.
 
Also a lot depends on how much space you have available--as well as the $$ available.

I happen to like the Furuno 1715 for a 30 foot boat. It is monochrome, compact screen and 2 KW, which I feel is enough for the the vast majority of cases. Some will say that 4 KW is better in heavy rain or fog. I have always had 2 KW (over 30 years in most of the world's waters) and found that was adequate. The wider the scanner, the better is the descrimination (that is the ability to separate two close objects.) I personally do not see a reason for color, but I have not owned a color or an integrated unit with overlay.
 
Sorry, I should have said WHERE I boat......Navigable river and area lakes but mostly Red River. I was told that radar can see bouys,rock jettys,logs floating down stream and boats in the river. This is common in the warm summer months(nite fishing). Most of these fishermen dont have there lights on making them hard to see. I need schooling! Help Thanks Jay
 
Given a choice, I'm not a fan of the radar/chartplotter overlay? I prefer a seperate radar & seperate chartplotter. I get a much more simplified picture with a seperate dedicated radar unit. In bad weather I don't want any more clutter then needed to give me a view of what's directly in front of me? (Imho)The ability to combine the two is a plus only when display space is a factor?
 
thataway4 pretty much covers it.

I had a 4kw, larger dome ( 24" ) and a large color screen. And in general those upgrades should be considered optional, esp. for your usage. Mono, 2kw, "standard" dome should provide the needed info.

Though the system I had provided radar/chart overlay, in my experience, it was not as useful as two screens. Reason: It appears that the brain interprets the two types of information slightly differently, so when looking at the overlay screen, you only "see" one or the other, but not both. Or at least my mind did... ;) I tended to miss the finer details ( often the info you need is in the details! ) of the radar. It also relates to "why" you have each type of instrument. GPS/Plotter is -only- for illustration your map position. Map data is not always that accurate, so it is only an approximation of the "real world" and it provides -no- realtime data other than the long/lat and the derived info ( speed, COG etc ). Radar on the other hand is a "camera" that sees "radio frequency light" and it images, at very near realtime, the actual surroundings. The means it show the actual position of buoys ( which may have been moved since the chart was printed ), the actual location of jetties ( which can shift due to barge strikes and storms ), many river banks, most of the nearby vessels, and sometimes floating logs and birds. The more experienced you are,the more useful the display can be. Note that radar only sees those things that reflect the radio frequency signal. Not all things that you can see with your eye ( using visible light ) will appear on the display, and some things will appear more prominent than your eyes can justify ( a pelican in flight can really mess you up! They can look like an outboard skiff... )
 
I like the overlay but you need a fast compass to keep it lined up. it helps confirm markers as opposed to boats and other objects. Color is good especially with the overlay.
Dollars will make the difference.
 
Thanks Guyz, that helped me understand what it WILL do and what it WONT! Is one brand better than th other? Jay
 
You will not be able to reliably see "logs floating down stream" on radar.
 
Jay, that's mostly correct, but you need to learn to use it well to be able to use ot for collision avoidance and navigation. It's not really like a chartplotter where you can turn it on and have little icons showing you where you should be and where other things -should- be. Shouldn't be hard to find someone in your area that can teach you to tune and interpret a RADAR. I've referred to a RADAR as St. Raytheon for a reason - it's one of the best tools on the boat. If it's tuned up right you can catch falling seagull poop. (Okay, maybe not, just wanted to say that)

Agree with the others about the overlay. Once you learn to use the RADAR, you'll find it just confuses things. There is also limited utility in having the set in the North-Up configuration, as most chartplotters are used, and vice-versa. It clutters the screen too much, takes most units too long to 'catch-up' and get everything updated, which isn't really too cool in the weather, fog, or restricted waters.

Anyone know if using an overlay screen is legal for commercial traffic? Was going to look it up yesterday in 33CFR, but realized I didn't feel like looking it up.
 
Back
Top