Radio Checks....

Radiowaves

Active member
Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2004
RO Number
14642
Messages
2,612
I am not big on doing radio checks on Channel 16, mostly on a pleasure channel or 09. But at times for the sake of knowing your radio is working you may need to.
Recently I got into a conversation / debate with someone over this topic.

Last season, I was heading from Montauk to Essex Ct. I could hear chatter on 68/69. But nothing on 16 which seemed very strange. I called out on various pleasure channels and no reply, including 09.

So I go to 16 and did a radio check “vessel requesting radio check 5 miles off Montauk" I get a reply back from the Coast Guard that 16 is for emergency use only and radio checks are not permitted. Now I heard this before but sometimes they reply back with no problems. I quickly and concisely explain that I thought I had no signal. He repeated his statement again. I say for the sake of safety I believe I was correct. He repeated the statement again a bit more agitated. Realizing that I had a signal I shut up.

Any advice or information on rules or procedures when you feel that your radio may not be transmitting?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Jonathon

I was under the impression that 16 was for hailing too.




Yes you can then switch to another channel. But I had no one to hail... My traveling group was already in CT.
 
in my area we call for a radio check and the local sea tow or towboat us will respond like

"vessel requesting radio switch to 69 for seatow, seatwo will give you your radio check on 69, 69 captain"
 
I've also used Ch 16.....and it says it was OK ( in our area ) ....but ?
 
The Montauk watchstander is wrong. In the First Dist.they are supposed to answer a radio check if they are not overly busy or handling an emergency. Why argue with him because as soon as he answers it is obvious that your radio is working.
 
I usually call my towing company on 16, THEN go to another channel; ask for a radio check, or whatever.

I suppose in a pinch you could call the Coast Guard on 16, when they answer ask them to shift to a working frequency, THEN tell them to have a nice day. Wastes more of their time (and yours) but at least you get your radio check (on two frequencies).

It would be a lot simpler if they'd simply answer a radio check with "loud an clear" and go on about their business. All the legal BS just ties up everyone's time, AND the airwaves.
 
I always have a handheld on board, and the admiral can give me a check if necessary.
 
Radio check on one of the upper general use freqs. CH 16 is Coast Guard and hailing in our area and 9 is for the numerous bridge tenders.
 
one radio check is no problem... but here in south florida and on week ends it's non stop and 16 becomes a zoo. The USCG is way to tolerant down here.

there are many channels that can be used for radio checks... in addition to 68, 69, etc... 13 which is the channel used by commercials around here could be used. In fl, Ch 09 is used by bridges but could probably be used elsewhere

90% of the time, the radio checks are useless because the guy who replies doesn't say where he is... he could be two slips down from you...

an RC using a handheld on the boat or even close by on a dink is equally useless as it doens't assure you of any range...
 
9th district (Great Lakes) has a no radio check policy on Ch. 16. You will get the same stern message here if you ask for a check on 16.
 
Problem with using another channel is that we're all REQUIRED to be on 16... If the other channel is quiet it may be because there's no one there to answer you; and if it's not, the clowns yapping are probably going to ignore you anyway.

An automated system on a dedicated channel might be a good idea. You call for the check, after a few seconds the transciever plays it back to you, and you're done.
 
I usually just say - "this is vessel XXX can someone please give me coordinates to anhcorage/harbor XXXX? I have all the beer and liquor for the raft up and the group is awaiting me."

I instantly get many, many, many responses.

In all seriousness, I usually hail one of the Newport restaurants/marinas from my slip.
 
quote:

Originally posted by yzer

Radio check on one of the upper general use freqs. CH 16 is Coast Guard and hailing in our area and 9 is for the numerous bridge tenders.




I just would like to clarify, I am fully aware of the general use of channel 16.

My issue was and the reason for my posted question is that I was over 5 miles out between Montauk and CT. I felt uncomfortable not hearing any talk at all on 16.

I then tested my VHF and no one replied on several pleasure channels. At that point I was not traveling with any other boat. So at this time I did a radio check on 16 and the Coast Guard was quick to say don’t use. As Gene said I should have realized that I was transmitting and not responded back. But it was a bit of a reaction to just say, I thought my radio was not working. I did expect a different more polite reply. But I did not reply again. So there was no further discussion.

P.S.

Essex Island Marina in CT. was great.
 
Thanks for posting this. It is something lots of us can learn from.

So, you were in the middle of Long Island Sound and you suddenly got worried that your VHF wasn't working because you didn't hear anyone talking on 16. You then make the leap that even though your radio is receiving on 68/69 that it must be broken. You then make several contacts with CG on 16, two of which were AFTER being told not to.

I have several questions: can your radio receive on 68 and 69 but not on 16? Maybe in the old days of crystal radios, but highly improbable with solid state. So you might think OK, I can receive, but can anyone else hear me? What is the point of doing a radio check while you are at sea? If you found out your radio was inoperable, what would you have done? Would you have terminated your voyage?

I believe that radio checks (on working channels) have their place, but do it where you can get it fixed or replaced if you find it's not working. And, always have a backup radio.
 
Some folks feel compelled to argue with even a vending machine.
 
I kicked, slapped and rocked a vending machine until it gave up my crackers last night. I taught it some new words as well.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Sea Gull

Thanks for posting this. It is something lots of us can learn from.

So, you were in the middle of Long Island Sound and you suddenly got worried that your VHF wasn't working because you didn't hear anyone talking on 16. You then make the leap that even though your radio is receiving on 68/69 that it must be broken. You then make several contacts with CG on 16, two of which were AFTER being told not to.

I have several questions: can your radio receive on 68 and 69 but not on 16? Maybe in the old days of crystal radios, but highly improbable with solid state. So you might think OK, I can receive, but can anyone else hear me? What is the point of doing a radio check while you are at sea? If you found out your radio was inoperable, what would you have done? Would you have terminated your voyage?

I believe that radio checks (on working channels) have their place, but do it where you can get it fixed or replaced if you find it's not working. And, always have a backup radio.






Gull, You obviously did not read my post or did not understand it.

1 I had been tuned to 16 as a boater should be. After significant about of time I noticed that I was not hearing anything. Which normally after 15 minutes you hear something.

2 I then switched to various pleasure channels and did hear chatter. This is true. But I tried to do a radio check several times on a few channels and got no response.

3 I then did a Radio Check on 16 and was told not to do this – I returned ONE statement to the CG operator stating that for safety I did this because I because I thought my Radio had a transmitting problem. I DID not respond back again.

P.S. I just purchased a backup Icom M72 from Boatfix.
 
Radiowaves: It's a good day in Long Island Sound when there is no one on Channel 16. Switch to channel 68 or 69 and ask for your radio check there.

Gene Johnson (above) seemed to know what he was talking about but no one seemed read his post.

These frequencies are all shared and there are few watch standers to monitor even the most important CG channels. If an incident happens and the CG asks those involved to switch to 22A, they may not be able to answer on 16 immediately. We, as recreational boaters, are supposed to know where we are at any given time. With that knowledge, it isn't necessary to call on the radio.
 
Back
Top