Reposessing boats

It really is sad. Hard to believe that he owes twice what the boat is worth seven years after he bought it. You really have no choice but to walk away in a case like that.
 
I would have thought his only real choice was to make the payments till it is paid off. I did not see where the article said he lost his job.
 
quote:

Hard to believe that he owes twice what the boat is worth seven years after he bought it. You really have no choice but to walk away in a case like that.





Whatever happened to the notion that you promise to pay and then do it?
 
You're right. And that's something I don't understand. The guy admitted that he overextended himself and that's what led to his problems. But if he didn't lose his job and his financial situation did not change, he should still be able to make his payments.

I know a lot of foreclosures happened because people owed more than their houses were worth all of a sudden because of the downturn in the real estate market. But if they still had their jobs, they really don't have the right to just walk away because they realized that they overpaid for their house. That's not the banks' fault.

I understand that the government is developing a program to refinance adjustable loans at the original rate so people don't have the same problem that the guy in the article had where he lost his condo because the adjustable rate went up and he could no longer afford it. I don't think it's fair that the American Taxpayer has to bail out those people who over extended themselves.

I bought my boat for cash. If I lost my job, which happened 5 months after I bought the boat, I would never have been able to afford the payments. And, given the boat market, I would not have been able to sell my boat. I would have really been stuck. The bottom line is that I would be devastated if I had to give up boating. It's a big part of my life. Fortunately, I did not owe any money on my boat and I found another job in three months. I'm a technology manager just like the guy in the article but I'm a few years younger. I was lucky I guess.
 
Loosing your boat because you over extended is sad, and irresponsible. Too bad it's a sign of the times - lack of personal responsibility.

On the other end of the spectrum, I've been making extra payments on my loan since inception, and paid it off on 13 years early on Saturday. Felt nice to own it outright when I was cleaning it later in the day.
 
Yes some people make very poor decisions when they finance a boat, a car or sometimes even a house. But just because you did not lose your job, that does not mean you can still afford to make the same payments that you were making 7 years ago. (I paid cash for my current boat).

In the last 7 years, my "fixed expenses" have more then doubled while my salary has not even come close to keeping up. by fixed expenses, Property taxes, have gone from $3,400 to $8,500. No change in property, just reassesments, and taxes going up. Fuel, from $1.25, to $4.00 a gallon, and I am not talking about fuel for the boat but for the car to do things like go to work, and the grocery store. My Gas & electric bill for the house has aslo doubled in the last seven years.

I do agree that when you take out a loan, you agree to pay it back, not just walk away when the times are tough, but sometimes it is a tough choice on where to put your dollar.
 
quote:

Originally posted by MichaelNJ

I know a lot of foreclosures happened because people owed more than their houses were worth all of a sudden because of the downturn in the real estate market. But if they still had their jobs, they really don't have the right to just walk away because they realized that they overpaid for their house. That's not the banks' fault.





I generally agree, but the RE debacle is a bit different. Many of those foreclosures are a result of adjustable rate mortgages that require refinancing the loan. When the RE value fell sharply, many owners found themselves upside down and unable to secure loans unless they had a large sum of money to pay the difference. In other cases the loan to value ratio was so high that those who could get financing ended up with unusually high interest rates. Ultimately the buyers screwed up, but in many of the foreclosure cases they had a lot of help.
 
This is exactly why I never see myself owning a new boat.
The payments are always big enough without the economy tanking and everything else going up so fast and furiously that the boat payment is no longer affordable. I just always figured that a boat is a recreational/pleasure item so if I can't pay cash for it....then I can't afford it. There's just to much uncertainty in this day and age.

I too lost my job of about 25 years 3 years ago and although I can say I don't miss it....I'll probably never find another quite like it and the reason for that IS the economy. (long story) But the point in this is that although my lifestyle has changed dramatically I still own the boat because I paid cash for it. Had I financed it when I bought it ......well....it'd have been history 2 years ago. Of course...how much I'll be able to use it is changing rapidly because of the costs involved but I'll still use it as much as possible this summer and see what next year brings. I've had this boat for 6 years now and I guess that if after this year I couldn't afford to run it anymore that I'm probably not out a whole lot of money. The problem then would be what to do with it at that point because certainly nobody is buying much of anything.
 
DiveDaddy and the group...

but why were they upside down...HELOC or 105% financing...then they pay. I don't understand why they HAVE to refinance...when they knew the terms going in...and they walk, that is just plain wrong.

I too paid cash for my boat, did with out, lived frugally and have suffered through several "down" markets and the 9/11 stuff and still have my house and boat. The house may be "worth" some percentage less, but I did not walk, nor do I think I should pay out to make some broker or impatient homeowner whole again.

YMMV, but be responsible...

dave
 
well heck it's done in the corporate world all the time; the company declares bankruptcy, the officers walk out with their golden parachutes and everyone else gets screwed. I think it's called "business".

It's not ethical but it's the sign of the times. Back when I was getting offers in the mail I was really tempted to mortgage my (paid for) home for 125% of equity, move onto the boat and steam away. I didn't, and I've been kicking myself ever since.
 
Maybe he should sell his house, get a storage unit/sell extra things, move onto the boat and devote himself to living up to his responsibilities.

If I was in his posistion, I might also be doing a bit of whining and bitching and generally unhappy, but you cross the line when you blame everyone else but yourself.

Definition of the word "deadbeat".
 
Its hard times for everyone, MichaelNJ, not everyone can afford to buy there boat outright. I certainly did not, I financed mine, and I can tell you after losing two businesses to the housing market, I too am struggling to make my boat payments. I have liquidated everything I could from my stores to keep my boat! But I am running out of things to sell. I am hoping that I dont lose my boat in 2008, that being said, I am also a very resorsfull guy, I am planning on chartering my boat so it can pay for itself for a while, thats the plan anyway for now. Otherwise I guess I will be screwed like some of those other guys.

Trying to make money in South Florida!

And for the ones who say I was irresposible, I say this, when I purchased the boat I was doing fine financially, both businesses were doing well, I am a victum of the Bush economy and the Housing market. Who knew things would get this bad? I certainly did not see this comming. All you can do is move on and hope all will work out. (as long as you keep maken payments)
 
Back
Top