"Perhaps the larger give-way vessel was defending her tonnage (see "Rule of Tonnage" in Chapman), while the smaller stand-on vessel was defending her right-of-way (see "right-of-way" in Chapman). Both, naturally, are totally illegitimate, and contradict the actual Rules, to the detriment of safety, though Chapman couldn't care less. "
let's not give people the impression that Chapman's is otherwise inacurate... that would be a disservice to those who need to learn and could use a copy.
call it what you want... right of way, give way or stand on, both vessels are at fault here and the exact wording is completely irrelevant.
frankly, i don't care if the guy approaching on my port side thinks i have the right of way or he is the give way vessel, either way he will know he has to take action.
like it or not, Chapman's is still the best book out there to teach new boaters the basics of boating.