Rust Removal techniques.

Thudpucker

Active member
Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2002
RO Number
10503
Messages
3,677
Rust Removal is a common question. A lot of products are out there for Rust Removal. This thread is on a Cheap (Cost Reduced) method.

I ran across a set of comments on using Sugar Beets and also a Mixture of Molasses.
Here are some quotes from other sites:

"I have used the super-simple electrolytic rust removal method many times with excellent results. No sticky mess that way and no expense.
- Battery charger, scrap steel sheets, washing soda and tap water.
And the solution can be reused again and again."

(this one's on the Molasses mess)"3 to 1 is what I use, should be done in a week. It will clean areas of those wheels even sandblasting won't get. Cleans gas tanks like new, and kills the gasoline so you can solder/weld them. The whole piece has to be submersed or the gas from the juice will REALLY rust what's sticking out of your tank. I wash and scrub with Spray Nine and a brush and rinse, rinse, rinse. I have stuff laying in my shop for a year without primer after derusting that hasn't started to flash. The feed store stuff is made from red beets, the stuff you eat on pancakes is made from corn. All the rustbeeter guy is doing is getting rich."

What do you guys know about this stuff?
Have any of you actually used the Beets or Molasses method?

I was really interested in the Elyctrolytic process.
 
I have no experience with any of the above, but I have seem them ( or minor variants thereof ). A note on the molasses method: you must degrease the metal first. The molasses will not work on oily sections.

I have a couple hundred pounds of what used to be tools damaged from the storm, and will in the near future be attempting recovery of some of them ( notably, the wood clamps ). I expect to try the molasses method, as well as muriatic acid. I had not( yet ) considered the electrolysis method.

Another note regardless of method: The process should leave fresh, chemically active, naked iron exposed. You need to immediately dry then protect the surface. I lean toward using phosphoric acid treatment, though any water displacer ( ie: WD-40 ) and/or anti-rust coating would do.
 
Well Thuddie, just because you asked (and I am intrigued) I spent about an hour and a half trying to figure out how the molasses thing might work chemically. Let's just say there are a number of possibilities, but I couldn't find anything certain. There are a lot of questionable explanations on the web, none of which satisfy me as a chemist. My suspicion leans towards sulfur compounds and reducing sugars in combination - these have been know for years. It probably also fits the sugar beet explanation.

Aside from mechanical (grinding, scraping, sanding, etc.) basically there are three ways to get rid of rust: (1.) acid dissolution (dissolve ferric oxide in an acid), (2.) complexation or chelation (usually combined with 1.), (3.) reduction of ferric to ferrous, or in extreme cases back to iron - this can be either via direct electrolysis or via a dissolved reducing agent.

Which method you choose probably depends on what you are treating, how complex it is, how much time you have and what you will do with it after removing the rust.

In (1.) you already know about muriatic acid (tech grade HCl). Phosphoric and oxalic acid also work, but more slowly and leave behind a passive form of oxidized iron.

(2.) alone is generally not very practical for the average guy doing any kind of large part, but it comes along with the HCl treatment and is the basis of many cleaners that include chelating agents like EDTA.

(3.) is how Iron out (in the laundry section) works - dithionite reduction of ferric to ferrous, which is more soluble and colorless. It's also the basis for electroreduction (the battery charger idea).

On the cheap, I don't know about the molasses trick. It reads like folklore but it has a lot of proponents and I suspect it will work. The one thing I did note is that it needs to be sulfated molasses, like the stuff you get at a feed store.

Other on the cheap household things that will work depending on the situation and what you are trying to accomplish: Snowbowl toilet cleaner (HCl), Coca Cola (dilute phosphoric acid), Super Iron Out (dithionite reduction), salt and vinegar or lemon juice (acid plus complexing). All of these water based solutions will likely require a very good cleaning/degreasing, and everything except the Sno Bowl will probably do better with a bit of surfactant (detergent) added.

So what's the project?
 
divedaddy, thanks for the info!

I have a pair of vice grips which became extremely rusty over the winter. They still work, but they get my hand all dirty with rust when I use them, and they look really bad, too. I think I'll try salt & vinegar with some liquid detergent thrown in and soak that baby!
 
quote:

Originally posted by Flutterby

I have a pair of vice grips which became extremely rusty over the winter. They still work, but they get my hand all dirty with rust when I use them, and they look really bad, too. I think I'll try salt & vinegar with some liquid detergent thrown in and soak that baby!






Liz,

I guess sometimes directions should come with the product. The salt with lemon juice or vinegar is a short-term treatment. Soaking in a salt solution can make things worse. It's okay to soak in some vinegar, then salt scrub with a towel or rag dampened in vinegar. If you do that follow with good rinse and something like WD-40 and some more rubbing. Don't use the WD-40 or any type of protestant until your satisfied with the cleaning part.

For your vise-grips try soaking for a day or so in Coke, then rinse. If your satisfied then some WD-40 with a rubdown. If not repeat the Coke soak.
 
Ok, thanks!

The problem is that the vice grips have a lot of areas which are difficult to reach to scrub. Guess I'll thoroughly clean off the WD40 with liq detergent, then soak in Coke for a few days, then rinse well. If they do not clean up completely, it's ok. They still work. Think I'll keep these at home from now on and just take to the boat as needed.......
 
Not sure what you are removing rust from, Thud. Anyway: Cheap: Bartender's Friend; Cheaper: Apple cider vinegar or white vinegar; polish with baby oil if it is metal Cheapest: Elbow Grease. Effectiveness is inversely proportional to economics, at least with me.

George

Anchored off Belhaven NC with another Hatt MY glistening in the setting sun. The only thing better than this is the move Big Brown made coming into the stretch of the Preakness today.
 
Should have added - wood bleach is oxalic acid. Good for rust stains on many things, including fiberglass. Get at your local hardware or mega home shop. Usually 12 oz. dissolved in 1 gal hot water, costs about $5.00. This is the same as the rust stain removers sold for about $10/qt.
 
quote:

Originally posted by jtybt15

Welllllllll, you asked!!![:P]





Whooo boy! I wonder if DiveDaddy was aiming all that mumbo-jumbo at me?
It'd be like preaching Nuculer physics to a Duck!

I actually have a grade for Chem 101 and more. It was long enough ago that I dont remember a lot of those terms.

The Project:
B1101st480x360.jpg

My latest aquisition. It's an old Garden Tractor and I got the tiller with it. I was thinking of restoring the Ugly yellow color. If you gotta have something Yellow, it should at least be trimmed in black, not Rust!

I did sorta like you did DiveDaddy. I spent an hour and more on the net looking at Car/Cycle/lawn n garden places where they'd be well versed in Rust.
Nothing positive came of that. Like your observation, it reads like old wives tales.

I was interested in the Electroplating Idea though.
Thinking a little deeper on that one, the Rust has fewer electrons than the Iron. The Iron would transfer first and leave the rust. That's probably not a good thing to try eh?
 
Thud,

The idea is to reduce the rust back to iron - switch the connection, and fast or your old AC will soon all be in solution !

For that project, I would go with scrape, grind, blast, sand, whatever, then treat with a phosphoric acid based metal prep. You don't have to get all the rust off, just the loose stuff. It forms a very stable converted surface. Prime and paint as usual over that. That will be the best and probably also the cheapest. One of the better treatments is a product called Ospho. It comes in qts, gallons and 5 gallons too - I suspect a gallon or two will do that job. I think it's about $30/gal.
 
Can't see really close but I 'spect it's not the really heavy layered rust scale. I've tried to clean up a couple trailers like that. A ball peen hammer and chisel gets the heavy stuff better than anything else. the a 'knot' wire wheel on an angle grinder will clean plenty good for the phosphoric acid.

Jabsco used to make a phosphoric acid at good concentration for about $10/liter. Haven't seen ti for a few years now. Ospho is the next best but doesn't seem quite as concentrated. 30+ years ago they used to have a product called Rust Mort(same stuff) that I used to get from auto paint stores. It cost $10 for about 10 ozs.
 
A commercial chemist once told me how to clean a frying pan with burned-on crud. It probably functions the same as the molasses. That is, by the time you have spent cleaning the gooey molasses off, you will have also cleaned the rust.

Anyway, the solution to the frying pan was to place some unpopped popping corn in the pan and set it out in the middle of the field. Crows will come and peck at the corn. Since they miss frequently, they will eventually chip out all the burned on stuff.

I never knew if he was pulling my leg because he was so damn serious explaining it.
 
Isn't Rustoleum designed for that sort of application? Get it at the paint store......
 
Thud: time to fire up the sand blaster to make fast work of the AC. Then do what dd says.
 
Yup, DD is right of course.
I was looking for an easy, lazy, fool proof, way of soaking the rust off. Something that would work good for Water manifolds as well. It's just not in the cards right now it seems.

One more thing that re-inforces DD's logical information is the amount of speculation in the threads on rust.
All of it that does not use the Sand blaster and wire brush is just plain urban legends.

Enough on this subject.
I've got some other projects to attend to before I can get to the AC. Last night I ran two Rabbits outta my garden.
Farmer McGregor is about to set up an infra-red based search and destroy, Shot gun armed, garden pest removal device. (look out watermelon thieves!)
 
quote:

Originally posted by Thudpucker

Last night I ran two Rabbits outta my garden.
Farmer McGregor is about to set up an infra-red based search and destroy, Shot gun armed, garden pest removal device. (look out watermelon thieves!)





I used to have great luck with blood meal (aka dried blood). It only last through a good rain, but is easily reapplied (around the outside) and makes a great nitrogen fertilizer too.
 
Something I haven't tried (in a long time)for rust removal(from the past) is naval jelly. It will stick to vertical surfaces.
 
Back
Top