Safe fuel storage?

WaxedElvis

Member
Member
Joined
Apr 20, 2006
RO Number
20940
Messages
126
The boat I'm looking at has a fairly large storage area under the deck accessed through a hatch in the floor (outboard powered). I would like to add a fuel tank to this area, in the 25 gallon range, that I could use on occasion – meaning remove it when not needed for long runs. Are there any safety concerns assuming two things – 1) the tank is secure and 2) it is vented overboard properly. I would either add a vent line with a thru-hull or perhaps tie in to an existing vent line. I wouldn't need it all the time so would pump the fuel to the main tanks when needed. If safe, this seems like a better idea than gas cans in the cockpit. Thoughts?
 
First thought is, if it can be installed properly (securley and permantatly) in this area -
A) Is there anything else down there that could present a hazard I.E. trim tab pump or any electrical devise
B) You will need a fuel management manifold to switch between this and the main tank(s)
C)IF this can be done, tank should be installed permantly. 25 gallon tank is going to be cumbersome and dangerous to handle. The mounting must be secure, 25 gallons of fuel is heavy and could rip the mounting in moderate sea. Also where are you going to keep this when out of the boat - worst of all it will be full of fuems.

Does not seem like the greatest of ideas. Just my opinion.
 
I think "safe fuel storage" is an oxymoron here. Sounds like it would put you and anyone on or near your boat in danger.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Gregory Saracco

I think "safe fuel storage" is an oxymoron here. Sounds like it would put you and anyone on or near your boat in danger.






Why?

If accomplished properly, what would be different about this tank and any other fuel tank?

G
 
Why?

If accomplished properly, what would be different about this tank and any other fuel tank?

G
[/quote]
Accomplished Properly is going to require a permanent installation. Even empty that tank will be large, heavy, awkward and explosive. Full, over 150 lbs of gasoline plus the weight of the tank, securing it in the bilge will be critical. ANYTHING that can possibly go wrong will in the MOST DISASTROUS manner possible. It will shift, it will get holes rubbed in it, it will spring leaks from lines. And notice I did not say it might, I said it WILL. Unless it is very carefully thought out and installed, those things WILL happen.

Is it doable. Sure. Just be sure it is truly done RIGHT!
 
By doing so you have created a space that must be ventilated by USCG reg. It must be vented to atmosphere and have a blower, any equipment already there must be or be replaced by USCG ignition proteted equipment.
 
I would put in a perment tank. The weight of the tank would be minimal--15 to 25 lbs for 25 gallons of fuel. It would not be safe to plug and unplug fuel lines and fuel fills--you would not fill this tank in the bilge.

There is no requirement for a blower in an outboard powered boat. Passive ventillation is required at 15" per cubic foot of the compartment if there is a plastic tank, a tank which vents into the air or any electrical component which might cause a spark in the compartment. Doesn't make a difference if the tank is portable or fixed.

Best to go with fixed.
 
Bob I don't know what the Reg. is verbatim I do know I was cited by USCG in 1968 for having a tank in the cuddy of a 1948 CC 16' with a 35 HP Johnson outboard. He didn't care if I had the hatch open or not it needed forced ventilation. I couldn't easily remove the tank because the fuel line was routed under the deck.
Case at hand was stated to be a removable tank therefore I believe it is intended to be filled in the space because I don't believe anyone would be able to place a 25 gal tank on the fuel dock and then move back into the hold. A blower may be the only way to get adequate ventilation into the hold.
 
Perhaps I need to reconsider or permenantly install. My thought was it would be nice to have the open space for storage most of the time but add the tank when needed. As noted, secure and vent where alwasy considered. I don't have the boat yet so need to really evaluate the space in detail and see what will/won't work. Thanks for the thoughts and time posting.
 
Outboards: no blowers needed as there's no engine room.

Why not contact the manufacturer with this question. There may be a very good reason they only put the tankage in that the boat has. Or, they may say the additional tank is an option they offer and have specs for.
 
" I think "safe fuel storage" is an oxymoron here. Sounds like it would put you and anyone on or near your boat in danger."

i really dont' see what the problem is.

all you need to do is make sure that the tank is secured, vented and that there are no ignition source (non protected electrical device) in that compartment.

indeed 25 gallons calls for a permanent tank with a filler and a transfer pump to the main tank, but that's no big deal. It is safer than having jugs out in the cockpit. although instead of a transfer pump, you're probably better off adding a 3 way valve to feed the engien from that tank.
 
IMHO, it's not safer than jugs on the deck the way it was described in the first post. He's talking about a portable tank that will be placed when needed and fuel lines, vents etc disturbed peridically. He's not describing a permanent installation. I would have no problem with a permanent installation done by ABYC standards.
 
years ago, i had a portable tank for a auxiliary. I discussed this with surveyor who said that it was ok to put it in the engine compartment as long as the tank was secured (strap and chocks) and most importantly vented to the outside.

in this case, a permanent install woudl be better but as long as the tank is secured and vented, it's fine.
 
Glen, I can relate to 1968 and what is being enforced is different than today. My father had a Cal 25 at that time, and the fuel tank was stowed in the areas under the seats. The CG requirement at that time was just two vents--one facing foreward and one aft. My father was upset by this requirement (no blower). My own boat was a Columbia 29 and with an inboard, we had a blower.

Currently I own a Tom Cat 255, which has 75 gallon fuel tanks in each of the hulls. The boat is powered by two outboards on the Armstrong bracket. The tanks are under the cockpit and under the cabin, but sealed off from the cabin interior. The boat is ABYC certified and has been boarded by the CG--no necessity for blower. A second boat is a C Dory 25, with a plastic fuel tank of 110 gallons, with adequate passive ventillaton--no blower. I also own an 18 foot Century Center console--50 gallon aluminum fuel tank under the floors--no vents or blower. All outboards, all ABYC certified and all with fuel tanks in the hulls with no blower.
 
Bob, I understand the Regs have either changed or are interpeted differently today than yesteryear. My point and I believe it is a valid one is the thread starter was describing a portable (although not portable) meaning it wouldbe fueled in place and through a cap on the tank thus requiring ventilation. As this ventilation wasn't or isn't factory it may be difficult if not impossible to get the 15 sq" / cu ft required ventilation. And the only way to complete this installation would be by using a blower.
The other concern her is the placement of the tank. Too far aft and the boat will take more to plane too far off centerline and the boat will list CL over the COG and low would be the best place to place the tank.
Glen
 
A 25 gallon fuel tank will weight (with fuel) less than 200 lbs--about the weight of many of us. Don't under stand the point about center of gravity in a tank which is below deck level.

The fueling in place may be implied--but is not stated. I don't think that filling a fuel tank in the bilge of a boat is an acceptable idea peroid. Fueling the tank in place gives an unacceptable risk of fuel vapor collection: Blower or not. The blower in an inboard or inboard outboard is there to remove any residual fumes at idle or at rest.

Once a fuel tank (which is filled from the deck and vented to the deck) is in place properly there should be no fumes in the bilge.
 
looking back at the first post, i dont' see any mention of a portable tank being filled in the bilge... i dont think anyone would even consider filling a tank in bilge! Pretty obvious the tank will need a filler in addition to a vent...

something else... depending on the boat layout, what's in the compartment, if that bilge is connected to the cabin bilge, i woudl consider adding a fume detector in there and possibly sealing that bilge to make sure any fuel leak doens't spread to the cabin bilge. I think (but could be wrong) that ABYC standards recommend that engine / tank bilges dont' connect to cabin bilges where non ignition protected devices can be installed.

if you do seal that bilge, make sure each compartment has at least one bilge pump.
 
Pascal, in one of my boats, the bilge is sealed from the fuel tank (how about most express cruisers, which have the fuel tank under the "cave" aft berth?). But in the catmarran, the fuel tank and bilge goes from the transom to the bow, with the fuel tank more under the cabin than under the cockpit. Both sides, have accessabality of the tank from the bridge deck from inside the cabin--but no non ignition protected pumps in the hulls them selves. The boat is ABYC certified. I agree that any bilge should have a fume or explosive gas detector if LP Gas or gasoline is present.

Agree that sealed compartments need bilge pumps, no matter where they are.
 
good point... it depends on teh construction i guess. the bilge coudl be sealed forward of the tank so that any leaks drains back into the ER, not under the cabin.

come n think of it, that's how my old bayliner was setup... the bilge was sealed forward of teh tank, under the cabin door. the tank was just aft of that, under the berth, and there was a limber hole in the frame just aft of the tank, going into the engine compartment. any leak in the tank would go to the ER, not the cabin. the berth bottom was all glass, you coulnd' see the tank there ....
 
Re jugs; used to have a friend who used them. I rigged up a "fuel wand" on a long fuel hose so that rather than trying to transfer fuel at sea we just hooked up the fuel wand and took the suction directly from the jugs. It was a lot cleaner and safer, and the jugs stayed secured on deck. Switching jugs was a matter of seconds.

Whether it would be appropriate in this circumstance I cannot say.

Tempo has 12gal portable tanks that while heavy are still manageable when filled. Two of them would provide nearly the 25 gallons. I'd be reluctant to put them belowdecks, though, unless the compartment was sealed from the rest of the boat and vented to the outside.
 
Back
Top