Safety Harness selection

jjs2204

Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2007
RO Number
27534
Messages
1
I'm trying to buy a Inflatable PFD w/ Harness, Manual - Type V. Are all PFD's basically the same? any experience with Revere, West Marine or Mustang? Any comments appreciated. cost is a factor, I will use this only a few times each year. They all look very similiar. Thanks
 
Your comfort should be one of your top deciding factors. I have on board 6 Mustang MD3183. These are Hydrostatic and appear to be beyond what you are looking for. I would question though why you do not want Hydrostatic and strictly manual. You should also check out Sospenders.
 
I agree that comfort is very important. Key area is around a bare neck, like when you are wearing a t-shirt. Admiral and I also have the Mustang MD3183 and they are very comfortable - soft and smooth around the neckline. They have an integrated harness version of the same PFD - it's the MD3184. We got ours via Boatfix - great price

http://www.boatfix.com/cart2/Scripts/prodList.asp?idCategory=174
 
Here's what I've been told is a good guideline for buying a PFD.
1-Comfort(If you won't wear it the best PFD in the world is useless)
2-Price(buy the best one you can afford. Saving a few dollars on a PFD may seem great until you need to use it, then the savings won't matter. Same goes for flares and parachutes).
3-Features(as long as it's CG approved it has to pass certain standards so you can be sure it's quality made. SOLAS standards are more stringent but add to the cost. Revere, Mustang and Sospenders are all good makes, I believe Sospenders or Mustang make the ones for West Marine. Buy the one that feels and fits the best. You won't go wrong with any of them.
 
We also use the Mustang MD3184's anytime we are out of the cockpit while at sea, we had one custom made for our daughter and all of ours have ACR water activated strobes. When the weather turns nasty or at night while we are at sea whoever is on deck wears a EPRB/GPS as well and we are very careful to always attach the harness when the weather is nasty or one of us is out of the cockpit in deck.

SeaQuest OE
A Lagoon 570 Catamaran
 
I have the sospenders auto-inflate with integral harness. I find it pretty comfortable. It is comparable to the Mustang units but a bit cheaper.

I agree you should go with an auto-inflate that will go off in the water. It's a couple of bucks more. I wear it while racing sailboats. I figure if I go over there's a good chance it was becasue I got hit by a boom and knocked out. Auto-inflate is cheap insurance. As for accidental inflation, I've take waves over the bow that soaked me and it hasn't set off the thing. It needs to be submerged.
 
Back
Top