Here's what I've been told is a good guideline for buying a PFD.
1-Comfort(If you won't wear it the best PFD in the world is useless)
2-Price(buy the best one you can afford. Saving a few dollars on a PFD may seem great until you need to use it, then the savings won't matter. Same goes for flares and parachutes).
3-Features(as long as it's CG approved it has to pass certain standards so you can be sure it's quality made. SOLAS standards are more stringent but add to the cost. Revere, Mustang and Sospenders are all good makes, I believe Sospenders or Mustang make the ones for West Marine. Buy the one that feels and fits the best. You won't go wrong with any of them.