sailboat prop performance ?

gibsoneric

Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2007
RO Number
28950
Messages
3
New sailboat owner here. Just purchased an 83' Comar Comet 860. 28'2" LOA, 9'6" Beam, 4'3" draft. It has a 12 HP Inboard Nanni Diesel and a 2 blade folding prop. Sailing in the Long Island Sound this past week for a shakedown and discovered, to my dismay, that while under power the boat barely manuevered. Was unable to keep up with the current and had a devil of a time mooring. Resorted to sails up approaches and departures from the dock. My question is...is this typical for a sailboat inboard? I don't expect the thing to be a speed demon, or to turn on a dime, but am I reasonable in expecting more than approx. 2 knots out of the system? When we pulled the boat the prop was covered in growth. Probably didn't help the efficiency much. I am definitely not a mechanic, but any suggestions would be helpful. On a separate note, The Boat Place in Port Jefferson on Long Island, NY were awesome helping us deal with a last minute storage solution. Thanks to Dan, Gary, Nick and the gang. See you in the spring.
 
First of all, I'm sure you will see a big difference once you clean your running gear.
If you want to get the absolute best performance you can under sail, leave the folding prop on as it does reduce drag while under sail. If that doesn't matter, than replace that folding prop with a standard prop as it will give you a little better performance while under power.
I used to have a 30' Catalina with a 16 HP Yanmar. I had no problems getting 5-6 knots under power.

By the way, you might want to edit the title for this thread. I-O means inboard-outboard which is not what you have. Change the title to sailboat prop performance or even post your thread on the sailing forum.
 
Keep that prop clean for its best performance!

And I'm glad you found great service when you needed it. All boaters are not as lucky......
 
Thanks for the info! Change has been made. As far as replacing the prop with a standard style...I would rather have better sailing performance. Maybe a 3 blade folding prop would be a good compromise? I will give it a test when I get it back in the water this spring after it has been cleaned. Thanks again.
 
Having witnessed several attempts at hooking up with a mooring recently I have to wonder about the circumstances but I will say a clean bottom and prop are going to aid the task significantly.
If the bottom is clean and the prop is not fouled, I would expect that you should be able to pick up a mooring easily. The thing to remember is to not be afraid of the throttle. I know that goes against the grain of sailors but approach, rudder and throttle were the dismay of many of the failed mooring attempts we witnessed.
First you need someone who is willing to SPIN the wheel. I don't mean just turn it lethargically, I mean SPIN it so you can swing the bow at the last second. Along with that a good belt of throttle to reverse direction or slow it so the mate on the bow can grab the pennant makes things easier.
We were surprised to see how frequently boats spun around a mooring because the captain went to the bow while the S.O. handled the helm in a rather helpless fashion.
 
My experience with sailboats is that they usually handle better than a power boat; with that big keel and rudder you should be able to turn on the proverbial dime. But like everything else you need to learn the technique; don't be afraid of the wheel, OR the throttle.
 
Folding props are good for racing but are marginal forward and terrible in reverse. The best, but most expensive way to go is a feathering prop. Autoprop and Maxprop are two brands. I put an Autoprop on our 42' trimaran. A huge difference in reverse since the prop reverses itself. You do need to make sure your prop shaft does not spin when the boat is sailing.
 
Thanks for the replies. We had some tense moments expecting movement when using the engine near the docks...with less than desirable results! Definitely not afraid to use the throttle and the tiller! Main problem was the lack of momentum when in a current. I used all the tricks I know, crabbing, sallying the rudder, prop walking, backfilling the sail. Didn't have to resort to kedging...but it briefly crossed my mind! We were successful, but it did take some last minute athletic moves combined with some expeditiously applied mooring lines! Approaching a mooring ball should give the option of choosing the best approach in relation to the prevailing circumstances. Approaching the dock sometimes limits your options. I am looking forward to the clean hull and prop to see the difference. I appreciate the tips and advice and follow these forums whenever I'm home. Thanks guys.
 
Never had a problem with MaxProps on two different boats. Three bladed would probably do better but they can be a bear to adjust - unless you have a new one. When you get a chance make sure the prop. has been lubricated properly - they can hang up and you won't get full pitch. Also, check the pitch. It is usually adjustable. The old Maxprops had to be removed to be greased and adjusted. The new ones can be greased and the pitch changed while mounted - underwater if the visibility is good. They are not as efficient in reverse but not that bad. Never had a problem making hull speed with either of them. Luck. Dale
 
Back
Top