On the island breakfast we like the "Village Cafe" the best. The old "Broken Egg" was much better than the newly relocated one.
Off the island North end breakfast has 2 nice options,
1. "Oasis Cafe" right at light in little strip mall.
2. "IHOP" Old favorite right on US 41.
Off island South end lunch/dinner: Choices are "Big Al's" sports bar type, "Long Horn" steak house, "Dutch Valley" family style. All 3 are off the South end of the island 1/2 block right on US 41.
Off island North end lunch/dinner: South on US41 is the "Olive Garden".