Bsteven,
IMHO the 36c (formally the 34C) is better than my boat. The reason I say this is because my only real bit-ch about the boat was it had a sideline master berth instead of the center island berth. The 36C has the center island berth. The quality of the boat is outstanding and the engine room is very user friendly, as a matter of fact, there is not one component on the boat that is not easily accessible. I have the 8.1 Crusader motors, I would not suggest that you go with small block (6.1), the boat needs the torque that the big blocks deliver. If you could afford to get this boat with diesel that IMHO would be the way to go.
I burn around 29 to 34 gallons an hour at a cruise of 21 knots; top speed is 25 to 29 knots with a fuel burn of 50 to 60 gallons an hour. My fuel burn is a true reading at these speeds (B&G fuel flow monitor). If I reported fuel burn, as many people do by using math, my fuel burn at cruise would be around 20 to 21 gallons an hour at cruise. If you get the Yanmar diesel package your fuel burn at 19 to 20 knots would be 18 gallons per hour (as reported by diesel owners on the SOC). The diesel motors cruise a little bit slower, and do not have the top speed as the gas motors.
If you look at any other sedan, sport fish, or fly bridge boat this size I think you will see that the Silverton is by far a much better value and a super quality boat. I happen to like the Meridian line, but the 34 Meridian does not have an option for big blocks and has much less of a beam than the 36C, in other words it is a smaller boat.
The ride on the boat is smooth and it does not squat at all upon acceleration, the boat is on a plane in seconds. I have had the boat out in 8 foot seas one second apart and it handled it like a champ. But keep in mind this boat is not a battleship, nor was it designed to be in these kind of seas for any prolong period of time. It is not a Blackfin, Cabo or those types of boats.
If you are looking at used Silverton’s, there are some great deals out there that have diesel, if you are a seasonal boater then gas would be fine. The advantage of gas is a little more speed and a lot less maintenance. It is also easier and less expensive to maintain and repair gas. If you plan on doing some real cruising (200 plus hours a season) then diesel should be your choice.
As far as your question about “is there anything else you think I should be looking at?”
As mentioned, the Meridian is a nice boat, the 34 Meridian would not be a fair comparison to the 34c – 36c (smaller boat, and IMHO small blocks is not the way to go with a boat of this weight). The 391 Meridian would be a better comparison to the 34-36C.
Regal makes a nice boat in this size, I would refer you to Rommer on this (go to the Regal Forum, he is the moderator).
The Silverton 38 Sport Bridge is a nice boat, I would consider that boat if you need something larger, and the 42C Silverton is a super boat and if I was to move up to a larger boat this is one I would consider, but would probably make the jump to my dream boat, the 45C.
I would never buy a 38c, IMHO the 36C is all over that boat and if I wanted larger the 42c is the boat.
Walter