Simple TV Antenna

TimHenn

Member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
126
Messages
346
With the upcoming digital TV change I'm now motivated to get a new digital TV. I don't want an expensive, fancy antenna system but purchasing something that could be mounted outside the bridge would be great.

Anyone know of a HD antenna that would mount on a GPS style antenna pole (1")? I'd like to re-use an old GPS mount but there is no room for the big wide disks that are 12" or so wide.

Is a HD antenna the way to go with this change? Don't see how I would pull any other signal into the boat unless it was satelite.
 
The smallest TV antenna I know for marine use is made by Glomex. There is really no such thing as a digital TV antenna. There is a Marine Antenna manufacture called Digital Antenna Company they make excellent marine grade antennas but nothing for marine TV. Do you currently have TV signals where you are at? If you don't or they are marginal DTV won't do much to help. Contrary to popular belief digital TV requires more signal than analog it's either a perfect picture or nothing no snowy pictures but if you currently have snow in your pictures there is a good chance over the air DTV won't be reliable.
Bill
 
Sorry somewhat wrong advice from the other bill. With analog i did not receive cbs 2, nbc 4 or fox 5 and even 7 abc was tough on long island and the higher chanells were iffy. With the same antenaa and a High def t.v. I get cbshd, 4 nbc channels. fox 5 and about 35 other digital channels that look beautiful. Best High def tv is off an antenna. I got rid of the portable satelite dish and receiver and couldnt be happier.
 
There are A LOT of myths at there that are just not true.

Currently DTV is broadcast in the UHF band of frequencies, so that alone will change your ability to recieve the channel
There is no such thing as a Digital Antenna, so don't waste money on it. A good UHF antenna will do just fine
There is very little correlation between which NTSC (analog) and ATSC (digital) channels you recieve
DTV does not = HDTV. Don't expect to get HD quality picture from a standard DTV
DTV does not require "more" signal than NTSC, but it can "seem" more finicky
Just like a digital cell phone, there is no static. Now you hear me, now you dont. Same with DTV
DTV is more susceptable to poor/corroded cabling.

I won't go any deeper than that. If anyone would like a dissertation on QAM, QPSK, 8PSK, MPEG2/4 encoding, PID, PAT, or PMT, feel free to let me know.

-Shane
 
"DTV does not require "more" signal than NTSC, but it can "seem" more finicky`"

It really depends on your definition of what quality signal is "good enough"...

If you are willing to accept a "snowy" picture, with periodic fading, then analog will work at lower signal levels. Further, the human mind can and does "filter out" multipath distortion to some extent, so even an analog signal w/ multipath may be "acceptable".

With digital signal, you either get a good image, or you get no image. There will be times where a weaker analog signal ( with many technical issues ) might have been received, where a digital image would not ( ie: signal strength/quality did not exceed the threshold ). But from a technical standpoint, digital transmitter power and bandwidth can be lowered ( compared to analog ) and still provide a "useable" signal for approximately the same area as analog...

Again, it all depends on your definition of "good enough". There have been times in the past, during hurricanes, where -any- image was "good enough" to convey the essential weather/preparation information. I suspect that under similar conditions a digital signal will force me to accept a "quality" signal or no signal at all, which would leave me without important information. Nevertheless, the change is here, and this observation is no longer applicable...

BTW: This whole process was an attempt to get the US in the same ballfield with the rest of the world. It got "politicized" and this is the result ( closer to the rest of the world, but inferior ). What it -does- do is conserve spectrum ( a limited resource ) while both improving the user's image, and lowering the power requirements at the transmitter ( ie: cheaper to broadcast ). It is not a bad change, but since we were going to replace every TV in the US, we might as well have done it right. << sigh >>

--

Yes. any UHF TV antenna will work just fine. I suspect that "rabbit ears" and properly twisted wire clothes hangers will also still work...
 
I'm thinking of getting a new HDTV and pulling in over the air HD signals -- my dock neighbor has done something similar but he has some old Navy, powered antenna on the hard top. I don't want to go crazy on an antenna just something simple and inexpensive. I don't require more than a channel or two at the dock -- same when I'm out somewhere, frankly don't have to have anything at all which is why I want to keep the antenna part simple.

I'll try to look up Glomex and see how small they are. Any other manufacturers with small, or vertical only antenna's?
 
I just installed an HDTV and put up a 14" Shakespear antenna (around $140) Awesome picture and about a dozen channels (6 HD) in my area.
 
There is no falicy or mis-information digital signals require a higher quality or Bit Error Rate and generally better RSSI. B.E.R does not exist with analog TV. I have seen it alreay in my boat. Local UHF Channel 40 a low power NBC shore affiliate used to come in all the time sometimes chrystal clear other times snowy and almost no audio when analog. Then they ran both transmitters at the same time and there were many nights I could not pick up the digital but could the analog especially during storms. Once you start missing enough 1's and 0's in digital it can not forward error correct and you get a blank screen or one that locks up. I went from a small 12" Glomex to the largest Shakesphere both had amplifiers and were mounted high on the hardtop. So I was comparing the same station same power level and the same fixed distance. I am glad I have Direct TV through KVH or I wouldn't be watching much of anything. We are at least 40 miles from the nearest transmitter and about 65 miles East of Philadelphia and more from the NY market with the exception of a low power digital Spanish station that is line of site in Atlantic City on top of the Taj.
I am also an RF engineer that fully understands digital vs. analog transmissions and path losses due to increasing frequency. DTV is not all it is cracked up to be especially if you are rural/remote. As far as digital modes used in weak signal work this is an entirely different mode of communications used by the government and ham operators it will not support video or audio just messages. At least Direct supplies me with local programming for TV40 as well as Philadelphia stations for keeping up on the local news. For weather I use my Garmin GXM-51 (N2K) with my Chart plotters as well as the good old stand-by VHF marine radio set to go off on a severe weather alert.
Bill
 
I have found just about any UHF antenna will work fine. As a matter of fact, I have and old CB antenna on my terrace I have that hooked up and it gets the same channels as my power antenna on my boat!
 
Good one Walt. If my CB antenna works, I'll bet the coat hangers work like a charm!
 
I thought that video was pretty cool, now if you modify it a bit, you may be able to make it better looking.
 
I showed it to a friend of mine, he lives in brewster, ny. He made it out of copper wire and put it in his attic. He gets the CT digital stations. He thought he was missing some so he bought a digital antenna, put it on his roof, gets the same channels!
 
My boat came with the Glomax with powered preamp and a cockpit 19" HDTV/DVD. I replaced the cockpit TV with a 32" HDTV to better watch the ball games. Anyway the Glomax does a good job IMO with HDTV and DTV stations and fits on the standard screw type mount.
 
My boat came with a Glomax. I honestly don't know if it will work in a couple of weeks or not. The ship's store at my new marina has an antenna that he got from Radio shack for about $25. It works very well. He gets about 15 channels with it. It is about the size of 6 packs of cigarettes 2 wide by 3 high. Very impressive for the price.
 
My boat came with a Glomax. I honestly don't know if it will work in a couple of weeks or not. The ship's store at my new marina has an antenna that he got from Radio shack for about $25. It works very well. He gets about 15 channels with it. It is about the size of 6 packs of cigarettes 2 wide by 3 high. Very impressive for the price.
 
David the Glomex worked almost as well as the large Shakespeare on DTV. Mine had the pre-amp like Mawyat's above.
Bill
 
Back
Top