Single Engine vs Twins

No info in your profile as to your location. Not enough info in your post to as to what constitutes a weekend trip. If you are on say Lake Lanier and anchoring in a cove for a couple of nights, a single is going to do you fine. If you are on a river or the ICW and heading to a nearby (<75 miles) marina for the weekend, a single is fine. If you are heading any distance offshore, you may want to consider twins.

Additionally, your engine room will be more accessible with a single. Your fuel costs will be lower. Theoretically, your maintenance costs will be 1/2. Depending on your size, twins may make some stuff inaccessible necessitating the need to hire a mechanic. At 6'4" I had some problems getting my fat arse into the engine compartment of my 2460 Regal, but I could reach most everything. Ain't happening in my 330 Sea Ray despite an extra 3.5 feet of beam.

HTH
 
I will stick with a single.

Based on what I see twin engines do not seem to help keeping some outa trouble. LOL

What ever you choose practice prior to ramping up the power when docking.
 
One of the problems that comes with choosing a different boat is, do I want a single or twins and you will find that question debated almost daily on any forum you log into on the internet as well as numerous articles written in the boating magazines. Thats part of the fun of shopping for a new boat! Truth is there is no such thing as the perfect boat. I believe the word is compromise. Many 28 foot boats will give up space allowed for a safe walkaround to accommadate more cabin space inside, where as a 75ft boat will most likely get you both. Put that 75 on an inland lake and it may be as usefull as an aircraft carrier to the average weekend boater. Put the 28 in the ocean with no walkaround and you may soon find your crew overboard. Trailering that 28 Rinker to your next cruising ground may cause you to also buy another tow vehicle and permits. You would not have to worry about that if you decide on the Aircraft carrier. As far as fuel effecientcy I get better MPG with my twin 5.7 Volvos than I did with an older 268 Searay 7.4 with an Alpha drive! The volvos push more than double the weight than the Alpha did! On the other hand The Mileage on my old 25 ton Trawler with diesels rb2@gr5t 8 knots was nearly the same as the 31ft is rb2@gr5t 30MPH.
Have fun making your choice!
 
if you dont' need the redundancy, then there is no reason not to get a single in that size range. if you plan on doing longer run away from homeport or in areas where assistance is an issue then you may want to got for the twin.

some thing can be fixed out there like belts, impeller, etc... but a drive failure or ECM will leave you dead in the water waiting for a tow.

the twin prop will make reversing easier, handling in close quarters while not as easy as a twin shoudln't not be a problem.

The big + will be less maintenance and most important better acccessbility in the engine bay. cramming twins in a 10' beam boat makes maintenance a nightmare...
 
WOW ! Thanks to you all for your responses, I read every single reply and I learned alot. Sorry, I created my account in haste and didnt include my location. I will be boating the the Georgian Bay region, just north of Toronto Canada. This area is pretty protected and we rarely experience very strong winds. I will be staying mainly on small inland lakes, and only occasionally venturing across larger lakes. My slip has tons of space around it, so I will have lots of space to practice. We will probably never take a trip where we will be more than 30 mins away from a marina, we mainly stay within that little region. So, that said, I certainly see the benefits for twin engines if your particualr situation requires it. I have no problems at all docking my current 21 footer with an 8.5 foot beam, so although the new boat is a bit bigger, I'm sure I'll get the hang of it with a some practice.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Chris_P

WOW ! Thanks to you all for your responses, I read every single reply and I learned alot. Sorry, I created my account in haste and didnt include my location. I will be boating the the Georgian Bay region, just north of Toronto Canada. This area is pretty protected and we rarely experience very strong winds. I will be staying mainly on small inland lakes, and only occasionally venturing across larger lakes. My slip has tons of space around it, so I will have lots of space to practice. We will probably never take a trip where we will be more than 30 mins away from a marina, we mainly stay within that little region. So, that said, I certainly see the benefits for twin engines if your particualr situation requires it. I have no problems at all docking my current 21 footer with an 8.5 foot beam, so although the new boat is a bit bigger, I'm sure I'll get the hang of it with a some practice.




Hi Chris,

That is close to the exact same sequence I went through. I had a 20' runabout with a deep-V and 5.7 I/O. I now have the boat you saw me talk about above. I find my bigger boat much easier to handle. It's the weight. Everything happens more slowly. Yes, if it gets away from you, it's less forgiving and the consequences can be much greater. Fortunately, I have not had that happen-- so far!

I let the weight of the boat tell me what it wants to do. I factor in the wind and other variables and compensate.

Just this past weekend, I was docking at lakeside restuarnt/bar with the wind wanting to blow me off the dock. I had not actually had that condition yet on this boat. I came parallel to the dock a little too soon and it blew my bow off. It was just a matter of a simple adjustment. I pulled back out and came in at a more aggressive angle and turned away later. We got a line on the dock and that single easily powered the stern into the dock with no problem.

As others have mentioned-- the single leaves lots of extra room down there! I even have a spot for an extra anchor (the stock POS that has never seen water!).

I have Bennett auto-trim tabs and the boat gets up on plane in about 4-5 secs with two on board. The Rinker you describe should do even better with less weight, more power, and the B3.

Good luck in your decision.

Paul
 
I've heard the North Channel is amazing. I havent ventured there yet with the 21 footer. That will be one of our first trips with new new boat!
 
A single in a lake or on a river might be fine. But there's a little more risk if you go offshore with a single. Last weekend I made it in to port on one engine after a starter failed on me about 20 miles out in the Gulf. I was sure glad to have the spare motor. And if I had been caught in a bad storm with only one engine and it failed I would not have been happy. Personally, I would prefer to buy a used boat in good condition with twins than to have a new boat with a single. It just all depends on what you use it for.
 
If I can respectfully offer my opinion, I personally disagree with the notion that twins are inherently more redundant than a single for multiple reasons.

1.) In a diesel boat, most engine failures stem from fuel issues. Twin engines offer no advantage in this matter.

2.) Most drives, props and rudders on twin screw boats are less protected from floating debris and from grounding than single screws are, especially on a boat with a large, deep keel. Hitting a giant log at night or scraping bottom can often do more damage to both drivelines on a twin than just one driveline on a single.

3.) With the amount of money and effort you have to spend moderately maintaining two drivelines, you can sink it all into keeping a single in top shape, and have a vast spare parts inventory. The additional space you have in the engine room/compartment will also aid you with maintaining everything.

4.) Singles are built with one large mass, on the centerline, down low, tending to make them inherently more stable. Twins tend to cancel each other out.

Most ocean-going vessels from the largest of ships, to the smallest fishing boats are singles and they venture well offshore in all sorts of weather conditions. The key thing is maintenance and there is no doubt that a single is easier (and less expensive) to maintain than twins.

Just MHO. . .
 
twin engines usually also means twin fuel tanks, so much for your theory about fuel issues. Many even include a Tee valve to allow pulling fuel from the 'other' tank in the event one has a problem. Definitely more reliable through redundancy there.

He's not looking at a trawler with a big-ass keel, he's looking at an express cruiser.

Most ocean-going vessels also have a professional on board whose job is to maintain/repair the engines. Not likely on recreational vessel.

Your points make no sense without entirely ignoring what sort of vessel the person is looking to buy.
 
quote:

Originally posted by wkearney99

twin engines usually also means twin fuel tanks, so much for your theory about fuel issues. Many even include a Tee valve to allow pulling fuel from the 'other' tank in the event one has a problem. Definitely more reliable through redundancy there.

He's not looking at a trawler with a big-ass keel, he's looking at an express cruiser.

Most ocean-going vessels also have a professional on board whose job is to maintain/repair the engines. Not likely on recreational vessel.

Your points make no sense without entirely ignoring what sort of vessel the person is looking to buy.






Fuel issues generally start at the source, so twin fuel tanks are only worth their salt if they are filled from seperate sources.

How many with twin tanks do that?

There was a guy at my former marina that bought a kicker and had it hooked up to his main fuel tank. Later that season his main engine quit from a fuel issue, so he fires up the kicker - guess what happened next?

The scary part is the guy is a neuro-surgeon.
 
Tankage arrangements are completely separate from the engines. You can have two tanks on a single-engine boat, or one tank on a twin. The point was that having twins does not inherently protect you from contaminated/dirty fuel or clogged filters.

Yes, most ocean-going vessels do have a professional onboard maintaining everything and most rec boats don't --> All the more reason to reduce your own maintenance load by halving the equipment you have onboard and focus all of your attention, time and money onto one engine. I'd take a well-maintained single over two mediocre twins any day.

I still think that a boat of that size and type does not need twin engines. It's more maintenance, less protection (even with sterndrives), cramped spaces and quite frankly, there are many boats of that type and size with singles that work out just fine. I'd like to see some statistics on how many people have TRULY been saved by having a second engine.

For the record, my boat is a twin and aside from the ease of maneuverability, having twins has never revealed a great advantage to me.
 
Chris - the Rinker 280 EC is essentially a newer version of the Fiesta Vee 270. I owned a 2002 270 for four years, running it all over Long Island's south shore. It had a single 350MAG Bravo III. The only trouble I ever had was trying to plane with 8 of my closest friends sitting in the back. With the 496 that should be NO problem.
Lots of folks here talk about learning to operate the boat in close quarters, and they are right. You need to really think about the front/sides of that boat as being a big sail. The wind will push it consistently downwind - as long as you plan for that ahead of time, you can easily manuever in almost any conditions. The Bravo III makes it easy to back directly in any spot, with no prop walk, etc. Worst comes to worst, I would use my "bow thruster" - my wife sitting near the bow with a boat hook fully extended. Never hit another boat, no damage in the 4 years I had her (the boat, not my wife..)
You will save a ton of money staying single (no pun intended) rather than going twin.
Good luck, it's a beautiful boat!!!

Ed
 
I also owned 2002 a Fiesta V 270 for 3 years with the single 300 hp. With the brava III, and the larger engine, it will be fine. I agree, occasionally I had to ask large crew members to come foreward to get on a plane, but with normal family, it was no problem. It was a good boat, and I had no problems. Disagree about resale. I sold it for only a couple of thousand less than I paid for it, after the 3 years. Cost less than $1000 a year in depreciation--pretty hard to beat that.

I found it easy to manuever. The Duo prop with no prop walk steers the boat very precisely--there is some windage from the express cruiser type of high hull profile. I prefer a pilot house boat and that is what I switched to--with outboards because of having to go over a sand bar each time I leave my house. Is my cat with twin counter rotating outboards easier to maneuver?--yes. But the Rinker was a good boat.
 
KPM

i know the single/twin debate can go on forever but...

yes, many diesel failures come from fuel, usually clogged filters but they rarely clog at the same time so you will usually still be able to keep on going on one engine... in any case this is not relevant here since this thread is about single/twin gas sterndirve.

you're right about single inboard usually having better protection for the running gear (assuming the boat as a keel)... not true on a single IO as the drive is hanging below the bottom. Some twin inboard have some protection for the running gear, it depends on the hull design.

i wouldn't worry too much about the risk of running a single engine boat, even a gas IO. my first boat was a single and i used to go out fishing 20 or 25 miles out the atlantic... never had an issue altough we'd know that the trade winds would bring us back to the islands in case of an engine failure :-)
 
yeah, Pascal, I know the debate can go on forever and I don't like to be argumentative (especially on the internet), so I'll leave it be. Really, I was speaking on more general terms of single vs. twin, rather than the specifics with these boats, which is my mistake.

Happy boating! (the weather up here needs to get better before that will happen, ugh)
 
Go to the Regal Forum on this site. There are a TON of folks on the Georgian Bay who could give you some first hand experience as to the pro's and con's of your potential decision.
 
Some day you will want to sell and move up. Single engine used boats in that size don't sell nearly a well as twins. .
 
Chris P, I think you made an excellent choice with the Rinker single. The dual prop will will be a big plus for close-in handling. You'll save on fuel allowing you to get out and do more boating. Twin engines have advantages, but they also have twice the mechanical problems of a single.

On single engine, single screw inboards, it's another story. If you have substanitial current or wind these boats tend to get a little hairy from 28-30' and larger. A skilled skipper can handle them at this size with ease, but practically speaking those skippers are a minority. I know people who take to handling larger single screw inboards intuitively, some others that eventually learn, and more that never really get it.

That Rinker is a nice looking boat, too.
 
Back
Top