Sinking Boat

bmaas00

Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2008
RO Number
29274
Messages
21
I took my boat into the shipyard last weekend due to a failing mid bilge float ship and an unusually large amount of water accumulating in the bid bilge in over a 24 hour period. I would come down to the boat every night after work to check on the water level and after 5 minutes of bilging it was empty. I timed it for 5 days in a row and there was never more than a minute, plus or minus, difference in the time it took to bilge. I checked the usual suspects - thru hulls, packing on both engines, exhaust leaks and couldn't find anything. Fortunately, the ship yard wasn't backed up and I was able to get an appointment to drop the boat off within a few days. It's now safely in dry dock being inspected.

While my boat was en route to sinking I was fortunate enough to catch the problem before it turned in to anything serious. However, there was another boat not too far from mine that wasn't so fortunate. This was the first boat I've ever seen (in person) that sunk in it's slip. I've certainly heard of it happening and seen a few pictures online but never seen it first hand. I have to say it was rather upsetting. I don't even know who the poor owner was but I just tried to put myself in his/her shoes and needless to say I can't imagine what I would do if it were me. I posted some of the pictures online here: http://www.uniflite.blogspot.com
 
I bought a boat from the Dock master that had sunk at its moorage.
I asked why they didnt pump it out for him when they saw it was sinking.
He almost slugged me in anger.
He'd spent a lot of time and money pumping it and trying to get hold of the owner. Finally he sent the required special delivery notice and when that was returned 'not here' he just let er sink till it could be put up for auction.
Find out what the Moorage policy is on that type of a problem.
 
First of all I would consider changing your main bige pump to an auto bilge that required no switch. It does this by turning on for a few seconds every couple of minutes to sense for water. If non detected then shuts it's self back off. No switch to fail, jam, screw up your zincs,etc.

Leaks are not always caused by underwater sources. Deak leaks around railings can get down to the bilge. The hull to deck joint can leak allowing wind driven rain, waves, etc to enter your boat. Leaking windows or other hardware can allow water to enter the bilge.

It may be alittle late now but if you spend the weekend on the boat do this... First dry the bilge as best as possible. Then lay some paper towels all around the bilge pump. Might want to get a hose and spray down the outside of the boat real good. Watch which towel starts to get wet and slowly work back.

Dave
 
"changing your main bige pump to an auto bilge that required no switch."

My boat has this type of pump in the forward bilge. I like it. Turns on about every 4 or 5 minutes and runs about one second.

G
 
quote:

Originally posted by Wingspar

First of all I would consider changing your main bige pump to an auto bilge that required no switch. It does this by turning on for a few seconds every couple of minutes to sense for water. If non detected then shuts it's self back off. No switch to fail, jam, screw up your zincs,etc.






I didn't even know such a bilge pump existed but that makes a heck of a lot more sense than hoping my float switches are going to do their job. I had initially thought that rain was the cause or perhaps my fresh water tank was leaking. Unfortunately, during the week that I was going down to the boat after work there were 2 days in a row that it didn't rain at all and still bilged for at least 5 minutes. The fresh water tank was emptied early in the week to eliminate that as the cause. It's been really frustrating not being able to find out what's slowly sinking your boat. Fortunately it's safe on land for now.
 
http://boatfix.com/catalog/566.pdf I've got the (Rule 51s).

Keep us posted on your progress in resolving your leakage. I'm interested in waht the final outcome is.

dave
 
standard rule pumps with float switch work well, they rarely fail... regardless of the pump that you use, there should ALWAYS be a back up. Unfortunately most boats dont have backups and owners dont' regularly check their pumps and float switches.

it's going to be tough to find the source of the leak while hauled out unless it's real obvious... water can sometimes travel quite a distance... I once had a forward bilge pump cycling on a 37 footer. turned out to be a missing screw from a transom transducer and water was traveling 15' forward not coming out in the aft bilge but in the forward bilge. Aft bilge was bone dry !
 
My very first boat, (19' Cruise Craft Cuddy Cabin) sank in her slip. What a sad
view that was! Turned out to be a broken stern plug. When I saw her I just sat in front
of the slip for about 10 minutes figuring what to do. Now I allways check my automatic
bilge pumps (all 4 of them) every time I get aboard. (Sunk boat paranoia syndrome)
Cheers,
Harold
 
Bear in mind you also need a backup for the shore power. When the batteries go dead, it doesn't matter how many pumps you have.
 
My Air Dock prevents my boat from sinking, even if it gets water inside.
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

Bear in mind you also need a backup for the shore power. When the batteries go dead, it doesn't matter how many pumps you have.






What would be the best form of backup?
 
quote:

Originally posted by bmaas00

quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

Bear in mind you also need a backup for the shore power. When the batteries go dead, it doesn't matter how many pumps you have.






What would be the best form of backup?







An Air Dock floats your boat even when deflated.
 
So what's with all the broken glass on that boat's deck? (Looking at the pics in the link).
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

Bear in mind you also need a backup for the shore power. When the batteries go dead, it doesn't matter how many pumps you have.





You are right.
I forgot to mention, Now we live within walking distance of the marina and I go every day to check it.
No, I do not leave the charger on. The boat has 2 pumps connected to the "house" battery (8D) and the other 2 connected to each starting battery (8D's ) too. All float switches are at staggered levels and a 5th float switch acts as a flood alarm set at 3 inches. Security at the marina is instructed to call me if the buzzer goes off. The Genset set uses a 4th battery so it will start even if all other 3 batteries are down. Am I paranoid? :)
Cheers,
Harold
 
I've seen boats sink for the dumbist reasons. I guess the one that wins the prize was the boat owner that came down to his boat and found a couple feet of water in the bilge. His bilge pump had quit so he rigged up a portable bilge pump with a long hose. Dropped the discharge end over the side and started pumping. Well when he pumped out all the water, he disconnected the pump and left. Never noticing the discharge line was below the outside water level and the water started siphoning back into the boat. I got a call from a panic'ed boat owner the next morning about his sunk boat. We raised it and when he realized what had sunk it the second time, boy did he feel dumb.
Easiest way to keep your boat from sinking, rig a float switch to the boat's horn. If the water gets too high, the horn starts blowing and someone will discover the problem before it hits bottom.
 
Backup??? Solar panels work for me.
I also have a LOUD alarm running off a separate battery.
 
quote:

Originally posted by b_arrington

So what's with all the broken glass on that boat's deck? (Looking at the pics in the link).






I was wondering the same thing when I first saw that. As I walked down the dock I noticed another empty slip that had a bunch of floating wood particles in it. Looking closer I could tell it was pieces of the sinking boat. It appeared that there was a wood and glass wind screen that was either blown off by the wind (unlikely) or, as the boat sunk and things started shifting it just buckled under the pressure and separated from the boat a drifted away.

I'm heading back down there today to see how things are going with my boat and change the zincs while it's in dry dock. I'll see if they've raised the boat yet.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Wingspar

http://boatfix.com/catalog/566.pdf

I've got the (Rule 51s).

Keep us posted on your progress in resolving your leakage. I'm interested in waht the final outcome is.

dave






Howdy everyone. I finally got my boat out of hock at the yard. Had some plumbing work done that took them forever in addition to the water leak problem.

So the leak problem was due to some rotted out holes where my large zinc (divers dream) is mounted on the transom. Water had slowly made its way in around the bolts that go all the way through the transom. Both holes were ground out and re-sealed.

I still never actually saw water coming in from there but didn't specifically look there either. Either way, I hope this is useful info for someone else out there.

The boat is back in the water and the bilge is basically dry, minus the normal packing drip water. Warm weather is finally here in San Francisco (at least as warm as it gets) so I'm sure I'll be posting some more questions soon.

Thanks for everyone's input on this.

- Bryan
 
Air Docks can in fact cause sinkings. There are several recorded cases when a chamber has become uninflated. The remaining inflated chambers either capsize the boat, or tilted the boat at such a severe angle that waves and wakes swamped the boat. I would not use an Air Dock without daily observation, which is the same with a boat in the water. The reason to use an Air Dock is ease of bottom maintenance, not to prevent sinkings.
 
Back
Top