Slow Pirates?

quote:

Originally posted by BillM2

How does an ocean liner loaded with 1,000 passengers outrun two "speed boats"?




it has a cruise speed of 18-20 knots so should be able to do 10-30% better than that at WOT
if they were in rough water they can make those speeds where a small boats will get the snot beat out of them and wont be able to maintain any real speed
 
well from the pictures I have seen of the pirstes speedboats, they are little more then wooden skiffs with an outboard. All you need is a little rough seas and an ocean liner that can do 20kts and I think it is no problem. More then 16,000 ships pass through the strait of Aden annually, less then 1% ever come even in contact with pirates.
 
My guess is that the sea conditions had a lot to do with it and once the pirates realized that they would not be able to board the ship, they gave up.
 
Then I guess the reporter in this story should have offered a better detail of the pursuing pirates. A wooden skiff with an outboard doesn't necessarily bring to mind speed boat. Unfortunately, these pirates and their ilk now realize they need a faster boat. Might be time to load passenger ships with some hefty arms.
 
quote:

Originally posted by BillM2

Might be time to load passenger ships with some hefty arms.




Some ships have LRAD's
http://www.spiegel.de/international/spiegel/0,1518,385048,00.html
0,1020,542091,00.jpg
 
"Might be time to load passenger ships with some hefty arms."

And lacking those trained to use them, what do you suggest they do with them?

I like that sonic canon thing - can I get one for my house?
 
They should have some crew members trained in 50 caliber weapons and have a few of those mounted on the ships. :)
 
quote:

Originally posted by C team

They should have some crew members trained in 50 caliber weapons and have a few of those mounted on the ships. :)






I honestly do not know why they don't. When I was in Hong Kong over 20 years ago, we (the wardroom) had lunch aboard a shipyard owners 100+ footer. He had a crew served weapon mounted on the bow for protection when traversing the South China Sea.
 
Merchant sailors are not warriors. It's hard enough now to get experienced, quality, well trained crewmembers. Tell them they will have to man weapons and they will just go to the company next door and hire on where defensive action is not required. I would bet that on most of these "pirate" events some crew member of the vessel captured, is involved and tips off the thugs on the location, speed and best time to board. Personal Sat phones and cell phones are carried by many vessel crew members and "one call, thats all".
 
A couple years ago a cruise ship off the coast of Nigeria was chased down and failed to board.
The ship turned off it's stabalizers and got more speed out of the ship.
If I remember correctly, the ship got up to around 32 knots, but cruised at 22 knots.
 
I believe one of those LRAD's was successfully used in deterring a boarding within the last few years.
 
What's wrong with a couple of carriers patrolling there. Have some jets in the air. First sign of trouble, like with this cruise ship, send the jet. Couple of missiles and goodbye buccaneers.

-Greg
 
How does one board a ship underway that does not wish to be boarded from a small boat? In anything but very calm sea a small boat will have a tough time keeping up with a ship such as this. How much damage could small arms do to it & how could they get an accurate shot from a bouncing small boat?

Keeping a couple 50cal onboard the ship, to be brought out & mounted if ever needed, seems like a pretty good idea. With a couple of trained officers to use them & knowledge that such a weapon is likely onboard, the pirates/terrorists will have something to think about.
 
That's a good point. If no one drops a jacob's ladder, how do you scale the side a of a cruise ship unless you fire a grapling hook with a line on it.
 
This was from another attempt...pretty cool picture.

The remnants of a rocket propelled grenade (RPG) shown after striking the cruise liner Seabourn Spirit

450pxseabournspiritrockhd9.jpg
 
I never understood how those guys manage to get on board so easily from the side of a big tanker.
I personally saw a professional pilot boarding a container ship from the side and it was not easy even for someone who does that for a living and with the crew helping.
 
A tanker has a lower freeboard than a container ship. They approach from the stern quarter and throw a grapnel over the rail. Once you get a couple of guys aboard with AK's the rest is academic.
 
Now that the Arab World--whatever that really is--is involved on both the pirates'end and the ship owner's end, I believe it is best for we poor Anglos to stand back and watch the show develop. The answer IMO lies ashore, within the failed governments of that part of the world. I believe that Piracy is a nasty byproduct of the p-poor living condiditions and lawless activities of all levels of government, from the tribe up to the peusdo-nation. Let them all fight/work/bribe their ways out of this themselves.

For those who want aircraft carriers---wake up to the ecconomic realities of life.
 
quote:

Originally posted by saltysam

Now that the Arab World--whatever that really is--is involved on both the pirates'end and the ship owner's end, I believe it is best for we poor Anglos to stand back and watch the show develop. The answer IMO lies ashore, within the failed governments of that part of the world. I believe that Piracy is a nasty byproduct of the p-poor living condiditions and lawless activities of all levels of government, from the tribe up to the peusdo-nation. Let them all fight/work/bribe their ways out of this themselves.

For those who want aircraft carriers---wake up to the ecconomic realities of life.






Here's some economic realities.

1. We have aircraft carriers and we pay for them, regardless of where they are deployed.

2. The last attack was against a US cruise liner.

3. If tankers must divert around the horn, then oil prices could rise, reflecting increased shipping costs and limiting their ability to supply demand, thus raising oil prices again.

Given this, are you sure it's strictly an Arab/Africa problem?

-Greg
 
Back
Top