Smoking Cummins

andreboats

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 3, 2007
RO Number
24757
Messages
50
A friend as a 1998 regal 402 whit 365HP Cummins, this engines are producing lots of dark smoke.
Engines are in top shape as the Cummins tech says and the dark smoke is normal.

Any of you guys have an idea on reducing the smoking???
 
Start by getting a real Cummins technician. Black smoke, or even dark smoke, is not normal. A hp rating or 365 is not normal either. A rating of 355 SAE hp which is equal to 370 metric hp is common.

Black smoke is carbon left over from incomplete combustion. You are over fueling or under supplying air. You are overloaded, usually by being over propped, or you are starving the engine for air commonly by having a bad turbo or a blocked air filter.
 
As a Cummins owner, no, smoke is not normal. Smoke is produced by all the reasons rbmitchell has listed. The only time I get a puff of smoke is after a period of slow running & I accelerate past the 12 to 1600rpm mark. This smoke quickly clears.
 
black smoke is indeed incomplete combustion or overloading (how clean is the running gear?) but i've seen black smoke with dirty racors. it takes a few minutes to replace the fuel filters (primaries and secondaries), try that first.
 
Off the top of my head
1. Overpropped
2. Dirty Bottom or too much weight,,,, See #1
3. Dirty Aftercoolers
4. Dirty air filters
5. all of the above
If it will not make 105% of WOT rpms start on the list or the engine is going to have a short life.
 
Low cetane level (poor quality diesel) can cause heavy sooting and black smoke.
 
If it smokes bad from both engines, then it sounds common to both, what ever it is.
 
quote:

Originally posted by rduhon

If it smokes bad from both engines, then it sounds common to both, what ever it is.






Nice Yogi, both ya think.

Actually, if you put a drag on one engine, both will suffer. Overload one and the other will also overload just trying to make up the loss. Blowby in the engine room will coat both filters.
 
Yogi thinks it can be worn turbochargers also.
 
I'll add one thing. A leaking head gasket. I had this one, and all the others mentioned above. Black smoke to port and white smoke to starboard! All fixed now. and can relay detailed info on both.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Skeetobite

I'll add one thing. A leaking head gasket. I had this one, and all the others mentioned above. Black smoke to port and white smoke to starboard! All fixed now. and can relay detailed info on both.






that is logical as the starboard did not produce sufficient power, thus overloading the port.

although we have almost the same boat, the motors are slightly different, mine are 6CTA's. when the turbo's are spooling up the motors are overloaded and do smoke heavily. once the turbo's wind up, there is enough HP to push the boat on to plane and the smoking stops. again a sign of insufficient air and as others have noted and unburned fuel.
 
Checking the turbo is pretty quick and easy.
If it is where you can get to it easily.
 
While I'm not a mechanic, my experience specific to my own boat has been that the black smoke is almost always due to lack of combustion air or proper compression. The white smoke is the unburned fuel. I had the white smoke due to dirty injectors, followed by the fuel shut off cylinder sticking (replaced for $130) I would have a compression check on each cylinder before opening my wallet very wide. You can also check your turbos. Sometimes "blow-by" can build up on the edges of the blades, causing them to spool more slowly, resulting in a sooty black smoke. Had that one too ;-)
 
Thanks guys, so I guess the story of smoke being normal on pre electronic cummins engines is crap...
 
I get a tiny puff of black smoke when I add load to come up on plane. After that, none that is visible. although I still get some soot around the exhaust ports. So yeah, I guess the stories are crap. My boat used to look like a city transit bus, but after two years of tinkering she's gone green, so to speak ;-)

The more I think about it, your buddy's boat sounds over propped. I would check the OEM specs against what he has in place. My spec was 18/19 and the prior owner installed 19/18. This resulted in not only black smoke, but the boat missed the max RPM spec by nearly 300 on each engine due to the change. That won't sound like alot to a gas boater, but the reality on a diesel is that it shaves about 3.5 knots off the top speed of the boat as well (in my configuration).
 
Start with the simplest thing first: check the bottom and running gear for growth!
 
I started getting some smoke from my engines when I loaded all my liveabord stuff on the boat.
Dropped an inch of prop pitch and changed to a front mounted crankcase vent instead of the old low rear vent and
upgraded to the high volume K&N filters used on the 1997 Dodge diesel trucks. (RC4780)
No Brown smoke at cruise. Added Wolverine 250 watt oil pan heaters and now there is very little white smoke at startup.

knn-rc-4780_w.jpg

This is a better setup than the old Walker Air sep a I take the blowby from the quieter area at the front case rather than the rear whre there can be splashing if the the oil level is too full or even at the correct mark if the engines are mounted bow high.

Google Seaboard marine envirovent for the article.
 
Back
Top