Sore Subject

Tanqueray

Active member
exMember
Joined
Apr 21, 2005
RO Number
17091
Messages
1,713
GAS......
I was just thinking that the majority...no...not even the majority....ALL of the Gas Stations (around this area at least) always advertise their prices for the Cheapest Gas they have. (which I understand) Unfortunately that Gas is 87 Octane and I believe that there are even some stations that have 86 Octane available.
I don't know about newer boats and the newer engines but how many of you guys/gals can actually run their boats on 87 Octane Gas?
I know I can't. Now what's bothering me is that the price of Gas that we're seeing at the Marina Fuel Docks by and large is undoubdtedly going to be 87 Octane and figure on 15-20 cents more per gallon for 89 Octane. Like I said...I don't know about the newer boats and engines but mine is an 88 with 350's and if I try to run anything less than a minimum of 89 Octane the engines ping and rattle and just generally don't perform well and I'm sure that it HAS to be causing some type of damage to the cylinders.
Have any of you tried any of these Octane Boosters that are available and do they really work well. If so....is the cost of the additive really a savings over the price of the more expensive higher octane fuel? I'm thinking seriously of starting to take my 5 gallon can with me to work at night and getting 5 gallons of 91 or so Octane at a time till I splash next week as a starter for the first fill of the season. Hell....I may even borrow a couple of cans for a few days and make a couple of trips a day....lol...
 
unless your supercharged 87 will work well if the timing is right or at least on the soft side timing must be checked at 4000 rpm
 
-- I have 2007 Merc 6.2 MPI Horizons in Saint Max. They are made to run on 87 octane fuel.

-- I can't speek to whether the octane boosters are snake oil or not, however, mathmetically where I boat, the cost between octane boosters added to regular gas comes out to be a wash when compared to buying 93 octane from the pump.

-- You won't be alone making the 5 gallon can trip to the boat. Folks have been doing it here all winter with both gas and diesel. Some folks at the club have been known to do it year round. The cost differential is that great. Where I berth, the owner tries to keep fuel within 30 cents of the street and doesn't change prices until he refills his tanks. Talking to dockmates, it appears the total gallonage sold will be down this year.
 
I doubt you save any money by using the additive approach - at least when I did the calc's in the past it never paid off.

I only see two fuel docks in my area - the one in our marina and one I pass in the main channel on the way out. There are others, I just don't see them. In our marina the only gas is 89 octane. At the other doc it's 89 or Shell V-Power which I believe is 93. Typically our marina is 5-10 cents per gallon less than the other big fuel doc, and at our marina the typical 89 price is about $0.50 per gal above street 87 octane when prices change - the marina only changes prices when they get a new load of fuel. The price at the marina changed over the weekend - local street average for 87 is about $3.43, the new marina price is $3.95.
 
The owners manual on my 454 Crusader XLs calls for 87 octane. It also states that is what the engine timing is set for.
 
I have a 1991 Merc 4.3L V6. The manual specifically says to use nothing lower then 89 octane fuel.

All the fuel docks in my area offer 89 and 91 octane. I do not purchase fuel from auto gas stations to fuel my boat.
 
WHY???? a boat with a V6 couldn't be much longer than 19' and it makes so much sense to fill up at an auto gas station. The fuel is so much fresher and LESS EXPENSIVE. I can't think of any rational reason NOT to fill up at an auto gas station even if I had to borrow a trailer.
 
put 110 gallons of 87 octaine (per manual spec) in last night at the courtesy dock, saved at least $110 over the marina gouging. it was quick, easy and safe.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Captain Buddha

put 110 gallons of 87 octaine (per manual spec) in last night at the courtesy dock, saved at least $110 over the marina gouging. it was quick, easy and safe.






22 five gallon cans or a tank on your truck?
 
quote:

Originally posted by CA Gresham

WHY???? a boat with a V6 couldn't be much longer than 19' and it makes so much sense to fill up at an auto gas station. The fuel is so much fresher and LESS EXPENSIVE. I can't think of any rational reason NOT to fill up at an auto gas station even if I had to borrow a trailer.






Rommer had a 28 or so with twin V-6's that flew. You would be surprised at the power you can get out of a small block these days.
 
22' boat David. If you use it hard on the weekend you can pay for a slip with what you save by using auto gas station fuel.
 
quote:

Originally posted by CA Gresham

22' boat David. If you use it hard on the weekend you can pay for a slip with what you save by using auto gas station fuel.






Agree, however, one has to make the assumption Flutterby has a trailer and desires to haul to an auto gas station. I don't know if she has a trailer but I do know she has slipped her boat for at least 10 years.

(http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=114058)

It may just not be worth the aggravation or the fine should she spill some fuel in the water. I know where I boat, even DNR will cut you some slack if you are filling at the dock and there is a slight accidental spill or vent burp. However, if you are filling out of a 5 gallon can and blow it, it's all over but the crying.

It's all a matter of choice I suppose.
 
quote:

Originally posted by CA Gresham

22' boat David. If you use it hard on the weekend you can pay for a slip with what you save by using auto gas station fuel.






I slipped my old boat and also had a trailer for it. Never filled up with auto gas station fuel except when it went in for the season and came out for the season.

Option A
The time and aggrevation simply is not worth it. I would have to bring the trailer to the boat ramp. Somehow get from the ramp to the marina. Bring boat to boat ramp. Deal with people at boat ramp. Haul boat out and go to gas station. Back to boat ramp to launch boat. Launch boat and return to marina. I now have to somehow get back to the boat ramp to get my truck/trailer.

Or, option B, fill at the fuel dock and be half way to the grounds before completing option a.
 
Tanqy,
Your engine is designed to run on 87 octane. If it's knocking, you have other things causing it. It can be anything from carbon build-up on pistons(increasing compression), Too advanced timing. Under Too lean fuel/air mixture, you can have Low float setting, Intake air leak, Fuel pump weak, air leak/restriction in intake side of fuel system.

Read your plugs.
 
InTheKnow is correct regarding my situation. Also, I do not have a hitch on my Subaru Outback, so I cannot tow it myself.

On other thing, the main difference between cost of auto gas vs marine gas are the taxes levied by Fed and State. And those taxes, for the most part, go to fund projects which is marine related. Go to Boat US dot com government site for details.

My vehicle supports transportation costs, my boat support marine costs somewhat.
 
I heard something about the ethanol levels in street gas compared with marina gas. Could be a bunch of bull but I heard that 0% ethanol gas (found at marinas) is better for a boat.

MN for one requires a certain amount of ethanol in all street gas - not just E-85.

True???
 
"Could be a bunch of bull but I heard that 0% ethanol gas (found at marinas) is better for a boat."

Here it makes no difference if it is a land station or a marina station - you are getting 10% ethanol.

No idea about the rest of the country.
 
In CA marine gasoline is exactly the same stuff as auto gasoline. The only difference is the additional tax and mark-up on the marine gas. Octane isn't much of an issue for me. The 1947 engine in my boat was designed to run on 70-80 octane.
 
Back
Top