Source for class BC fire extinguishers?

JoeBTB

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
517
Messages
711
Anyone know where to find a good 40-BC fire extinguisher?

I've always read that you don't really want to use a class A fire extinguisher on a boat, but the only pure BC-rated extinguishers that I can find are tiny, like 5BC or 10BC. I'd like at least one 40 on board.
 
http://www.boatfix.com/bykeywordnew2.asp?textfield=KID46616401&texttype=2&submit=Search
 
Yeah, I've seen that one, but it's a tri-class. Any opinions on tri-class vs. BC?
 
OK, this made me do some research.

The dry chemical Mono Ammonium Phosphate (Acidic) type extinguishers are the only dry chemical extinguishers which cover classes A, B and C.

This agent is corrosive, and it is rated class A because of it's ability to get into equipment it's used on. For these same reasons, it's not recommended for marine use.
 
I have -not- heard that you should not use A-B-C extinguishers on boats.

That said, dry chemical extinguisher chemicals certainly are corrosive.

The non-corrosive types are usually gaseous ( or water based foam ) such as CO2 or Halon derivative/replacements.

If memory serves me correctly, those small extinguishers ( 5BC and 10BC ) are not labeled as ABC not because of a different chemistry, but because they do not contain a sufficient volume of dry chemical to qualify for an "A" rate. ie: they are also dry chemical, and the product is corrosive.

--

I wonder about the need for a 40lb extinguisher. They are heavy and would be difficult to use for most people, which is the likely reason you do not see 40 lb portable extinguishers.

What application are you looking for, specifically? YOu can get fairly large CO2 extinguishers, including portables. In large sizes you can get built-in systems using CO2 or Halon-equivalent.
 
Eh, maybe 40 is overkill. Or maybe I'll get one or two 10BC, and a 2A40BC backup. The "A" is apparently corrosive and destructive to electrical.

Dry chemical extinguishers come in three varieties. Sodium Bicarbonate B, C (Alkaline); Potassium Bicarbonate, Purple "K", B, C (Alkaline); and Mono Ammonium Phosphate A, B, C (Acidic).

The A, B, C dry chemical is not recommended for marine use for two reasons:

* It is corrosive
* The way in which this agent obtains it class A rating is its ability to melt, seep and encase. This necessitates dismantling of equipment to repair or rebuild.
 
Of course, it does not matter if it is corrosive if the boat burns to the waterline and sinks.

My preference is Purple K, which is absolutley miserable to clean up. Bu I have seen it in action, and it definitely will extinguish flames.

It really depends on what the primary risk is and how you intend to use it. Each had it's place. Your raw water washdown pump forms a wonderful way to extinguish a bedding fire, while you could likely use all 40 lbs of a dry chem extinguisher and still not control it completely.

So, examine what you are trying to do, and tailor your extinguishing equipment to match the risk. Gaseous extinguishers are "clean" but except in an enclosed area are not very good. And in an enclosed compartment, you will have a breaathing problem when you use the gaseous types.

Know the product, know your risks, get the right product for the risk.
 
JoeBTB, not jumping on you, but you do realise that your extinguisher package will not effectively fight a Class A fire such as: wood, fiberglass or clothing/bedding, all of which are all over most boats.

Water is effective for Class A. On many larger boats, your raw water washdown pump is available ( if the hose is long enough! ). Please study the issue carefully and be safe.
 
Bill, I see your point, so it seems logical to have a tri-class aboard as well. My main concern is an engine room or electrical fire. By the time wood, fiberglass, or bedding is on fire, it's likely too late for me to do anything about it, and I'll be abandoning ship. Galley is probably an exception to that -- probably want an ABC for many materials there.

Thanks for the help.
 
Back
Top