Speed?

Pete, see my previous post comparing my 220HP Larson (50mph) vs. a similar 220HP StingRay (65mph). Stingray's hull is designed for speed, the Larson is designed for a more all-around ride. The only real difference is the hull design, and that gets Stingray 15mph more speed.
 
Your right. I dont have the slightest idea about factors that influence boat propulsion. So One of my questions is still IS my new boat like driving in over drive and the old like dirving in low? Meaning does my bravo have differnt gearing comparred to the alpha?

One of the things I am wondering is how much difference in speed is related to prop slip and how much faster is the prop on the bravo drive actually turning in the water.

BTW the Baja has a 454 magnum engine. But do you guys understand the The engine size in this comparrision is irrelevant....My point is that both engines are turning at 4800 RpM so what if it takes 800 hp to get the rpms to that point. The rpms are converted by some ratio to prop RpMs then in trun theoreticlly goes through the water based on the pitch of the prop. And if I understand correctly prop slip is what keeps the vessel for attaining the theoretical speed. The amount of slip stems from factors like hull design weight waterdensity trim position and so on.

In the end I am just doing all of this because I want to know and understand more.
 
quote:

Originally posted by drpete3

But do you guys understand the The engine size in this comparrision is irrelevant.





Sorry to say but that is about as wrong as you can be.
 
You defintely need to get the gear ratios from the drives to understand better. Usually, they're printed on a plate attached to the drive, but after almost 20 years, that plate may not be there.
 
Higher horsepower engine can turn bigger pitch prop faster example
4800 * .5 = 2400 Prop RPM (assumes 2 to 1 ratio)
2400 * 21 * 60 / 12 / 5280 = 47.7 MPH (assumes no slippage to make things easier to see)

Lower horsepower engine can only turn smaller pitch prop not as fast
4800 * .42 = 2000 Prop Rpm (assumes 2.4 to 1 ratio)
2000 * 19 * 60 / 12 / 5280 = 35.9 MPH (assumes no slippage to make things easier to see)

Both engines turning 4800RPM, NEITHER prop is turning 4800RPM

Engine size matters. It's fact not fiction!
 
LONG POST

You also have to take into consideration the ACTUAL weight of the boat vs the advertised weight. If you were to run them both over a set of scales, I think you would be amazed at the real difference.

There are a couple of differences in a 454 turning an engine to 4800 RPMs and a 305 turning a prop to 4800 RPMs...Horsepower and torque. A boat is at constant battle with friction and gravity. My Mom's deacon used to race as a hobby. I remember asking him why he spent so much time in the air going over waves. His answer was because it's faster than going through them. That takes care of the friction. as for gravity, the more horsepower you have to the prop, the faster you go. The faster you go, the less wetted surface you have dragging in the water (oops...there's that friction thing again)...The less wetted surface dragging in the water, the faster you go until you reach the physical point that the boat can not go any faster because it has no more power.

As for hull design, that plays a HUGE part in performance. Let's just say for the sake of argument your 454 in your 24 degree deep V BAJA puts out 300HP at 4800 RPMS. Now lets say a person in a 22' Ranger Bass Boat with a 300HP Suzuki outboard pulls up beside you. When he throttles his Ranger to whatever RPM will produce 300 HP, he is going to walk away from you because even if he was loaded down with enough gear an fish to equal the weight of your Baja, the hull is flatter at the transom and easier to push over the water.

If you want to experiment yourself, tuck your drive all the way in and lower your tabs all the way and see how that effects you boats handling and speed (CAREFUL ON THE SPEED!!!!YOU COULD EASILY BURY THE BOW AND FLIP THE BOAT!!!) Reset your tabs to half way up and 1/2 trim on the drive. You will notice a world of difference due to the change in hull configuration.

HTH
 
Back
Top