Stand On Moron

Prospective

Active member
Joined
Sep 7, 2006
RO Number
23085
Messages
1,343
I had a great cruise down to Newport yesterday. The water was increadibly and unusually smooth for Narragansett Bay and the Family and I had not used the boat in a couple of weeks. Gotta love Soccer season.

Anyway, as many of you know, I am a new powerboater, just finishing up my first season of ownership. But I have really tried to do as much right as possible.

At any rate, while cruising down at 28knts with my 9 year old daughter on my lap, I was explaining some rules of the road. Pointing to the right side of the boat I explained that we need to move out of the way for folks coming from that direction. Pointing to my left I said, those folks need to avoid us and we need to maintain course. Cool Dad!

Then this 24ft crownline comes toward us from our 10 o'clock. I tell her to maintain course. Still coming, still coming, finally he takes our stern about 25ft away on plane. I stair back at him to figure out why he would come that close and he raises his hand at me as if to say "thanks idiot". I actually had to consult my notes later to make sure I was the stand-on boat, I was so amazed.

My question, this guy looked to be about 40ish. How could someone spend even a week on the water and not learn this basic rule by accident. Forget a boater course or reading a book. You would think after a weekend of getting cut off, you would figure it out.
 
25' Yikes! You also need to teach your daughter that not everyone knows the rules so you have to make sure and take a defensive stand. If you see another boater headed toward you, alter course for goodness sake...don't hope he's awake, sober and planning to buzz your stern.
 
quote:

Originally posted by WALSHIE

25' Yikes! You also need to teach your daughter that not everyone knows the rules so you have to make sure and take a defensive stand. If you see another boater headed toward you, alter course for goodness sake...don't hope he's awake, sober and planning to buzz your stern.






I hear ya, I was fully prepared to miss the guy by moving, that's when he changed course and took my stern. Once he's behind me there's not much I can do increase the distance other than speed up. I figured, no collision, if he wants to pound over my wake that's his problem.
 
It is your fault as a new boater. Your mistake was to think another boater actually knows the stand on, give way rules.
This season I avoided two collisions with 45 ish fly bridge boats. You would think a captain of a boat like that would be experienced enough, but no.
One time I changed course and passed behind the other vessel. One time I blasted 5 short blasts because I could not change course in the narrow channel.
you know what happens when you asuume.
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

Did this happen just off the Northern tip of Jamestown?






ITK, it was off of the east side of Prudence. I was in the providence channel heading south, he was cutting accross the channel going west toward potters cover.
 
Thanks - I witnessed a similar incident just North of Jamestown yesterday
 
quote:

Originally posted by billybokay

It is your fault as a new boater. Your mistake was to think another boater actually knows the stand on, give way rules.
This season I avoided two collisions with 45 ish fly bridge boats. You would think a captain of a boat like that would be experienced enough, but no.
One time I changed course and passed behind the other vessel. One time I blasted 5 short blasts because I could not change course in the narrow channel.
you know what happens when you asuume.






Folks, I did not assume that he knew the rules and I am aware that ultimatly we all are responsible for avoiding a collision. But Stand On means Stand On until you think a collision may occure. I was prepared to move when he took my stern. He choose to get that close to me, not the other way around.

My point it that this guy actually though HE had "the right of way" How could you not just accidently learn this basic rule after a weekend of getting cut off.

If you never drove in a car before, you would figure out the red light green light thing pretty quick.
 
In my estimate only 50 percent of boaters even know there are any rules of the road and only 10 percent know what some of the rules are. However, 95 percent try to be courteous and avoid close encounters. The other 5 percent represent the same "me-first-jerks" who cut you off on the freeway, get agressive and yell at people to get their own way through intimidation, and lets their dogs run around the neighborhood at night barking at everything. This is a good age and opportunity to teach your daughter a life lesson that some people care very little for others and she must take action to avoid being hurt by their agressive attitude and stupidity. After she learnes defensive boating the act of defensivly driving a car will become second nature. And hope there is karma for the fools that endanger others because of their self importance.

And never again let another boat get within 25 feet of you while on plane; no matter how stupid he is.
 
I encountered a similar display of lack of knowledge of the "rules of the road" this past weekend. I was the give-way vessel, with the 'stand on' vessel approaching on my starboard at a high rate of speed. I slowed to permit his passing. Instead he stopped and waved frantically for me to cross. I held my position, as there was a boat behind him closing rapidly. A radio broadcast on channel 16 was heard "what's your problem yellow boat? are you gonna cross?"

After all was clear, I proceeded to cross at safe speed. Subsequent radio broadcast as I motored by "a$$hole." I was thinking to myself after hearing that, who's the idiot here?
 
The stand-on Rule allows you to take avoiding action the moment you deem the give-way vessel's avoiding action to be at all deficient. Paragraph (a)(ii) is the "may" part of a 3-part "must-may-must" rule. Using it keeps you safely away from the boors and egomaniacs.
 
If someone is approching me at 10 o'clock, I not going to assume he will give way. He may think that it's a head-on situtation and expect me to alter course to starboard and I will. Is 10 o'clock "near head-on", probably not but it's hard to judge that angle exactly. If in doubt then alter course.
 
Coming back from Montauk a few weeks ago, I had a guy in a 46' Post overtaking me on my port side at an angle that would have put him directly into me. He was clearly on autopilot and it was also clear that he was at the helm he did not intend to change course or slow down, so I throttled back and let him pass in front of me.

When my wife looked up and asked why I was slowing down, I pointed him out. She asked if I had the right of way and I told her yes. Whe she asked why he wasn't slowing down I cited the idiot rule which briefly states that if a dangerous situation arises and one party is an idiot and the other is not, the non-idiot needs to take evasive action to protect himself from the idiot.
 
There are also quite a few people who may know "the rules" but don't really care. These same folks drive cars/trucks. Just tonight, we were coming back from the marina and we had a guy weaving through traffic and passed us on the the shoulder. You can't tell me he thought that was right ... he just didn't care.
 
Prospective, just curious, do you know anyone from Prudence Island? I used to own a summer home on the island and used to cruise those waters many years ago. I lived on the east side of the island and my relatives lived on the west side. But everyone knows someone from there.
 
I generally assume the other guy in not paying attention or has lots more insurance than I do so I tend to take evasive action long before a situation becomes a crisis. I'm out there for pleasure not a speed record so unless I'm gonna go into the mud or the rocks I give most folks a wide berth. When in doubt though I will ripple the water with my twin trumpets to get someones attention. I love the obnoxious ripple in my high tone trumpet, sets your hair on end.
 
It's great to hear that your daughter is hanging with the captain learning real life lesson about boating. By the time she's 16 you should be able to sit back relax while she her dad for an afternoon cruise.
 
quote:

Originally posted by lark

If someone is approching me at 10 o'clock, I not going to assume he will give way. He may think that it's a head-on situtation and expect me to alter course to starboard and I will. Is 10 o'clock "near head-on", probably not but it's hard to judge that angle exactly. If in doubt then alter course.






Lark,

Rule 14(c) says that when in doubt of whether a situation is a head-on or not, it shall be assumed that it is a head-on and both vessels must act accordingly. The obvious reason for this is that it doesn't establish a stand-on or give-way vessel, rather both vessels are obligated to alter their course. This is designed to prevent the exact situation you described. Note also in Rule 14(a) that there must be a risk of collision for the head-on situation to exist.

That being said, 10 'o-clock would not normally be considered "head-on". That's about a 60 degree difference in heading (assuming a risk of collision exists) and would most definitely be a crossing situation (the 10 'o-clock vessel being the give-way vessel).
 
Back
Top