Starboarddddd !!!!

PascalG

Moderator
Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2003
RO Number
12212
Messages
12,221
ouch!

maltesefalconcrash.jpg


http://lyonsimaging.smugmug.com/gallery/6142227_HoUAr#386640001_ojnQx
 
Nice yacht... Maybe they forgot to program the "rules" into the computer?
 
I am not familiar with sail to sail RoR. Please enlighten me. Seriously....

HOWEVER.

I see the REAL problem.

1) It's SFO

2) Small Boat v. Big Boat = Jackarse v. Elephant.

3) Small Boat hits Big Boat.

4) Big Boat is at fault because it is Big Boat.

5) Government steps in to support Little Boat while telling Big Boat to GFY.

6) Law suits ensue due to conflict in hull colors.
 
When racing boat on Starboard tack (wind coming from the Starboard side) has the right of way. I assume that these photos were taken during the Lukemia Cup race. No issue of constrained by draft in this case--both sailing vessels. On the other hand....one must use all caution to avoid collision---if it occured, the smaller boat may also be held partly at fault. I always thought that a handy can of red day glow paint to spray the other boat's hull, rather than hitting it, made sense!
 
How that 40 footer did not see the Maltese Falcon and avoid a collision is beyond me. Even if you have the right of way and can probably come out on top in the protest room you still knocked yourself out of the race (and a few future ones) with the boat on the hard at the local boat yard...

Avoid the collision and the ensuing repairs, then protest.
 
Looks like an ordinary port-starboard situation to me, I doubt "racing" rules apply. I'm not familiar with the waters there but the Falcon MIGHT have had a draft restriction...

The small boat was darned lucky... if the Falcon had hit THEM the results would have been a lot different, possibly fatal
 
Check out the other pictures on that sight. The smaller boat sustained some damage to the bow and the larger one to their railing. Assuming the pictures are in timed order, it appears the boys on the Falcon got a good laugh about it. Then they overloaded their tender to go to shore.

http://lyonsimaging.smugmug.com/gallery/6142227_HoUAr#386645644_2YoSE

http://lyonsimaging.smugmug.com/gallery/6142227_HoUAr#386649041_PXAy5

MJK
 
I don't see the day shape for a vessel Constrained by Draft in any of the pictures, and i dont' think it applies in racing, unless the race instructions specifically state so.

they seemed to be pretty far offshore anyway, beyond the banks at the harbor entrance and channel... looks like a classic case of Tonnage Rule arrogance and smaller boat pressing the issue.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG
looks like a classic case of Tonnage Rule arrogance and smaller boat pressing the issue.






If you have ever done any competitive J-24 racing, you can understand how racing can become a full contact sport.

I was once involved in a J-27 event off of Newport in which a major collision occurred at the start (5 boats involved) and a woman lost 3 toes and part of her foot. A massive brawl then broke out at the starting line with crews jumping boat to boat.
 
The "mast abeam" rule has been eliminated from the racing rules for about ten years, for those who might be interested.

The "new rules" were established then and made it slightly simpler to race a sailboat.
 
I think we need a class on the constrained by draft rule. Every time this type of discussion comes up, constrained by draft enters into the discussion.

First, the definition:

(h) The term “vessel constrained by her draft” means a power-driven
vessel which, because of her draft in relation to the available
depth and width of navigable water is severely restricted in her ability
to deviate from the course she is following.

A sailboat can not claim the status unless they are under power. Secondly, it's an international rule only - there is no inland equivalent. I can't tell by looking at the photos but they look like they might be in a bay, inside the line of demarcation. As Pascal notes, even if they were under power, they have to display the appropriate day shape to claim status.

But, unfortunately, the smaller vessel will probably get saddled with the bill. It hit the yacht about midships and did apparently did nothing to avoid the collision. Seems like arrogance on the part of both parties.
 
Permit me to add a "folksey" comment, one learned during a long time running boats/ships: Don't never hit nobody 'less you are ready to foot the Bill.
 
I stand corrected Les; the definition does exclude sailing vessels. Probably not applicable anyway in those particular circumstances.

I agree with Pascal... plain old tonnage arrogance (or failure to keep a lookout).
 
Looking at the 3X version of picture 358 (and pretty much every picture until impact) of the phote sequences the two in the cockpit of the "small" sailboat appear to be visiting with each other and not even see the Falcon. It is interesting to go through 358 through 363 of the photos. The two in the small boat don't seem to have any clue there is another boat anywhere near them until photo 363 which I would caption, "Did we just hit something?"

It would seem they would both be looking forward in those photos if they actually saw the Falcon.

At a certain point it doesn't matter who has the right of way, as a matter of safety you would just change course.
 
If the guys in the little boat did not see the big boat, they must be very chagrined! "But officer, I did not see it!"

duhhhhh

shockface.gif
 
The sloop's captain was heard to exclaim, "Pardon me ....& and do you have any Grey Poupon?".

That's quite a series of photographs. Sure is hard to imagine the sloop didn't notice the approach of the mammoth MF from their windward side. It's obvious plenty of POB the MF noticed the sloop.
 
Back
Top