Starboarddddd !!!!

If they are both on the same tack, doesn't the windward boat have the right away?

Theory being that you can always turn downwind but the options of turning upwind are more limited.

Rod
 
quote:

Originally posted by abdiver

If they are both on the same tack, doesn't the windward boat have the right away?

Theory being that you can always turn downwind but the options of turning upwind are more limited.

Rod






No. If the boats are overlapped, the windward boat must remain clear. If they are not overlapped, the boat astern must stay clear.

Moot point anyway, as the two boats in this scenario were definitely on opposite tacks.
 
"Check out the other pictures on that sight."

Ah yes, now I see. Didn't go that deep into the photos.
 
KKMI will do the repairs and the rumor is that the quote is around $100K.
Even a simple scratch will cost a fortune on a $180M yacht.
 
From Latitude 38:

Collision between Falcon and Stand By
October 8, 2008 – San Francisco Bay

According to those aboard Maltese Falcon, including a Bay pilot, the Nordic 40 Stand By T-boned the Falcon after inexplicably luffing up.

Last Saturday there was a collision between the Nordic 40 Stand By and Maltese Falcon on San Francisco Bay. The smaller boat plowed into the 289-ft yacht's starboard beam, damaging a bit of the hull and rail. The top of the mast also punched a hole in one of Falcon's sails. As for the smaller boat, a big chunk was taken out of her bow.
Falcon's cap rail and a little bit of her hull took the brunt of the damage from Stand By's bow.
Falcon's crew was up till 1 a.m. repairing the hole Stand By's mast punched in one of the big yacht's 15 sails. The repair had to be done with the sail in place.

We haven't been able to locate the skipper of Stand By for comment, but Perkins posted his version of what happened on photographer Peter Lyons' website to accompany the many photos Lyons captured of the incident. It reads as follows:

"A few minutes before this photo sequence was taken, the Falcon had turned to port, to give the right of way to the smaller yacht, which was to leeward on the starboard tack. The Stand By was originally on a roughly reciprocal course to that of the Falcon. Prior to the photos shown here, Stand By was bearing away, and the two yachts were on safe courses to pass roughly with a distance of 200 feet separation. After Stand By had sailed past the Falcon's bow, the smaller vessel suddenly rounded up, possibly to tack in order to follow the Falcon, when she lost control. With her main sheeted hard in, the smaller boat was unable to bear away to avoid a collision. A San Francisco Bay Pilot was on the Falcon's bridge overseeing the Falcon's course at all times. The pilot is also an experienced sailor and sailboat owner. Because of the Falcon's tonnage, a licensed pilot is required whenever the yacht is underway, approaching, or inside the Bay. The Stand By did not stop after the collision. The Falcon furled her sails and pursued the 40-footer under power, in order to determine her name and registration number. The pilot radioed the U.S. Coast Guard, which intercepted Stand By and boarded her. The accident was caused by Stand By's sudden change of course, which was much too quick to permit the Falcon to respond. The Falcon sustained damage to hull, capping rail, superstructure and main lower topsail, but fortunately there were no injuries to persons aboard either vessel."

We spoke to others who were aboard Falcon, such as Tad Lacey, who has been sailing and racing the Bay for more than 50 years, and they were dumbfounded at what happened. Lacey and the others said the boats were passing with no problem until Stand By suddenly luffed up.
 
"A San Francisco Bay Pilot was on the Falcon's bridge overseeing the Falcon's course at all times."

I wonder if it was the same pilot that hit the bridge.
 
Here lies poor old Michael O'Day;
He died maintaining the right-of-way.
He was right.
Dead right.
But he's just as dead as if he'd been wrong.
 
Boaters tend to assign more complexity to the rules than they should. Most here will never be able to claim status as anything other than a power boat or sailboat - no constrained by draft, no restricted in ability to maneuver, no fishing boat, no nothing other than a power boat or sailboat. The most complicated it gets for most of us is the narrow channel rule. Other than that, the rules are simple.
 
is there a quick explanation for 'luffing up'...besides broadsiding a much bigger boat
 
If the wind becomes excessive, or heel too great, a sailboat is designed to "luff up" (head into the wind) to relieve the pressure - or the helmsman can do it. And, of course, a blowboat will luff when coming about - sometimes getting stuck "in irons" when coming about too slowly.
 
It's called "weather helm": when the boat tends to round up into the wind as the pressure increases.
 
It looked like they redid the whole top rail of the MF over the last weekend. We went by the yacht Thursday through Sunday and they were working on it the whole time. It was moored close to my boat yesterday next to the PIER 39 Marina. Looked like they were bringing on provisions. It was still there this morning when I left.

It is hard to believe an accident like that could happen with such a large boat; although, I am always surprised at the number of boats on the bay that don't seem to be paying attention to were they are going.

Here are some pictures of it I took over the weekend.

009.jpg


001.jpg


002.jpg


010.jpg


Kris
 
It is a very impressive yacht.
From all acounts I have heard, the Nordic gave the Falcon no opportunity to avoid the collision by tacking in such a close range.
 
I would think the 5 blasts from the Falcon's probably very impressive horn might have gotten the other skipper's attention. Hard to believe the Stand By changed course several times just before the collision and still failed to see the Falcon.

Mike
 
Back
Top