storm port?

peteyo

Member
exMember
Joined
Jul 16, 2007
RO Number
27488
Messages
82
Our community recently experienced a vessel sinking due to silting in the access channel to Lake Michigan. The vessel, a 32 foot sailing yacht encountered high winds on the lake and attempted to make safe harbor only to strand inside the harbor mouth, actually a channel which connects an inland lake to Lake Mich. The vessel was lifted repeatedly by the waves and the keel was battered. A private tug was able to tow the vessel out of the channel into Lake Michigan, where it attempted to make harbor of a deeper port to the south. The vessel began taking water and sank approximately 1/4 mile south of the initial stranding in 10-15 feet of water. The occupants made shore safely. I don't know if the skipper or crew were in contact with the coast guard by radio but can only assume the skipper was unaware of his vessel taking water and so decided to try to save the boat. I can understand the people involved not wanting to risk the vessel becoming a navigational hazard in a restricted waterway but in hindsight it seems foolish for the skipper to be allowed to risk continuing on with the vessel compromised. I also overheard someone mention the next day that ours was a registered storm port. Never heard of this before. If in fact it's true, wouldn't the channel depth have to be maintained by dredging? Any thoughts or info on this?
 
I assume that are speaking of Portage Lake, which is listed as a state of Michigan "Harbor of refuge". The channel is noted to be 9 feet as of June 2004--that was 3 years ago. You would have to go to the local notice to mariners, which will tell of shoaling. Since my chart, which is electronic and a year old, shows a number of NTM, I suspect that there is shoaling present. I understood that the Lake Michigan Harbor of Refuge program is susposed to keep the entrances clear to those designated harbors. I would suspect that budget is keeping dredging from happening...certainly something to investigate, and have the state pay for dredging. I suspect that the dredging is susposed to be by the Army Corp of Engineers. We have been working for over 10 years to get a specific harbor dredged in Pensacola--not happened yet. I would go a political route to put pressure on the powers--before people die.
 
"but in hindsight it seems foolish for the skipper to be allowed to risk continuing on with the vessel compromised"

not quite sure what you been by this... if he coundl't make it in the harbor so had no choice but head back out once towed and attempt to get to the next port. Until he knew that the hull was damaged, that was a sound option.

Bob is right... checking the Notices to Mariner is easy and a must, especially when cruising un familiar waters.
 
NOAA chart for Portage Lake is 14939, harbor chart. In an article written by a Holland C Caper a retired Naval Officer and Attorney who keeps his 33 foot sailboat in Portage Lake, it describes the situation with the Yacht Baraccuda, a 40 footer drawing 7' 9" returning to Chicago from the Mackinac race. They had touched attempting to get into Arcadia. "Next, Barracuda tried to get into Arcadia, However, they touched bottom attempting to do so but were able to return to deeper water and thus keep going.

The next port was Portage Lake. There is no warning that the entrance between the two piers to Portage Lake has not been dredged for several years and is now only three or four feet on the edges and about six feet in the middle. Recent Charts show a depth of 12 feet across the entire entrance and there are no notices to mariners about the shallow condition that has existed for more than two years." Apparently an Inn Keeper was contacted and indicated that there would be water if they stayed to the North side of the channel. The mainsail had ripped and the boat was under power. A "Mayday" call was sent and " Manistee Coast Guard sent four young men in their rubber rescue boat but given the dangerous condition in the channel there was little or nothing they could do." A local 26 foot tug (volunteers) was able to get out of the harbor, at risk to their crew, and tow the boat into deeper water, when the crew was taken ashore by the Coast Guard "rubber boat".

Apparently many of the "Harbors of refuge" are shoal. Comments suggest that nearly all have less than 6 feet in the channels. Many are not mentioned in NTM. No dredging has been done. I have noted in the Great Loop lists, there are references made to these harbors of refuges. Comments in the lists consider that one doesn't have to worry about bad weather because of these harbors of refuge. This is critical, because if the water is less than 6 feet, and there are 8 foot waves (as was the case of the Baraccuda's loss)--even the shoalest vessel is at risk.

I ran the last several notice to Mariners for District 9--and although there are several mentions of shoaling this specifically is not mentioned, including the most recent. So it appears not only is the Corp of Engineers, the DRN of Michigan but also the Notice to Mariners are not taking proper precautions to advise and aid mariners of dangers. Yet, billions go for "port security"--

Wonder if the loss of this vessel will be noticed? Fortunately there were no lives lost.
 
FWIW: If you send notice to the USCG that a particular channel has shoaled, they will ( eventually ) investigate and if found to be accurate, will post in the LNtM. Same is true for missing/malfunctioning ATNs.

Yes, they are short handed/funded ( they are out catching Cubans and druggies ).
 
i can understand dredging being a $ issue, but at the very least such shoaling should be listed in the NTM !!!
 
Back
Top