$$$$ "Strategy?"

Remsberg

Member
Joined
May 24, 2006
RO Number
21391
Messages
79
Please lie to me and tell me this "plan" makes sense since I'm already doing it. ;-)

Buy new boat (ugh) with virtually nothing down (double ugh) and finance very short term (5 years). Create huge monthly payment but generate large interest deduction which was badly needed. On the positive side it does get me through the biggest depreciation years fast and I get closer to not being upside down so long. You just have to commit to keeping the boat at least 3 or 4 years (no problem so far there). I have my Kevlar body armour on so prepared for your responses! Thanks!
 
That probably makes more sense than financing over 15 years, if you can pay a little extra each month you will be even better off. Then keep the boat after it has been paid off.
 
That's a great strategy if you plan on keeping the boat a long time. Money is money, put a big down payment 40% or pay bigger payments, either way it's your money that has to pay the bill. Paying in 5 will greatly reduce your interest expense. Why not put more money down?

One thing you should consider is that if you contract for 5 year term, there is no way you can lower your payments over the 5 years. If you contract for 15 year term and pay the extra money each month to the principle, you have the option of making smaller monthly payments if you ever needed to. Gives you a better option in my opinion.

Also, keep track of all of your extra payments to principle so you can keep track of your loan.

If you are going to upgrade in the next 2-7 years you should buy used.
 
No problem , no armor needed. U have a need. ( write off ) u filled the need. ( boat purchase ) Go to it . Obviously u have the funds to pull this off there is no downside only enjoyment.

Good luck to u ...

Rob
 
R.N.

Good points for sure......I know if I had done the longer term some "crucial need" would always come up....now my bank keeps me disciplined!

You are right.....there will be no more new boats...."I have learned that which I knew."
 
I agree with R/N......contract for 15/20 year loan.....then pay it in 5. This way your not " locked " in to heavy payments....if you hit a hard spot .
 
Obviously I have no idea of your budget but keep in mind that there is a limit on the mortgage deduction - interest and amortized points on the first $1 million of mortgage debt (whether house or boat or a combination of the two) is deductible. Also, you seem to think that you have to buy new. Why is that? For tax purposes it new vs. used doesn't come into the picture.
 
only interest is deductible so your plan actually reduces deductions over the term since you will pay less which is good IMO.
 
Paying it off quickly is good, but you're still worse off deducting the interest than you would be if you didn't pay any interest at all. The interest you pay is money down the drain. Deducting it only softens the blow. In any case, enjoy the boat - that's the important thin.
 
quote:

Originally posted by DaveT

Paying it off quickly is good, but you're still worse off deducting the interest than you would be if you didn't pay any interest at all. The interest you pay is money down the drain. Deducting it only softens the blow. In any case, enjoy the boat - that's the important thin.






Ditto what DaveT said. The deduction only makes sense if the underlying expense is needed anyway. You are better off without the expense and deduction than you are with the expense and deduction. Think of the deduction as reducing the expense (in this case interest) by the amount of your marginal tax rate. So if you're in a 25% marginal bracket, the interest expense is effectively discounted by 25%. And all bets are off on second homes (or boats) if you are in AMT.
 
If your goal is maximum interest deduction, you pay more total interest for a 15 year loan than for a 5 year loan. Your initial payments on a 15 year loan are mostly interest, while your initial payments on a 5 year loan are mostly principal. You'll have to run the numbers to see how much interest you pay per year on your particular loan, but here's a real example to illustrate my point. On a $200,00 loan with 8% interest, you can pay about $1900 per month for 15 years or just over $4000 per month for 5 years. Total interest paid for 15 years is about $85000 vs $42000 for 5 years.

Since you've already done it, the purpose of this discussion is?

Brett
 
Mostly I was curious to see if others took the same approach. In the end it comes down to the least painful way to get something you want (no boat is a need) at a time when I can enjoy it (thus not wait until more downpayment is available). I also thought (mistakenly it turns out) that a new boat would be free of mechanical issues (I've had way too many) and I wanted that reliability / warranty. If I had it all to do over I would have bought a larger 1-2 year old boat with at least 30% down since I have upsized once already the first year (went from a 260DA to a 300DA).

Still I'm OK....got a boat I love and use often; likely content to keep for quite some time; and can afford. Isn't that what we all strive for? Thank you for all of your feedback.
 
Back
Top