Stripped railing screws

HarlenW

Member
Member
Joined
Mar 30, 2007
RO Number
25699
Messages
473
The screws that attach my railings to the fiberglass decks are stripped in several places. On the flybridge, it's about one third of them. I have two questions please:

This is a new boat. Is this a common occurrence?

What is the best way to fix it?

Thanks!
 
IMO any railings should be through-bolted with proper backup...
 
Screws? Attaching railings to the deck? Those should be thru-bolted, and I'm surprised Mainship would use anything but bolts.

When you say they're stripped, do you mean the deck coring is stripped, or the actual screw is stripped? Something doesn't seem right, and I'd certainly be on their case to fix it under warranty. And fix it right, too.
 
After 12 years, my bow rail screws began failing. So I had them thru bolted as they should have been in the first place!
 
The horizontal railing has vertical posts every 4 feet or so and these are screwed into the base gelcoat with 3 screws each. It seems to be the gelcoat/fiberglass that is stripped as the screws just spin in the hole without tightening. I don’t think through bolting is an option due to accessibility. To take it back to the dealer is a three hour trip so I will DIY if I can.

So, what is the best way to do it other than through bolting?

Thanks.
 
There is no other way. Railings must be thru bolted, the holes in the deck sealed with epoxy and SS back up plates (fender washers are a poor second) must be installed. Even if the headliner has to be replaces, it must be fixed in all railings. This is a safety concern--and Mainship needs to make it right. There is another side of the issue--and that is screws which have pulled out, were into a core--that was plywood, balsa, foam etc, covered with a thin layer of glass. If this tore out, then water can intrude into the core. Do NOT take no for an answer from Mainship--this will be like a cancer in your boat if it is not fixed now.

Consider that you also have a liability--lets say that a passanger leans on the railing and falls over board--there is an injury--I need not say more.
 
I think they may be spinning because they are thru bolted. They were just not tightened enough OR the coring wasn't dug out & replaced with epoxy or solid wood in that area. If that is the case, then when did tighten down,, the internal coreing was crushed. Any way you slice it, IT IS A DEFECTIVE INSTALLATION!
Al
 
I too suspect they are through bolted. Mainship is a sister co to Silverton and uses the same construction techniques as far as I can tell. The stanchons and grab rails on my Silverton are all through bolted with large fender washers. The Divinicel cored deck is replaced with wood where the stanchons bolt through. I suspect yours is the same.
 
I'd be stunned if Mainship is screwing into the deck. I also suspect they are thru-bolted, and spinning because the nut is spinning on the other side.

You need to check this out carefully. Like Bob said, water intrusion in the core will be a big problem if you don't make this right. You can DIY, but you probably shouldn't -- you might void warranty coverage. Take it back to the dealer, or offer to pay their travel to come to you and fix it.
 
Bob beat me to it. I share a strong opinion that thru bolting is the only acceptable method. Screws have very few valid uses on a boat. They don't have the strength and worse, they are responsible for a majority of transom, hull and deck failures as they allow water ingress as the screw inevitably fails. Screws are used because they are the only fastener that will fake being a proper fastener long enough to get the boat sold. If the mfg did not provide access to the underside, that's a design flaw and the fault of the purchaser for keeping the mfg in business by allowing them to build boats in this fashion and stay in business. Can't really be overstated in my humble opinion.

Sorry for the attitude, but I've spent too much time on the receiving end of trying to fix that which the mfg knew better. This definately includes 3 boats, all with failing railing stantions, all with screws into a core I had to rescue.

bp
 
Watching a fellow dock mate carry a large section of his damaged bow rail down the dock this morning leads me to this post.

His boat, a newer Grand Banks, mounts their rails in a way that is very easy to remove without tearing out the interior. Other boats don't do it this way and when you need to remove the railings, you have to tear up the interior to get to the thru bolts.

This to me is a problem as well.

Jonathan
 
Thanks everyone for straightening me out on this. I now think that I am mistaken on the screws and that the railing is likely through bolted. I had noticed that several of the screws seemed loose as I could turn them without tightening them and assumed it meant they were stripped. But they are likely bolted but just a little loose so that I can turn them. I will research it further to make sure.
 
Well, that's good news.....somewhat. Better that they are bolts, but if they are turning then they are not sealed. The only way to seal them is to remove, sqirt in some sealant and then reinstall the fastener. You need access to the nut to re-fasten.

Don't settle on letting it leak.

bp
 
Like bp said.

Two person job -- one inside working the nut, other on deck with a screwdriver. Take it out, squirt in 3M 101 sealant, reinstall fastner and tighten gently just until sealant starts to come out. Wait a week, then hold the screw firmly while someone tightens the nut. Try not to turn the screw at that point, b/c you could break the new seal.
 
Back
Top