Sudden Storm Mistakes

chriscraft67

Member
Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2003
RO Number
12563
Messages
529
I was reading the post below and it made me think about last Sunday afternoon. I'm a pretty experienced boater (40+ years) and I think - or thought - I knew the drill when the weather turns bad. The area described will be familiar to Long Island, NY boaters.

We stayed too long visiting with friends at the marina in Greenport. Sunday was in the 90s and when I checked the NWS on Sunday morning, there were those usual threats of "thunderstorms possible." When we left the dock at 4 PM for the 38 mile trip back to Connecticut, it was hot and sunny. As we headed up Long Beach island towards "Plum Gut" and then Long Island Sound, it started to rain and the sun disappeared. I was monitoring channel 16 but in the time it took me to go down from the flybridge on our old 32 ft. Chris Craft, all hell broke loose. We were in Gardiner's Bay and the water is shallow - just 16 feet where we were. The wind and rain hit us from the north (our port side) and the lighthouse and the Gut simply disappeared in the rain. Visibility went from 10 miles to 100 yards. From the lower station, I turned right (south) into what I knew was open water. But that's the way the storm was headed and it was obvious that the following seas would probably swamp us. I used the port engine to turn us into the wind and waves and tried to hold us in position. The wind and rain intensified and the wave frequency worked against us. We'd surf over one and than bury the bow of the boat in the next. Everything in the cockpit and inside the boat came loose. The wind howled and then our bimini top came crashing down into the cockpit behind us taking one of our two VHF antennas with it. Then our flag let go and finally, the other VHF antenna snapped as we crashed though another wave.

In 25 minutes it was over and we were just about where we were when this storm caught us. The boat looked like a wreck but we - and the boat - were OK. It was the worst 25 minutes of my life.

What did I learn? Both the Admiral and I should have been wearing PFDs but they were stowed below where we couldn't get to them. That's just stupid and I will never do that again.

I should have checked NWS before leaving Greenport. All I had to to was turn on a radio and hit the "WX" button but I was in too much of a hurry. I know better than that or thought I did. Dumb again.

My so called lower steering station is useless in a bad storm. All I had was a compass and in banging around as badly as we were, it was very hard to read.

The purpose of this post isn't to inspire more war stories but to let newer boaters know that things like PFDs and checking the weather is important.
 
I agree with the barometer. The storm we just went through wasn't called for an there were no NOAA warnings (until after the storm, of course).

I hope your intended goal of pointing out just how bad it can get does get through to some people. Sorry about the damage. And while not cheap, at least rather minor.
 
If the storm was over in 25 minutes you were in a thunderstorm. There is absolutely no way to predict where and when a "Widely scattered afternoon and evening thunderstorm" will hit. If you have a decent radar the thunderhead will show up and with luck and plenty of speed you can weather route around it and maybe miss the worst of it. Most likely it will kick your butt anyway. Keep a weather eye, look for the building clouds and classic anvil top. Tune in an AM radio (my boat even has AM) and listen for popping static, that indicates a thunderstorm between you and the transmitter. All you can really do is tie everything down and ride it out. Don't try to out run it, you may be going with it and just prolonging the experience.
 
Good story & reminder , hope your message helps someone also
Happy to hear you made it through allright.
 
Wow! I guess another lesson learned to have the boat secured before leaving the dock, so that things aren't flying around the cabin. I've had thing flying around just bucking some big boat wakes. Your conditions had to be much much worse.

Glad everyone was okay!
 
quote:

Originally posted by L. Keith

If the storm was over in 25 minutes you were in a thunderstorm. There is absolutely no way to predict where and when a "Widely scattered afternoon and evening thunderstorm" will hit. If you have a decent radar the thunderhead will show up and with luck and plenty of speed you can weather route around it and maybe miss the worst of it. Most likely it will kick your butt anyway. Keep a weather eye, look for the building clouds and classic anvil top. Tune in an AM radio (my boat even has AM) and listen for popping static, that indicates a thunderstorm between you and the transmitter. All you can really do is tie everything down and ride it out. Don't try to out run it, you may be going with it and just prolonging the experience.






Good analysis.

G
 
My first trip out in a boat where I was actually responsible for operating it since years ago in high school put me in the worst storm on the water I've ever been in (on the water). We really didn't believe we would survive it. I don't know what was worse, the strength of the storm or my lack of skills behind the wheel of the boat. Luckily common sense and a tough old boat got us through it. We were about twenty miles out in the Gulf of Mexico. It was the best thing to happen to us because it caused us to study things we should have already known and to prepare our little boat for the next one.
 
Chriscraft67 - glad you are all safe.

There was a similiar thread that talked of sudden storm scenarios http://www.boatered.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=115951. One of the ideas for tracking weather was cell phones/pda's. We all seem to have them now and they work extremely well if you have the service to get weather. I bought a phone last year based on seeing a friends phone show live loop radar which showed my to not go out even though the skies above us were clear. I use my phone every time we go out, it is simple and only takes a second to check the radar for whatever area you are in.

As far as the comments here about items not stowed or moving about in cabin or cockpit, in my past life in the Navy on subs the on of the first things the skipper did when we went to sea was called angles and dangles. We would take the ship and do large up and down angles to check our stow for sea. Biggest thing I learned from all of that is that there are two main hazards with not keeping your boat stowed all of the time. One is that those things flying around can really hurt you or others, this rule also applies in your car, hit the brakes and stuff will fly. Second, any of that stuff that is lying on the deck is now a trip and slip hazard you have to deal with while moving about on your boat when you may not have the time to be looking down to get something done in a hurry.

Not trying to tell anyone how to boat just giving some past experience.

The Goat Locker
2007 Regal 3060
 
well, PFDs woudn't have helped you a bit in this situation... unless the boat sunk. I think the focus should be on other things.

first, check the weather. Being asleep at the wheel is dangerous. Been there, done that, lost the bimini. Whenever there is a risk of TS, setting out on a 40 miles trip without a weather update is dangerous especially up north where TS can be hidden by other clouds or Haze. Down here in So Fl they cna be seen 50 miles away...

NOAA broadcast on Wx ch. are ok but they are often useless. When a storm develops in one area, NOAA broadcasts switch to emmegency mode and focus on that one cell. There can be another one closer to you that's not even mentioned. Sometimes, at least down here, the NOAA emmergency mode broadcast will focus on a cell that's inland and of no concern to boaters. It's real nice when you see something brewing in the bay to tune here and hear about another cel that's going it a mall 20 miles inland!

Cell phone browsers are the second option. the images are hard to see but it's better than nothing. BUT, you need to have the pages/images bookmarked ahead so that you can get to them quickly without having to go thru a bunch of pages and entering zip codes! set your bookmarks!

IF you have a laptop with aircard, and a boat with a lower helm, take it along and keep it running. My favorite radar imagery is Intelicast, they have a number of options and it's much better than others like Weather.com

if you dont' have an aircard but use your boat a lot in summer, it may be something worth considering... service is around $60/70 a month unlimited and you can use it when travelling. not cheap but very convenient. and if it keeps you out of a storm just once, it's worth it.

On board radar can also be used to find the heavy rain and navigate around. But it takes a little practice so spend some time getting familiar with your radar.

As keith said, most "storms" are localized thunderstorms which can often be avoided and they dont' last long.

Another thing is to make sure the boat is ready or can be readied in time. Biminis need to be able to withstand strong gusts or they need to be setup to be quickly folded up. The weak link in most biminis is the frame. Those little allen screws never hold, once your bimini is adjusted you can drill the tube and use machine screw that will get into the tube instead. Once the frame is secured, you may loose the fabric but at least you will not have frames flying around. Been there, done that, got the close call.

teh final thing is find the nearest sheltered water if you do get caught. Seas can build very quickly so finding some shelter is critical especially with a smaller boat. of course you need to balance this with staying off the coast in poor visibility. In your case, since the winds were blowing from the N, turning towards Long Beach/orient point might have been a good option. that would have kept you into the wind with no chance of being pushed toward shore. waters woudl have been smoother.

dont' forget the sounder as a nav tool either... look at a chart and the depths, in that area it remains deep enough close to shore so if you stay in 10' waters, you'd be close enough for protection but far enough to be safe.

Getting caught in a bad storm with an open helm can be hell. My last resort is to wear snorkeling goggles and a good sailing jacket to stay reasonably dry. dont' laugh.. it helps. it beats being at a lower helm and not seeing a thing and not having a plotter.
 
We went through a similar experience two seasons ago on the 4th of July. Once things calmed down, the first thing the wife asked was "would that satellite radar thing you've been talking about have kept us from that?". Best money I've spent since, it's saved us a number of times. Being able to see the weather as it's advancing and seeing it's likely path has made it much easier to plan our next moves. Either stay put because the weather is going to travel right across our expected path, or bug out NOW because our path is open, but the current location is gonna get slammed. Well worth the initial install cost and monthly service. And when the weather gets crappy it being integrated with the chartplotter means I can keep an eye on things. Can't do that with a laptop down below or a cell phone. As you've discovered, you'll have your hands far too busy to go fiddling with anything that isn't nailed down.
 
This was a particularly bad storm for this area. I'm glad you made it through all right. There were several at our marina who couldn't get into their slips and others who just quit and tied off at the fuel docks to ride it out. I heard a boy was killed at Hammonassett beach by lightning during the event. We get some good ones but this was well above the average.
 
Ditto to satellite weather Bill. It is priceless in North Carolina, Tennesee and Kentucky with all of the afternoon thunderstorms.
 
I was caught in similar conditions. Unluckly(or maybe luckly) the engine hydrolocked so I had to put out the sea anchor. Best move I coulda' done. Wind was blowing out to sea so I just rode it out.
 
Thanks for the 'storm warning'...a good reminder for all of us.

Last time I was in one, the sounder went bananas until the lightning stopped.
 
Read the thread in the Long Island Sound forum. I was in the middle of that storm near where the man was killed and it was the worst thunderstorm I've been in.
 
I had a similar situation on the Chesapeake Bay this weekend. Don't have a radar or a satellite receiver, but I did recently install a digital TV tuner. Several of the stations around Balimore broadcast a continuous weather radar display on their new digital channels.

I had the TV on all afternoon and checked the progress of storms. In some ways this was better than having a weather radar since storms a hundred miles away could be seen and their progress could be tracked. Late in the afternoon on Saturday I moved to a more protected area well before a storm hit the area.

Mike
 
I know how you feel. We were lucky. We just got into port about ten minutes before "all hell broke loose". It sounded like a war zone. This storm came in so fast and caught many by surprise. NOAA predicted it, but it's speed was incredable. I was saddened to hear several people were struck, one killed, less than an 1/8 mi. from us. God works in mysterious ways!
 
We went through a similiar experience south of Charleston, SC. last summer coming up from Florida to North Carolina. The boat is well equipped with gps and radar, however, being unfamiliar (new boat) with the equipment, I had the chart plotter in "boat up" mode and the radar in "north up" mode. I thought we were easily going around the storm and ran us right into it. The admiral had called for canvas up earlier and I didn't heed the call. I will never, ever, ever ignore a call for canvas up from the admiral again. After the storm passed us we arrived into Charleston Harbor, which looked like a war zone. Three boats went down in the harbor during that storm.
 
Back
Top