Teak has natural oils, which help to preserve the wood. When you sand it, it removes equal layers of hard and soft fibers and will be smooth, but you have thined the boards, and eventually the plugs will wear thin and come out, exposing the screw heads. When you add artificial oils, they will attract air pollutants, dirt, molds etc and become very dark. If you "clean" teak, by using harsh chemicals--mild would be oxylic acid--harsher would be either a strong acid followed by a base or a strong base, followed by a weak acid. Both of the latter chemical tend to damage the wood surface. The softer wood is taken out, especially if you power wash or use a stiff brush with the grain.
When I have had to clean teak, I have used oxylic acid, followed by TSP--this is as harsh as I like to go--use a green scotch pad across the grain--but this will cause some wood damage. The "blander" way is to use "whisk" and dilute chlorox--but this will often not remove any of the dark material.
Frankly the teak decks are best washed peroidically with salt water and brushed across the grain with a flexiable brush or the scotch pad. Then just let nature take its course. The oils look fine for a short time. There are compounds like "teak Guard", or Semco which do seal the teak--and the latter is available with some pigment in it--which keeps a lighter color.