Testing for electrolysis

WALSHIE

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
2124
Messages
2,376
We're losing our wood/steel seawall due to electrolysis! We're trying to find the source of this electrolysis. Therefore, with the boats out and no electric connected, I'd like to see if there's electrolysis present now. When we turn on the electric, I'll test again, when the boats are in, I'll test again.

Does anyone have any idea how to test for electrolysis or electrical currents in the water?

Also, we have an electric railroad near our property and some are wondering if it's current coud be contributing to our problem. Someone mentioned it's "DC" and that's much worse than "AC". Is that true, if so, why?
 
I believe u can do it with a regular multi meter... LEt me find out the attachment they used...

Rob
 
I believe I have heard the same,a volt meter should work.Also if you notice any tingling when in the water.Within the last two years a young boy drowned when he dove off the dock and the electrical current prevented him from using his muscles.His mother also nearly drowned in an attempt to save him.
KEEP POWER CORDS OUT OF WATER.
 
You need a silver/silver chloride (reference) electrode and a DC voltmeter. The electrode replaces one of the meter leads and is put in the water. Place the other lead on the metal to be checked. Different metals will have different voltage ranges that indicate protected/unprotected. I couldn't find the electrode on Boatfix but WM (not WalMart:) sells them for $90.

I have a hard time believing the steel is being corroded much by electrolytic activity with boats around. If you are losing steel, outdrives would be falling off the boats since aluminum will generally protect the steel if they are connected via shore power ground. The wood will not be affected by electrolytic activity.

If there is a problem you could connect any old aluminum (mag wheels, lawnmower bodies, etc.) to the steel to protect it.
 
Tony, is that because aluminum is less noble than steel, and serves in the same way that zincs protect aluminum outdrives?
 
Can't help much but to say DC current is much worse than AC current. This was proven on Myth Busters.
I have a device on board to test for electrolysis while in the water for the boat but have never used it. It hooks up to a sensitive multi-meter but that's all I can tell you having never used it. I'm sure someone that's familiar with the device will comment. Seem to remember it had, I believe, a silver nitrate probe ????
 
Tony is correct. The silver cell is used because it establishes a known voltage against other metals. Lacking a silver cell a crude test is to drop any wire connected to the meter in the water and attach the other lead to the steel. If you measure a voltage near 1.0 VDC you have a problem any AC voltage at all is a problem.
I dont know what Mike means but both DC and AC are bad.
 
Mike,

Yes, the aluminum will protect the steel due to their relative position on the galvanic series scale. The galvanic series diagram below shows the relative scale of different metals. The ones at the top will protect the lower ones when electrically connected and in an electrolyte (i.e. water).

galv_series.gif
 
According to that chart, magnesium, zinc and aluminum can be used as sacraficial anodes to protect the steel, is that correct?

I think the reason the outdrives on our boats is not eaten up is due to the use of sacraficial zincs, we all have them and they last about a season. The wall is I-Beams driven about 20' into the hudson floor , in the water about 10' and exposed to air another 20'. These beams had zero protection and lasted about 20 years.
 
Yes, you could use magnesium, zinc, or aluminum. I assume you are in salt water which is a good electrolyte. Aluminum should be fine. It will last longer and is usually cheaper. If you were in fresh water (not a good electrolyte) you might need the sacrificial metal to be further away on the scale. This is why zinc does a poor job protecting aluminum outdrives in fresh water and magnesium is recommended.

It is possible to over protect metals which can cause paint to bubble on the surface. The silver electrode will also show you that. I'm guessing your sea wall is not painted so that shouldn't be an issue.
 
It is important to realize that galvanic corrosion protection has limited effect on stray current problems.
 
There is a very simple way to find the source of electrolysis. Get a high impedance voltmeter and connect it to 2 identical electrodes (eg both zinc) so that you do not record galvanic potential. Place the electrodes in the water a fixed distance apart (determined by the voltage reading on the voltmeter) and rotate the pair until the maximum voltage is seen. The electrodes now point to the sources of the potential difference. Rotate the pair until the voltage reads 0. The electrodes now are perpendicular to the sources. If you do not note a voltage in this manner , then the electrolysis is due to boats which have been removed for the season.
 
I really cant see a steel seawall being lost from electrolysis when a bunch of different less noble(and smaller surface area) metals on boats are in the water and still there at the end of a season. Your problem is more then likely galvanic corrosion which is having two different metals in an electrolyte (water).
Electrolysis is a stray current. If you have a stray current in the water, some boats will be going through zincs in weeks, possible days. The seawall with electrolysis present would have selected (weaker) areas corroded, not a surface rust all over.
12 volt DC will do more destruction because its a constant positive voltage. AC voltage is fluctuating, therefore is basically taking electrons off on the + cycle then putting it back on on the - cycle, but not all of it. It still does destruction, just a bit slower.
How long has the wall been up? Cheaper steel has lots of impurities, it could be destroying itself.
Gary
Sound Marine Survey
 
Gary, in fact, we do have selected areas affected. A diver went down and inspected. Anything under the riverbed or above the water is fine. Apparently the bad area is just below the mean low waterline and down. Also, there's speculation that the pressure treated lumber we use contains copper and migh cause some sort of corrosion.

The wall is 20 years old.

Thanks for the clarification on DC current, makes sense now.
 
Maybe somebody dumped a marine/auto battery overboard? Have anybody leave the dock under bad terms?

Now that I think about it, maybe that is an "admiral's" tale.
 
20 years old is up there. I can't see any metal except stainless lasting much longer. Whats was the life expectancy of other metal walls in your area. There could be lots of contaminates in the mud, metals are heavier and will fall to bottom. That also could be a factor. Croton on the Hudson, oh boy lots of controversy going on there with the past dumpings. God knows whats in that mud!
I know pressure treated wood is made using all kinds of copper. That's why it's so dam expensive today. Are the areas next to the wood showing more signs of corrosion? If so that could be a culprit also, thats galvanic corrosion, not a stray current.
It wouldn't be a bad idea to have the water checked with a meter to verify there isn't any stray currents and to CYA, if you know what I mean.

Gary
Sound Marine Survey
Mamaroneck, NY
 
that is always the bad area with any material. I wont hurt to measure for stray currents though
 
that is always the bad area with any material. I wont hurt to measure for stray currents though
 
that is always the bad area with any material. I wont hurt to measure for stray currents though
 
Gary, I agree, 20 years seems like a long time, perhaps it's just due. However, a few people, alot smarter than me and working in the field for many decades identified the rot as electrolysis.

In regards to contaniments in the mud, we recently dredged our basin so the riverbed was tested and came back perfectly clean.
 
Back
Top