The Great Loop

  • Thread starter Thread starter blouderback
  • Start date Start date
Just curious but does anyone really believe that the OP has any desire to actually DO the Loop in a bow rider or any other boat for that matter?
 
Of coarse not. It's just another game. Considering his last loop was around Ocean City, N.J.
 
quote:

Originally posted by rommer

Just curious but does anyone really believe that the OP has any desire to actually DO the Loop in a bow rider or any other boat for that matter?





I don't think it actually matters, many of us wile away the long winter dreaming of great nautical adventures. Some will be realized, most probably won't. Here's a quote I heard once that seems appropriate.
"I'm the kid who has this habit of dreaming. Sometimes gets me in trouble too. But the truth is I could no more stop dreaming, than I could make them all come true.”
 
Bob, I have read a lot on the great loop. I think you have a valid question, but you might want to be slightly more objective, thought your original question did have some specifics in it.

Most people do the loop over a longer period of time. What are you thinking?

Are there some parts that you are more interested in than others?

There are large stretches of water, all over, that will not have a hotel right on the water. What would be your plan for these situations?

I'm a little hung up on the practicality of having to sleep a wife and kids in a hotel every night. If I were you, I'd start breaking out online maps of the area and seeing how practical you could handle that.

It's winter, so building an itinerary based on some kind of planning will answer all but a few of the most specific questions you should have.

Are you thinking about
 
Bob, If you want an "adventure", trailer your boat to Jacksonville, Fl. and launch in the St. Johns River, you can get a slip right there intown for the night. Head south toward Palatka, making that your destination for the first day, stay at the Holiday Inn there on the river (I guess it is still there), the have (had) a marina where you could tie up. The next morning head southe again stopping at Silver Glen Springs around lunchtime, then head toward Sanford. Spend a couple of days there, and reverse the trip. We did this several years ago in a 20' boat and it was a great trip, safe and comfortable, lots of wild life to see.
 
For what its worth, my dad went from Delaware to Jacksonville FL in a 14' woody runabout with a 35 (if I remember correctly) Evinrude back in '61 or so. I have the logs but haven't read them yet. He passed in '67 so I have no recollection of first hand experience. When we came up from FL to DE (47'er, quite different) it was neat to hear we stayed in the same places he did back then. The boat broke loose once while they were in a tent on the beach, ran out of gas and tied to a day marker in Charleston till help arrived. No phone, no radio and a floor full of 6 gal gas tanks (and I suspect beer :). Maybe I should dig out the log and actually read the whole thing sometime.
Adventure is the spice of life!!
 
"just curious but does anyone really believe that the OP has any desire to actually DO the Loop in a bow rider or any other boat for that matter?"

I guess you've never come up with a "what if" or "it coudl be fun" idea, even if far fetched. sometimes it can be interesting to think out of the box and consider things that may be a little different. i woudn't do it in a small boat, but i see the attraction. there are many places along the way where you can camp for the night. Camping is not my thing but obviously it is to many boaters. I see plenty of them camping out on beaches on some of the keys on week ends... so why not?
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

"just curious but does anyone really believe that the OP has any desire to actually DO the Loop in a bow rider or any other boat for that matter?"

I guess you've never come up with a "what if" or "it coudl be fun" idea, even if far fetched. sometimes it can be interesting to think out of the box and consider things that may be a little different.






Other times it's interesting to watch a train wreck as a person continues to find ways to pull the collective chain of others.

Here we have a site about boater education and a person seemingly bent on pushing the envelop of safety in many of their posts. The 2 interests are in direct opposition and offensive on the scale perpetrated by the OP. I can quote numerous cases of this behavior as it is not a new experience.

Bottom line with the vast majority of his posts is that the theme of his posts are how to use a boat designed for the relative calm of an inland lake in ways that it was not designed. Even the post about favorite nautical books had to do with using a very small boat to make a dangerous trip.

Nothing wrong with his desire to expand his horizons but damn if I think we should give the impression it is a wise and safe thing to do. Remember this site is called BoaterEd short for Boater Education, not DangerousBoatingTips.com

FWIW, I don't give a rats behind about WHO posts a dangerous idea I'd have the same comments if you posted them. I believe a true mariner cares not only about his/her own safety but the safety of other boaters as well. The more "smart" boaters out there the safer it is for everyone.
 
I guess maybe it would be OK to trailer the boat to certain areas and do parts of the loop. For example, maybe I could start short 1 or 2 day trips on the east coast. It would be fun! Start in Atlantic City, and head south, maybe I could make Ocean City, MD in a day or two? I could have my wife shadow us with the trailer, and she and Jimmy's wife could hit the outlets whle Jimmy and I are on our adventure.

Maybe each summer, we could go a little further, or maybe move our starting point further south. Then, the next year, we could start in OC, MD, and shoot for some point south after 2-3 days, and so on for a few years. I guess it could take us maybe 15 years, but what an adventure!
 
you are missing something... boaterEd is a DISCUSSION FORUM! discussion being the key word here... we discuss things and ideas, that's the point.

doing the loop in a bow rider is not a dangerous idea... it can be done safely, the logistics are the problem but can be solved.

what makes you authority on deciding what is safe and dangerous? What make you decide what boat is an inland boat or an offshore boat?

as mentioned, this topic comes up on other forums and usually result in an intersting discussion with good advice given and interestings ideas or tips being given. Only here on BoaterEd do we get this rants and sermons... Sad.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

what makes you authority on deciding what is safe and dangerous? What make you decide what boat is an inland boat or an offshore boat?






Since the title of this forum is "Ask the Captain" he must assume that refers to him, maybe it should be renamed "Ask the Captains".
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

I guess maybe it would be OK to trailer the boat to certain areas and do parts of the loop.





When I had my 19 foot Wellcraft, my wife and I would trail the boat once a year (usually first or second week of June, before we put it in the slip) and take a nice 100 to 125 mile cruise. Early June was a good time of year to do it as it was fairly warm and there was much less traffic. It took us a few years, but we were able to cover the intercoastal between Coinjock, NC to the Delaware Memorial Bridge (including a trip up to Trenton), and between Atlantic City to the George Washington Bridge.
 
I seem to recall that a pair of folks completed the Great Loop on PWC's within the last few years. If that could be done, I'd think a bowrider would be way more comfortable and capable, with proper planning.

You could check out the greatloop.com for ideas. Personally, I would rather trailer the boat to various places and stay for a couple days. Practically speaking, the kids might get tired of being confined to a bow rider for weeks. Can imagine hearing "Are we there yet?" for weeks on end?
 
Ahh heck, I'll bite, it's snowing outside, nothing else to do--except get back to work.

I heard of folks doing the loop in smaller boats. You gotta remember that a bowrider can do say 35 to 45 mph. That will take you a long way in a 10 to 12 hour summer day. That would be at the expense of passing by a lot of beautiful scenery and interesting stops along the way. So, that's the downside of doing the loop in a bowrider.

I would definitely take the tent and camp stove because there are stretches that there are no hotels. Also, there are stretches that you wouldn't want to stay in a stinking hotel. [:-banghead]

It would only be as dangerous as you choose to make it. As with any boating trip, you gotta know your limitations, choose your day, be educated and be prepared.

Start planning, Bob.

David
 
There was an article in either BoatUS or Baoting magazone of a guy that did the loop on a center console. He rigged a tent on the bow for sun protection and weather shelter when needed.

Rommer, I know that Bob likes to be provacative, but it is a valid question, as many have suggested, you may not want to do the entire loop, but select portions of it. The advantage of a bow rider is it's trailerable.
 
It seems that by asking the question, and then reading and heeding the answers, Bob is being educated and will use proper preparation. An excellent question for BoaterEd's ATC Forum!
 
Bob,

Go for it. Do you have the tools and know-how for unexpected "mechanical events"? I guarantee all the planning in the world won't cover the blown impeller, alternator failure, drive coupler, bent/broken propeller, busted belt....I could go on.

I hit a refrigerator one time on the ascending bank that was stirred up off the bottom of the river one time by a tow pushing a full raft of 15 barges. They produce an enormous amount of power.

Can't tell you how much fun it was limping home on 1 intact blade left on the prop at dead idle speed.

;)
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

you are missing something... boaterEd is a DISCUSSION FORUM! discussion being the key word here... we discuss things and ideas, that's the point.

doing the loop in a bow rider is not a dangerous idea... it can be done safely, the logistics are the problem but can be solved.

what makes you authority on deciding what is safe and dangerous? What make you decide what boat is an inland boat or an offshore boat?

as mentioned, this topic comes up on other forums and usually result in an intersting discussion with good advice given and interestings ideas or tips being given. Only here on BoaterEd do we get this rants and sermons... Sad.






And what makes you the authority that my opinion is any less valid than yours? Your right, this is a discussion forum about boater education and safety and I will continue to do just that. At least I don't use it as a personal advertisement.

Les has stated many times in the past that one of the most important things on this site is that new boaters don't ever leave here with a false sense of what is or isn't safe.

Your up....
 
"Les has stated many times in the past that one of the most important things on this site is that new boaters don't ever leave here with a false sense of what is or isn't safe. "

So asking if the loop can be done in a bowrider is not a opportunity to discuss safety or exchange tips on how to do it safely? i dont think questioning whether or not the OP really intends to do it is very productive. if you have nothing to contribute to the thread then don't post on it...
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

doing the loop in a bow rider is not a dangerous idea... it can be done safely, the logistics are the problem but can be solved.

what makes you authority on deciding what is safe and dangerous? What make you decide what boat is an inland boat or an offshore boat?

as mentioned, this topic comes up on other forums and usually result in an intersting discussion with good advice given and interestings ideas or tips being given. Only here on BoaterEd do we get this rants and sermons... Sad.






Pascal, either you are not familiar with the entire Great Loop, or you are pulling our collective legs. Your post: "it's possible although there are a few open stretches that would delay a bowrider" is absolutely wrong.

You don't actually think that it would be safe for Bob to take a 20' Bowrider on Lake Erie, Ontario or Michigan do you?? Those bodies of water are more dangerous than the ocean. Bob has virtually NO experience with heavy weather, his one trip into the "ocean" was a quick jaunt off the Jersey coast in perfect weather.

And someone with your experience stating that we can't tell the difference between an inland or offshore boat - c'mon, you gotta be kidding us. Do you honestly believe that?? How many 20' Bowriders did you see out in the ocean on your trip north?

The only one I see ranting and sermonizing here, is you, and I am quite surprised.

Bob can get all the information he needs right here:

www.greatloop.com

but he refuses to pay for any information on the internet. Shame, he could actually learn something.
 
Back
Top