The Great Loop

  • Thread starter Thread starter blouderback
  • Start date Start date
3 years ago the Admiral and myself were crossing Lake Ontario and a storm blew in...We both put our life jackets on...I was very nervous...And I have a 30 foot boat...not a Bow rider...
Lake Simcoe is another lake you dont play games with in a small boat...very shallow and the storms come from nowhere and it gets VERY rough...
Here's a map of the entire great loop...
http://www.remedyandcrew.com/rxcruises/gloop/loop1.html
 
Thats a great website http://www.greatloop.com/topic.asp?pid=1, if Bob didn't ask the question I probably would have never visited it.
I especially like the paragraph on the bottom of the home page.
"Our members range from experienced Loop cruisers to boaters in the midst of Looping; those planning on one day cruising the Great Loop to those simply exhilarated by the process of learning about the journey. Every level of interest is welcome, no restrictions or limitations! Whether you’re young or just young at heart, still working or retired, ready to travel full time or only every-so-often; whether you’ve got a powerboat, sailboat, trawler, rowboat or no boat; whether you are doing or dreaming – you’ll fit right in, come aboard"
 
"You don't actually think that it would be safe for Bob to take a 20' Bowrider on Lake Erie, Ontario or Michigan do you?? Those bodies of water are more dangerous than the ocean. Bob has virtually NO experience with heavy weather, his one trip into the "ocean" was a quick jaunt off the Jersey coast in perfect weather."

"3 years ago the Admiral and myself were crossing Lake Ontario and a storm blew in...We both put our life jackets on...I was very nervous...And I have a 30 foot boat...not a Bow rider...
Lake Simcoe is another lake you dont play games with in a small boat...very shallow and the storms come from nowhere and it gets VERY rough..."

You both make good points. But I don't think any one is seriously telling Bob to "go for it" with the skill and experience level he has now. Any more than I believe Bob is about to head out in the near future and "do the loop" in one big bite.

But it has been done many times in boat his size or smaller and the folks doing it have managed to survive the journey with no ill effects. So just picking on the size of his boat adds no real validity to your arguments.

And his idea of doing it in bite sized pieces does have validity. There really is no other way to gain experience without starting to get out and do it.
 
i'm obviously not delusional today claiming that a bowrider is an offshore boat, but then is a 35' Carlineraytonal an offshore boat? obvioulsy not. Does it mean that one shouldn't ask if they can do the loop in a 32' carver?

both the bowrider and teh 32 carver can run offshore if the conditions allow.. this is were skills and experience come into play by recognizing what is safe and what is not.

let's be realistic here, 90% of the people thinking about doing the loop never do it for a variety of reasons but it doesn't mean we can't discuss it.
 
Pascal, thanks for adding some sanity here -- I agree 100% with your comments.

While Les and Mike are great and get most of my boating purchases, the bashing of individuals, holier than thou attitudes and petty bickering on BoaterEd are the reason I no longer have an anchor by my name. To me, it is a shame that such a great place is being drawn down by a few people that cannot get along. It seems like folks are starting realize that this is a significant problem and I hope it continues to improve as I would like to spend more time here.
 
I agree with Pascal.

When Bob was talking about the specifics of running to Block island and his more local inlet, we (myself included) handed his unsafe, unprepared, poor attitude butt rigth back to him.

The great loop is a large large collection of boating trips for a bowrider, many of them perfectly safe. When Bob wants obstinately wants to cross one of the great lakes without so much as a grape soda, we can hand him his little butt again. IF, he start spewing such filth again. Until then, I think we should help him find sane stretches of water where he can hone his skills and continue to learn.

It's certainly not lost on me that Bob could have proceeded in less of a stir the pot manner, given his history, but I think a lot of you took the bait too quickly. If your going to be fished, don't just take the lure, push it around awhile to see if it has hooks first.

bp
 
Thanks Ghost, Pascal, WB, Bill, Mike, Brad, Wayne, adru, et al.

I'd really love to do the entire loop some day. I realize that my current bow rider is really not the right kind of equipment for such a journey, yet, like many have said, parts of it could be done easily with my currrent rig.

My dream is to get the kids through college, out of the house, retire with a huge nest egg, and then buy a good size cruiser and spend 6 months cruising the Great Loop. Then maybe I'll start exploring other destinations, such as the Caribbean, the NorthWest, and even possibly Block Island! :)

For the time being, all I can do is dream about it, and live vicariously through those who have already experienced it.
 
Bob, don't lose your dreams because others try to bully you.

Like you, we have a bow rider and a map of the Great Loop on the wall. For now, we're hitting some of the highlights, but once the kids are out of the house, we'll be on the water for some extended trips, hopefully including the GL. And it will be on a different boat.
 
quote:

Originally posted by blouderback

Thanks Ghost, Pascal, WB, Bill, Mike, Brad, Wayne, adru, et al.

I'd really love to do the entire loop some day. I realize that my current bow rider is really not the right kind of equipment for such a journey, yet, like many have said, parts of it could be done easily with my currrent rig.

My dream is to get the kids through college, out of the house, retire with a huge nest egg, and then buy a good size cruiser and spend 6 months cruising the Great Loop. Then maybe I'll start exploring other destinations, such as the Caribbean, the NorthWest, and even possibly Block Island! :)

For the time being, all I can do is dream about it, and live vicariously through those who have already experienced it.






So then why do you start the thread off asking if it can be done in a bowrider???

Seems to me that the only people that "got hooked" are those who took him seriously!
 
Well, Hogan, I guess I can start to get experience by doing parts of it in a bow rider. Maybe take a week or two each summer, trailer the boat to a starting point, and then somehow get the trailer and tow vehicle to the end point. That's the hard part. I was wondering if anyone had any experience on doing it with a trailer boat like mine, and how they accomplished it.
 
If you really wanted to learn from people with experience doing what you say, you would cough up the money and join the Great Loop web-site. I'm sure they will answer all your questions.

As to Block Island, any time you are ready, let us know...
 
"Seems to me that the only people that "got hooked" are those who took him seriously!"

Hogan

you're missing a little detail here... this thread is not a set of private replies to Bob. or whoever the orginal poster may be. it is a public discussion read by thousands of members AND visitors, not just Bob... so when those you think "got hooked" reply seriously, they don't do it just for Bob but also so that others may learn something when they read the thread, including visitors who may not even be registered here.

and guess what... if you type "great loop bowrider" in Google, this thread comes at the top of the result. Funny how those who claim to post to promote boating safety and education end up making this site look bad. do you guys really think that someone searching for info on doing the GL with a small boat would be interested in joining boaterEd after reading this thread after finding it via Google?

has anyone noticed how the "latest member" shown a the top of the page hasn't changed in over a week?
 
Amen, Pascal. That needed to be said long ago.

Let's lay off Bob. If he wants to join as an RO, he will. In the meantime, let's stick to boating. That's why I'm here, too...to learn about boating from those with more exerience and different experiences than I have. I find all these stabs, digs and slaps distracting, unnecessary and a bit childish. Let's move on.

[/offpulpit]
 
"has anyone noticed how the "latest member" shown a the top of the page hasn't changed in over a week?"

Sure, and that means nothing….Derrick showed up there even while posting and waiting on his Anchor. I’ve seen a number of new members that never showed up there.

Stan
 
the "latest member" shown at the top of page is shown until someone else signs up... posting and anchors are irrelevant. in the past, that used to change every day, sometimes even more. Maybe it's yet another broken thing in the code, i hope it is, otherwise this is telling me fewer people are signing up...
 
as this is a public portion of the forum, the repeated requests/demands that people who don't "support the site" are somehow inferior have gotten so old. i've been a member before and didn't find any value in reading the more vocal people of the forum pass jabs back and forth...and talk about the non-paying members in an area they can't read.

"support the site"...you guys should get t-shirts and form your own little militia, arm bands...the whole 9 yards.

i love how Bob gets so many bites with his posts. with nothing worth keeping, he throws them all back and doesn't sink to the levels that others have....some of the fine paying members that we're all supposed to want to join?
 
Pete,
Here is a pic of the Holiday Inn dock in Palatka, I took about 2 1/2 yrs. ago. When we were there the place had just sold to someone besides Holiday Inn. As you can see it was rather shi**y.

43005068.jpg
 
I have to agree with the majority here. It can be done "safely" in a bowrider "if" you plan properly and expect delays due to weather, breakdowns, etc. You would need a lot of back up plans because of the limitations of the vessel. I have never boated on the great lakes, but have spent a good amount of time on the Gulf of Mexico. Storms can come in quick, basically with no warning. Bowriders are NOT designed for bad weather and rough seas.I have been out in my 24 ft. bowrider and got into "sticky" conditions. Nothing quite as fun as stuffing the bow in 6ft seas to get your attention. All it took was someone on board distracting me for 1 SECOND and I got behind on my piloting.
Would I like to make the journey....yes. Would I do it in my current boat....very doubtful. Would I do it with my family in my current boat....no way. Not enough room for everyone, and they would be asking the age old question after a few hours.."Are we there yet?"

Ken
 
Back
Top