Thirsty Westerbeke~Help!(Rant!!)

dale4320

Member
exMember
Joined
Jul 8, 2007
RO Number
27317
Messages
14
Here's one that as usual, is beyond me...
I have a westerbeke 5.0 BCG generator, installed by the marina after the original Kohler died, prior to my purchase of the boat in June.(95 SeaRay 330 SD) The gen had 9 hours on it when I got the boat, but had not been run in a year or so. First trip, it runs fine. On the second trip out, it refused to start. I had the marina look at it & I was informed that I had filled it with water by cranking too long. Ok, but then they say that when they put in the new plugs to try to correct the won't start problem, that the engine also a more serious problem, a loud knocking inside. The service guy says that the starter can break a rod if the unit is hydrolocked and attemts are made to start it. I believed them, pulled the gen out of the boat, replaced broken rod, piston, etc, and reassembled. Reinstalled, tested, & eventually got all under control. Ran the unit 20 hours or so over the next three weeks, all ok, except that I had to replace the impeller from sitting for awhile before i got it. Check this:
I went out after a week or so away & the gen won't turn over. Yup, full of seawater again. Not from my doing this time, as far as I can tell. But the marina had it in the water & worked on a fuel sender problem during the interim...hmmmm....(Strangely, when I tried to turn it over with water in it, it didn't break a rod...it just wouldn't crank.) Ok, I remove plugs, blow out water, change oil, restart, run for an hour or so, all good. I then closed the seacock, ran it for 5 seconds to clear the water from the exhaust a bit, & had it put in it's dry slip. The marina then in the interim fixes a carb problem for me on the starboard engine. I come back a few days later and the closed gen seacock is OPEN, &.... yup, seawater in gen again. Marina says cracked manifold. Here are some observations:
1. The manifold had antifreeze in it, & none had drained from overflow into the manifold that I could tell.
2. Cylinders had SEAWATER not antifreeze in them.
3. The exhaust riser is the only part of the exhaust that gets seawater.
4. The manifold holds pressure when I seal the exits & blow into the coolant inlet, seemingly not cracked, maybe?
5. If the riser was "cracked" it would only leak into the bilge.
6. When i removed the exhaust hose from the riser today, the water in the hose was right at the top of the hose, after a week out of the water. That seems awfully close to the same height as the valves...
6. The Westerbeke is lower & smaller than the Kohler, can the exhaust be draining back into the engine due to the location of the exhaust vs the valves?
Am I nuts here? Is this whole ugly scenario the marinas fault? I don't want to believe it.
 
The Westerbeke is lower"

Sounds like perhaps a bad install to me. Take some measurements and check with Westerbeke.
 
it's important to check water levels when replacing a generator with a different model, there are two possible issues.

first on the exhaust side, your exhaust must go from the manifold to the water lift muffler in one downhill run. from the waterlift mufler, it has to go straight up about 36" above waterline from what i remember then overboard.

BUT... you MUST also check the intake side. if the exhaust manifold is within 12 or 18" of the water line, you must add a rising loop and syphon break on the raw water pump discharge side, before the the heat exchanger.

if you the height are marginal, it won't take much for water to get in the engine. a couple of people standing on the swimplatform or even the rolling of the boat...

when i bought my boat, the original Onan and been replaced by an 18kw norpro (Isuzu engine). it had 100 hours and i put another 1200 trouble free hours in the following year and a half. I installed a larger inverter and battery bank and stopped using the genset all the time. a couple of month later it ingested water and I had to pull the head to replace 3 vavles. I had a norpro approved mechanic do the head work, reinstall the head and re route the exhaust which was thought to be the issue. He missed the fact that the water had actually come in from teh intake side, not the exhaust... re ingested water again, luckily with no damage this time. I decided to look into the issue myself and realized that a anti syphon valve should have been added when the lower profile norpro was installed.

all it took was running the boat with the generator off for the motion, rolling, etc... to get water in.

your mechanic is correct about a starter possibly breaking a rod, didn't happen in my case, only bent/corroded valves, but lower end damage is frequent whenever an engine, any engine, is started with water in one or more cyl.

so check the level carefully and make sure BOTH your exhaust and water intake side are properly installed.

nothernlights has a great PDF document on their site detailing all this. follow the directions carefully.

http://www.northern-lights.com/PDFs/misc_pdfs/dont_drown_me.pdf

The installer should have followed these steps and in theory is responsible. if that's the marina you're using now, they should cover some of the expenses if you confront them with the evidence of a poor installation.

as to prolonged cranking, yes, it can cause water to accumulate in the exhaust and mufler and back in the engine since a waterlift mufler requires exhaust pressure to expel water. 30" is usually considered the max you want to crank a genny with the seacock open...

NEVER assume a mechanic knows what he's doing... in my case, both the guy who installed the norpro and then the mechanic sent by norpro to investigate the water ingestion failed to notice that the exhaust manifold was too close to WL and that a syphon break should have been used.
 
since you say the boat was out of the water it is possible that water in the lines flows into the new smaller gen if the boat was tilted on the lift. It is not unusual for lifts to tilt the boat bow down.
 
I may be wrong, but I think David Pasco said some of the SeaRays with the midship genset had a design problem
where the gensets were prone to water backing up into the exhaust.
 
Hi Again! Thanks Pascal, Bruce & Monterey10 for your help! I humbly beg your further indulgence...
Back from taking measurements, & here are the numbers: Some probably don't matter...sorry if there is too much info...
The actual location of the generator exhaust manifold itself as currently installed probably averages about 6 inches above the waterline.
The genset is about 20" high overall from mounts(bottom) to manifold(top).
There is about 6-8" more clearance available from the top of the genset to the max reasonable mounting clearance in the bilge, to possibly elevate the unit.
The gen could also move forward 4 inches or so, further making it "uphill" of the whole exhaust system, with the help of the upward/forward attitude of the boat.
The base of the genset as mounted in the bilge is about 14" below the waterline.
On the input side, the seawater line from the impeller into the riser has a siphon break 12+ inches above the waterline, & 10 or so inches above the exhaust manifold.
On the output side, the riser angles straight down 6" into the exhaust hose, which travels about 10" more downward, turns a 90 then goes a total of about 18" more inches horizontally to mount to the bottom of the waterlift muffler. Out of the top of the muffler it then goes pretty much straight up about 18" then elbows down about 5" to the outlet on the side of the hull. From what I have gleaned from the "don't drown me" site (thanks Pascal!) the overall install isn't "physics perfect", but it is close enough that it should be ok, right? It sounds pretty typical, from what I understand. (Hey maybe the fact that the gen only had 9 hours on it was actually a bad thing in this case due to the lack of real world test time on the hydrodynamics of the install before I got it? Just my luck!)

Here is my 6000 dollar question: If I raise the whole genset 6-8 inches, it will put the exhaust manifold & the actual valves themselves above the high point of the outlet exhaust elbow. That would cure the whole "water backing up into the manifold" problem, no matter what is causing it~ wouldn't it? No matter how long you cranked the generator, the water would still exit downhill thru the muffler, up the exit hose & out the end of the exhaust first, as the manifold/top of the riser where the water is pumped in would be above the top of the exhaust exit elbow. Or at least make it much much harder to backflow, as it would be "uphill" to the manifold?

ANY REASONABLE IDEAS ECSTATICALLY WELCOMED! I hope I'm missing something in my thinking~(more than usual, I mean)

I'm waaaaay too new to boating to know anything, but this entire "catastrophic multi-thousand dollar failure from water ingestion" problem seems WAY too prevalent and easily created~ surely there is a fix/prevention for it other than "Don't crank the starter more than a few seconds"? If you put something this expensive & easy to destroy in a car, your company would be in court nonstop & out of business in a flash!
Additional info: The exhaust manifold has had a balloon blown up & attatched to it for half a day & the balloon is still mostly blown up. Chances are the manifold isn't cracked as the marina suggested? Also, as well as the cylinders, the carb & spark arrester had seawater in 'em, & not antifreeze, which is all that flows thru the exhaust manifold & engine. Wouldn't that also rule out the manifold & head gasket & head, too? Check me on this: The most likely culprit is cranking the generator, isn't it? I'm not ruling out Monterey10's downhill forklift theory, but in all the times I've seen the drivers go by, the boats were all bow up. Maybe the repair guys themselves are the culprits? Hard to believe that pros would be that dumb, especially twice in two weeks? Although I did cut off the seacock 5 seconds before I shut down the generator the last time, then when I returned after the mechanics, the seacock was open & the gen was drowned again. They were the last ones on the boat the last time, too.
So! Human error? Mechanical error? Exhaust design error?
I await enlightenment!
Dale
 
forget moving it up or forward, too complicated... not needed.

first, cranking for a few seconds will not be enough to fill the muffler. the limit is usually about 30" or so... that's a long time. at 30" your starter is already way too hot anyway.

5" from teh top of exhaust loop down to the outlet may not be enough. it should be... but if the thurhull outlet is really at the water line, it's possible to get water... is there anyway to that loop higher ?

you need to find where the water is coming from : exhaust or intake. Start the genny, let it run for a little while then shut it down. disconnect the exhaust hose on at the exhaust manifold elbow and lower it until you get water coming out. note that water level and reconnect. Crank for 10 or 15" twice (let the starter cool) with the ingnition disconnected... undo the hose and check water level. that will tell you right away if cranking is the issue, i don't think so, but it's good to eliminate that.

another thing to check is to leave the exhaust hose disconnected and rock the boat and/or have a couple of adults standing on the swim platform. See if that gets water in, either from the exhaust or raw water side. if you can, leave disconnected for a few hours while you're on the boat and see if water comes in after a while.

since teh boat is dry stored, it seems to me that it doens't take long for water to come in... maybe hours but not days... it's not a head gasket or cracked head... you'd have coolant in there, not raw water. checkign for cracks in the manifold is pretty easy...

finally, when an engine suffers water ingestion from sea water, you need to flush it with oil right away... even a couple of days can cause damage. you also need to change the oil at least twice after crculation it/short runs. when i had the problem on mine, I first refilled the crankcase with diesel and cranked (glow plugs off) then drained, cranked again with oil, drained, and tghen finally refilled and started. let it get hot ten changed the oil again. that's critical to remove all teh salt residue. Just one change is not enough.
 
you dont have a scoop on the inlet seacock do you?????
 
Back
Top