Here's one that as usual, is beyond me...
I have a westerbeke 5.0 BCG generator, installed by the marina after the original Kohler died, prior to my purchase of the boat in June.(95 SeaRay 330 SD) The gen had 9 hours on it when I got the boat, but had not been run in a year or so. First trip, it runs fine. On the second trip out, it refused to start. I had the marina look at it & I was informed that I had filled it with water by cranking too long. Ok, but then they say that when they put in the new plugs to try to correct the won't start problem, that the engine also a more serious problem, a loud knocking inside. The service guy says that the starter can break a rod if the unit is hydrolocked and attemts are made to start it. I believed them, pulled the gen out of the boat, replaced broken rod, piston, etc, and reassembled. Reinstalled, tested, & eventually got all under control. Ran the unit 20 hours or so over the next three weeks, all ok, except that I had to replace the impeller from sitting for awhile before i got it. Check this:
I went out after a week or so away & the gen won't turn over. Yup, full of seawater again. Not from my doing this time, as far as I can tell. But the marina had it in the water & worked on a fuel sender problem during the interim...hmmmm....(Strangely, when I tried to turn it over with water in it, it didn't break a rod...it just wouldn't crank.) Ok, I remove plugs, blow out water, change oil, restart, run for an hour or so, all good. I then closed the seacock, ran it for 5 seconds to clear the water from the exhaust a bit, & had it put in it's dry slip. The marina then in the interim fixes a carb problem for me on the starboard engine. I come back a few days later and the closed gen seacock is OPEN, &.... yup, seawater in gen again. Marina says cracked manifold. Here are some observations:
1. The manifold had antifreeze in it, & none had drained from overflow into the manifold that I could tell.
2. Cylinders had SEAWATER not antifreeze in them.
3. The exhaust riser is the only part of the exhaust that gets seawater.
4. The manifold holds pressure when I seal the exits & blow into the coolant inlet, seemingly not cracked, maybe?
5. If the riser was "cracked" it would only leak into the bilge.
6. When i removed the exhaust hose from the riser today, the water in the hose was right at the top of the hose, after a week out of the water. That seems awfully close to the same height as the valves...
6. The Westerbeke is lower & smaller than the Kohler, can the exhaust be draining back into the engine due to the location of the exhaust vs the valves?
Am I nuts here? Is this whole ugly scenario the marinas fault? I don't want to believe it.
I have a westerbeke 5.0 BCG generator, installed by the marina after the original Kohler died, prior to my purchase of the boat in June.(95 SeaRay 330 SD) The gen had 9 hours on it when I got the boat, but had not been run in a year or so. First trip, it runs fine. On the second trip out, it refused to start. I had the marina look at it & I was informed that I had filled it with water by cranking too long. Ok, but then they say that when they put in the new plugs to try to correct the won't start problem, that the engine also a more serious problem, a loud knocking inside. The service guy says that the starter can break a rod if the unit is hydrolocked and attemts are made to start it. I believed them, pulled the gen out of the boat, replaced broken rod, piston, etc, and reassembled. Reinstalled, tested, & eventually got all under control. Ran the unit 20 hours or so over the next three weeks, all ok, except that I had to replace the impeller from sitting for awhile before i got it. Check this:
I went out after a week or so away & the gen won't turn over. Yup, full of seawater again. Not from my doing this time, as far as I can tell. But the marina had it in the water & worked on a fuel sender problem during the interim...hmmmm....(Strangely, when I tried to turn it over with water in it, it didn't break a rod...it just wouldn't crank.) Ok, I remove plugs, blow out water, change oil, restart, run for an hour or so, all good. I then closed the seacock, ran it for 5 seconds to clear the water from the exhaust a bit, & had it put in it's dry slip. The marina then in the interim fixes a carb problem for me on the starboard engine. I come back a few days later and the closed gen seacock is OPEN, &.... yup, seawater in gen again. Marina says cracked manifold. Here are some observations:
1. The manifold had antifreeze in it, & none had drained from overflow into the manifold that I could tell.
2. Cylinders had SEAWATER not antifreeze in them.
3. The exhaust riser is the only part of the exhaust that gets seawater.
4. The manifold holds pressure when I seal the exits & blow into the coolant inlet, seemingly not cracked, maybe?
5. If the riser was "cracked" it would only leak into the bilge.
6. When i removed the exhaust hose from the riser today, the water in the hose was right at the top of the hose, after a week out of the water. That seems awfully close to the same height as the valves...
6. The Westerbeke is lower & smaller than the Kohler, can the exhaust be draining back into the engine due to the location of the exhaust vs the valves?
Am I nuts here? Is this whole ugly scenario the marinas fault? I don't want to believe it.