Trailer brake question

rjr

Member
Joined
Jul 25, 2002
RO Number
9498
Messages
66
After many years at a marina I bought a boat I can trailer. Connecticut does not allow surge brakes over 8000# and electric drum brakes don't seem like a good idea. Any thoughts or idea's? Electric over hydraulic seem like the best option but I have never heard anything good or bad about them.

rjr
 
I have a loadmaster gooseneck trailer with triple 7000# axels and electric drum brakes. All total my load is around 20,000 lbs. I have had no problems. Loadmaster offers the elec. over hydraulic as an option. Since what I have works OK for me I really do not know anything about whether one is better than the other, however Loadmaster has a web site and I found them to be easy to work with. Maybe they would be willing to offer an explanation.
 
I have an aluminum loadmaster 18k triple axle trailer with electric brakes on two axles. They work fine,no problems, but I would suggest brakes on all three axles for sure. They are near fool proof and not much maintenance. I had surge discs on my last trailer and they were the best (stopping) I've ever had. If you're using the trailer alot it may be worth the investment to get the electric over hydraulic discs. Tom
 
Electric brakes are the best for boat trailers. They even work going backwards down the ramp. Been using mine for years without any problems. 4 axle loadmaster with 7000 # axles.
 
I have heard that drum brakes suffer from corrosion. I do most of my boating in salt water and don't want to waste boating time working on the trailer. I am also thinking that since I already have disc brakes on 2 axles the electric over hydraulic setup will not cost a lot more than replacing everything with drums

rjr
 
One of the options I ordered from loadmaster was a salt water flushing hookup. Each brake drum is piped with a hose connection for cleaning the salt off.
 
On my first tandem trailer I had electric brakes ( all new), they worked ok but I found that in 3 yrs they were shot ( could have been that the trailer was at it's limit for the boat I had)We sold that boat and trailer and I bought a new Fastload triaxle , I had it built with electric over hyd disc on all axles . I have never been more happy with a braking system. We live in Alberta Canada and I have towed to the West Coast over some serious mountans ( the boat and trailer are about 10,500 lb).The controller I use is called a Prodigy and when I come to a stop the power is cut back to the trailer , Great system .
 
I'm done with drums. Very happy with electic over hydraulic discs.

Peter
 
Electric over hydraulic is the best braking system I have ever towed.
 
Without offering an opinion on which is better, I'd sure like to know what Connicut's objection to Surge Brakes is?
I've had both and worked on bunches of both and just cant find enough of a glaring fault with surge brakes to make them illegal!
 
I think the newer electronic controllers (about $100) for the electric brakes make them better than the surge brakes. Surge brakes won't help whent rolling backwards down hill. The electrics can. I have both and don't care which I use.
 
Apparently the problem is brake fade on long downhills because the brakes overheat. Once when I was a teenager racing along the twisties in my Dad's 1962 Buick Special (215 CI Aluminum V8 convertible) the brakes just disappeared I can say from that experience that it would be truly scary, if not deadly, to have a load of any size chasing you down a hill

rjr
 
Thudpucker, The rap on surge (with the law) is that IF you were on ICE the surge brakes may possibly not respond since your vehicle has to slow first in order to engage the surge brakes. I KNOW what your gunna say, but you must remember who writes the laws. Tom
 
Up here in Canada ( Brtish Columbia) anything over 6000 lb has to have cab controlled brakes . And of course that only leaves elec or elec/hyd. I seldom ever apply the trailer brakes only but the odd time it is nice to be able to . I know that the laws are different in the US and some States don't require brakes on all axles , but in my view for the little extra that they cost why not?
 
T'nk ju veddy mush!

'Yes' on Cab controlld brakes. They have saved my buns a couple of times.

GeeBee has the right idea though. Disks out perform all others hands down.
 
Back
Top