tv antennas

greenstreak

Member
exMember
Joined
Mar 8, 2004
RO Number
12942
Messages
320
Do these really work. The ones that are round and come with an amplifier? The one by Triax claims to bring channels in crystal clear within 30 miles of transmitter. This is the smallest and lightest on on the market. I wanted to mount it on my bow rail.

thanks
art
 
Don't believe it. The few channel's I could get were all blury. We got a direct TV hook up at the dock. If we're on the hook, it's DVD's only.
 
thanks pgilbert. I do record a lot of tv shows on my computer and burn them to dvd. That way I can watch tv programs or movies I save. I use the Hauppauge WinTV tuner for my computer. Does an excellent job.

Art
 
I used a Shakespeare antenna on my house in Fl and it picked up stations 60 miles away.
 
I use a shakspeare 2025 and at my home port in maine pick up Boston channels about 70 miles away.
 
hey shadowcruzr-- Do you know what the db gain is on the shakepeare? The Triax has a 28 db gain. Also it is the smallest.

thanks
art
 
I've got the "typical powered-type TV antennae that gets mounted on the radar arch" on my Carver...in the slip it's essentially worthless...on the water it's pretty good for the double-digit channels (UHF?)...pretty poor for the VHF (single-digit?)...on the hook I'll get a station decent, then the boat swings, it gets worse...lol...so I used satellite at the dock and dvd's out and about.
 
I would suggest getting a unit that has an adjustable gain feature, that is easy to get to and use. Signal overload can be as big a problem as lack of signal. They work better on UHF because size matters especially with VHF channels and most are a bit small for the lower VHF channels. A resonant antenna for channel 2 and 3 would have to be anywhere from 50 to 58 inches long to be resonant at those frequencies. Even if you wrapped the element it could not fit in a 20 inch circle.
 
Anyone who is having trouble with their Shakespeare TV antenna should have the whole system investigated. They work great. But I have seen too many installations of the coax and the connectors that were done wrong. Too many of the people installing these systems have no clue how they are supposed to be done correctly.
 
icon_speech_ok.gif


I guess I'll try one of the Shakespeare antennas then...

[:-headphones]
 
4 boats later and still ****ty reception....

I get the spanish channels great....

I wouldnt waste the money....

Rob
 
I got a $24 amplified rabbit ears and picked up more channels than people with the $130 shakespear ones.
 
I had the shakespear one for a couple yrs..it was crap...was about 3 miles from the antenna of a tv station and couldn't get anything...so..called my dish network and bought a reciever for 145 bucks that came with a new dish antenna....had a couple of mounts added to the base and I hook it to the bow rail when in port....for 5 bucks a month I get all the tv stations I get at home....since I got mine..I see in the marina alot of people are doing the exact same thing...when we head out to another marina..I stow it...tie up...and then stick the antenna right back on the bow rail....aim the antenna and badabing...I got TV!!!...it's great..!!
 
Marblehead, Ohio. I pick up Cleveland and Toledo. If I put them up on deck I can even pull some Canadian Channels.
 
Just a quick technical comment: Broadcast TV is, like marine VHF, direct line of sight.

Given that many boating areas are not near mountains ( hey, I'm a flatlander, 200 ft is a mountain, ok... ), the only antenna height is the actual tower height. Most ( all? ) antenna towers are 2000ft or shorter. Running that through the line of sight calc give an absolute max range of around 60 miles. Subtract for power loss at a distance, and the fact that the tower is unlikely to be "aimed" at open water, and your range will definitely be shorter. Plus, for TV you need a good strong signal.

Net result? You are going to be limited to something like 30 miles or less regardless of the antenna you have aboard. Amplified antennas will amplifiy whatever gets to the antenna. In fringe areas that means it amps the degraded signal and all of the background noise. Thus, amplifiers, while they do work, provide only a limited improvement. A taller, not necessarily higher gain, antenna will provide the best result.

--edit--

Before I get bombarded with barnacle clad rocks, I should state that the above comments are specifically about TV reception aboard boats, which move and rock...

On shore, higher gain, directional antennas are often useful, at sea, their usefulness is questionable.
 
icon_speech_ugh.gif


...to buy or not to buy, that is the question.

— Shakespeare

[:-ashamed][:-indifferent][:-turtle]
 
Back
Top