Uh oh, another PFD thread

lil red truck

Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2007
RO Number
25758
Messages
593
at the risk of starting another knockdown/dragout:I have two ?s.

1) what is the best PFD for a toddler? The one I have in mind is 17 months old.

2)This kid is F.A.S.T. like most kids her age.
We've talked about taking a day trip with the child and her parents. I think I would feel more comfortable if she was tethered to one parent. One of the parents seemed not to happy with that idea. " I'm not putting a leash on my daughter." Our boat, our rules? Or rely on judgement of parents? I'm pretty sure I know, but I'd like some advice from some seasoned folks. Thanks.
 
My kids started boating when infants (one month) and my grand children at several months of age. The kids know that they are expected to wear a life jacket, just like they are expected to use the car seats etc. No fuss, it is just what they do. Try and make it natural. We did lead by example at first; although I rarely wear a life jacket, I did when they come to visit. Some with their parents.

We use the Stern's jackets. They have a floating collar, which will keep the head out of the water, and float face up. This is very important. We have never used tethers, but one adult is assigned to each child--at least at first, until the rules of the boat are learned. In some ways it has been easier, because we currently have mostly pilot house boats--and they first learned about boating in a large trawler. My granddaughter is 6 1/2 and will be driving the 18 footer (along with gramps)--and I suspect that the 5 year old will want to drive this year too. At age five my children were sailing their own sailing dinghy--but the grandchildren don't have this opportunity.

My advice for a toddler is assign an adult to supervise, use a sterns jacket appropiate for the child's weight and chest size, and have the head floatation until about age 3--maybe longer if the child is a non swimmer.
 
any PFD which fits... in other words.. not too big. personally, i think a cat III is ok, doesn't have to be the bulkier cat II unless conditions are bad...

you're the captain, it's your boat, your rules. that said, tethering maybe a little too much, if the parents pay attention, it's probably not needed.

on your boat, make sure the child stays in the L shape seat across the helm, I'd avoid the cockpit. I had an 85 2550 when both my kids were young, and to be totally honest, they rarely wore PFDs... too darn hot down here.
 
PFDs for children are based upon weight. Under 30#s, 30-50#s and 50-90#s. The under 30 has a collar, a crotch strap and a loop on the collar. Makes it easier to grab in the event of a fall overboard. I've never found a tether to be necessary and may actually cause someone else to trip. One parent is responsible to watch the child AT ALL TIMES. If they want to relax, they need to bring a babysitter.

Gene
 
We have two - a Stearns and a Mustang. Our procedure is that once we are on the boat, either my wife or I hold one in each hand and he picks which one to wear.

With repsect to tethering, it has its place, but mostly for offshore sailing. For a family cruise around the bay, I think it is way overkill.

Besides, at 17 months, the baby will most likely be fast asleep 50 yards from the dock. A boat is the greatest rocking chair ever invented.
 
We have three young ones, ages 2, 6 and 7. I like the "Lil' Legends" by Mustang - Cat II for the younger ones, the 7 year old's size is youth and is a Cat III. The only difference is the head-supporting collar, so no additional bulk or heat issues. Whatever you use be sure it is CG approved for the age and size, which then will have a crotch strap.

When underway, the 6 & 7 year old's (wild minded boys who can move very quickly) are required to be in either the helm or companion helm seats. The 2 year old is firmly attached to the Admiral, wherever she is.

Harness and tether is debatable, and opinions vary widely (and can be fight provoking). Fundamentally, it is a safety device, not a leash. Anyone who has done any shorthanded offshore sailing knows this well - that's where I learned about them years ago. We use them with our kids on a power boat as we have a fairly open cockpit and the adults are normally outnumberd. If you are inclined to using tethers, then some serious judgement in where and how they are anchored is necessary. One simple option is the tether is always on underway and is in the hand of an adult at all times. This tends to reinforce adult responsibility.

Whatever you decide, it is your responsibility and hence your decision. End of story.

I'll add one more practice. While the Admiral and I are both excellent and experienced open water swimmers, we both wear Mustang inflatables when we are underway with our kids. We do this both to set an example and end the questioning of why we don't when they must. The added benefit is if something develops suddenly, nobody has to deal with getting a PFD.

Edit - had the name wrong, it's Lil Legends, not Survivors.
 
I like the Mustangs. They seem to be of a little better quality then the rest.
 
I personally prefer the Mustang Lil 'Legends. Even the 50-90 pound jacket comes with a crotch strap and collar handle.
 
For our three year old (she is a Princess and in to Barbie), I found a Barbie child life jacket at WalMart. I also found a Spiderman one for the six year old, but he is just a little bit too big for the child size. I found they got excited about their life vests when we made a big deal about how cool they were. WalMart has some cool ones - Barbie, Spiderman, Dora, Scooby.
 
Thanks All.
I like the idea of giving a choice and the added perk of availabilty of a second dry vest.
I'm leaning toward having a tether (safety device, thanks) available for use if the conditions warrant it's use...and to let the parents decide. I'm confident that with 4 adults present who love this lil one she'll be fine. thanks again.
 
Personally, I don't like the tether idea. If it gets wrapped around a prop or drowning person, the kid will be pulled down. If it's even slightly rough, someone will want to hold the kid, trust me. If it's calm, someone will want to hold the kid while underway. While anchored, if the kid climbs over and falls in, that's what the vest is for.
 
i have always made it manditory that a life jacket be worn on a child when --

-- underway..at all time ruff or calm, warm or cold everywhere on the boat.
--- while stationairy and on deck, if in the cabin with adults around it is ok to remove jacket

the few bucks to upgrade to a better jacket is IMO money better spent then buying any kind of tether
 
Thanks again all.
Chris, you make good points.
Les, she's sleeping right now... boy did she need a nap. When she wakes up we'll measure her chest. She just weighed in at 30lbs last week. Hopefully, I'll order later today.
btw, pascal--I was thinking the same thing about seating.
 
Please be certain the PFD fits properly. Do NOT buy her one to "grow into"! A PFD which is too large is more dangerous as it has the potential of trapping the child's arms over her head in the water. And adjust its straps so the body of the vest fits snuggly to prevent it from riding up her chest.

Put baby powder on her skin and perhaps a cotton shirt under the PFD to help her be more comfortable. If she can play in the tub or a kiddie pool before she wears it on the boat, that will help her get used to it and to associate water = wear PFD. Have fun!
 
I know Liz.
On the other hand, since all this measuring and buying and making sure she wears it is gonna be such a huge PITA,
we've decided to just tie balloons to her neck. They will be brightly colored to ensure being able to locate her...and besides she really likes balloons.
 
Honora,
Just be sure that the balloons fit properly. Helium might be a possibility for better flotation. Around the neck is good, since then you won't have to worry about them "riding up her chest." I wouldn't try the kiddie pool or tub first, as simulated experiences often give a false sense of security.

Melanie
 
But if the helium should leak from the balloons, how long would she sound like your cousin Donald?
 
You guys---gals---are tooooo much! Have a great weekend. I'm going boating. Bye
 
Back
Top