Understanding transducers

MrsRobinson

Active member
Member
Joined
Nov 22, 2005
RO Number
19626
Messages
1,074
We own a Garmin GPSMAP 2010 and want to add the GSD 21 sounder.

We will need to purchase a new transducer that matches up with the sounder.

Here is a link to the sounder and optional transducers:

http://www.tigergps.com/garmingsd21.html

The boat is on land right now so now would be a good time to do this. The transom mount is less expensive but thru hull "feels better" to me for some reason.

Both mention "Beamwidth of xx degrees" where xx is 12, 14 or 15.

What does this mean? Our deadrise is 14 degrees. Is this a measure I need to be aware of/concerned with when purchasing a transducer?

Second question, is transom as good as thru hull in our application? River boating, depths up to 50 feet, usually in the 5 - 25 foot range, 33 foot cruiser.

Thanks
 
Hello there.
Please picture the Beamwidth as the width of the "beam" or signal in degrees as it exits the transducer and shoots down to the bottom. The signal "leaves" the transducer with the size of the antenna (transducer) and starts spreading while traveling downwards. What is the importance of this? You want a narrow beam for detail or to "pinpoint" an area and not the entire bottom, but not so narrow that the signal is lost when the boat rolls or pitches.
As for thru hull or transom mount, trailered boats usually use transom mounted and the mooring/marina types use thru-hull. (The thru-hull transducer can be damaged by an impact with the trailer while loading or unloading)
Hope this helps.
Cpt.Harold
 
Think of your beamwidth as a triangle that starts at your transducer and spreads out as it shoots down. The narrower the beam, the greater the accuracy over a specific area.

When mounting a transducer, the trick is to get it in clean, undisturbed water to give it as much accuracy as possible. I have had both applications and both have worked well for their use. Another option is a "shoot thru" - if your hull is cored - disregard this option, it will not work.

Either one requires a hole to be drilled, either in the transom or through the hull. When mounting a thru hull you will probably need a faring block to compensate for the angle of the hull to horizontal. Makes the install a bit more tricky.

Are you self installing?
 
The degree’s on a transducer are their “cone” degrees. The example listed below is from one of Garmin’s options. It’s a dual freq unit, when at 200kHz it’s beamwidth is a narrow 14 degrees, at 50kHz the cone is much larger at 23 degrees.

1KW, Bronze, thru-hull mount, transducer with depth, temp and fairing. Operating frequency of 200 and 50 kHz. Beamwidth of 14 degrees at 200 kHz, 23 degrees at 50 kHz. Transducer kit comes with installation instructions. Please follow these instructions carefully to ensure proper operation.

I have multiple transom mounts, but also have an aluminum hull. Debris and haul out methods sometime interfere with the mounting. Cables are ran on the outside of the transom and don’t provide as a pristine look of installation as a thru-hull mount.

Deadrise degrees has a bearing on the installation of a transom mount regarding placement. Needs to always be in CLEAN undisturbed water and not in propwash, this is easy with I/O’s and much more difficult with inboards. Thru-hulls are installed forward of the transom and props in clean water and are better suited for inboards.

Performances between properly installed thru-hull and transom mounts are equal.

BoatFix.com has both the GSD-21 and Digital GSD-22 sounders.
 
Greg,

For your application I recommend you consider a "shoot thru the hull" transducer over a "thru hull". For the boating style you mentioned it will serve very well with the added benefit of very low cost of both transducer and installation.
 
The 'angle" that is being measured in degrees as you read on the specs for the transducer is actually called the "Cone Angle".

If you picture the sonar signal being sent out by your transducer as an upside ice cream cone you will understand better what is happening.

The larger the angle of degree (higher number) the wider your signal is being spread, but less dense in concentration. As you go into progressively deeper water, you are "painting" a larger area of the ocean bottom with your signal.

A narrower or smaller cone angle is preferred when you are fishing frequently in the deep, while a wider (smaller number) is better for less deeper water. There are some transducers that are designed to work in waters like the flats down in the South east coast or the Bahamas, etc.

As far as thru hull versus transom mount? The answer is that the thru hull "SHOULD" work better. In regard to your particular boat, your mileage may vary!

A "PROPERLY LOCATED AND MOUNTED" through hull will work better than a "PROPERLY LOCATED AND INSTALLED" transom mount. This is only because the through hull is located in the smoothest and "acoustically cleanest" water which is further away from the prop(s) than a transom mount.

Every boat differs, so while one boat may work better with a thru hull, another boat may work better with a transom mount. Much has to do with the hull characteristics of the boat, and whether an upstream fitting, chine or strake cause some turbulence.

Transom mounts are not the easiest to mount as the actual position of the transducer face has to be "just so" or you will not get the ultimate echo, or will lose image at speed, or will get 'lost bottom' symptoms.

By design, a transom mount is meant to "snap" out of the holding bracket if an obstruction is hit, to avoid damage. Many transom mounts have a tendency to "shift" slightly, or pop up completely, particularly in sloppy conditions, and cause the boater to have to reset or shift them, usually at an inopportune time.

If you are concerned about putting a hole in the bottom of your boat, remember that the manufacturer has already put a handful in there!

The accidents that you hear about with failed thru hull transducers are usually the result of sudden hard impact or a poor install.

There is a newer type of transducer available, manufactured by AIRMAR, that is called a "tilted element" transducer. These are mounted in a hole in the bottom of the boat like a conventional thru hull, but are flush to the hull surface and protrude by about 3/16". they are next to impossible to knock loose by impact or by putting on a trailer. There is just really nothing to hit. The install, by following the instructions, can be done by a Saturday DIY'er with some simple tools and materials.

THEY NEED NO FAIRING BLOCK!

The sending element is tilted, and the assembly can be tweaked to match the deadrise in your hull so that the transducer face is always as close to perpendicular to the ocean bottom, the ideal position. And they run clean and turbulence free. A coating with transducer paint and they remain clean for a full season.

They are available in two configurations, 12 deg. and 20 deg. to more closely match the deadrise of the boat. There is also a HIGH Performance model available in SS with multi elements and 1000 watt capability for the serious offshore fishermen.

I have two fish finders on my boat. The same 2010C as yourself, and a Furuno NAVNET. While there is no comparing the two, I use the Garmin as a backup, or, as the primary, when I need to run radar on the Furuno. I originally had a conventional bronze thru hull with fairing block hooked up to the Furuno; with a shoot thru (as mentioned in another reply) to the Garmin.

I switched out the Furuno tranducer, and installed a tilted element. I no longer lose image at any speed, or in sloppy conditions. The overall image, definition and separation is much better with the tilted element!

I am considering switching out the shoot thru and installing another tilted element for the Garmin. A friend of mine did that last year and saw much better results with the thru hull hooked up to the Garmin. He did this on a relatively thin hulled flats boat, so he never really had much signal loss with the thru hull which is their major disadvantage.

No matter what fish finder you may purchase, no matter how much it costs or how many bells and whistles it has, the extent of its performance and your satisfaction is dependent on the transducer. A poor install or the wrong type can make a superior Fish finder a mediocre performer, while a good install with the right transducer can make a mediocre fish finder a dependable producer!

http://www.airmartechnology.com/airmar2005/ex20/RMProducts/ElectCat.asp?ProdID=36&Man=Garmin&PageNo=67

Hope this helps. :)
 
I have the GSD21 displaying on a Garmin 478. I use the transom mount transducer.
tigergps_1984_17205823


My setup reads accurately down to 1' (12") of water.

The nice thing about a transom mount is that if it is not performing as you think it should, you can easily change the location or angle. The disadvantage is it is more susceptible to outside influences. I didn't have much luck with a shoot thru installation because I wanted reliable shallow water readings.

IMG_2483.jpg


Notice I have a Starboard plate mounted to the transom. This allowed me to fine tune the location of the 'ducer with no new holes in the transom.
 
Great feedback, thanks.

Our #1 concern is shallow readings, the closer to true depth the better. It's not unusual for us to end up in 5 feet or less water.

The boat has an existing thru hull and I plan to do the installation myself. I did it on a previous boat with no issues.
 
Greg,

When considering which transducer to install, our deadrise is 17* v. 14. Just wanted to save you some headache down the road.

Good luck.
 
Back
Top