Using a boat broker

CurrentSea

Active member
Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2002
RO Number
10265
Messages
9,958
Decided to take my boat selling to the next level, so I went to see a broker.

I am talking a few deals with dealers about trading my boat in and I tell him that. He says this is a partnership and even if I sell my boat on my own, trade it in, or trade it for a new boat I still owe him 5%. Is this normal?

Now I am stuck because I am close on a few deals where I would get more than if he sells it and I pay him his 8%.
I got screwed on a house like this once. 2 weeks after broker took it, my friend bought it from me. Cost me $8k to the broker who did nothing.
 
Is this normal?

Dont matter.

What matters is the deal you set up with the broker. Or the deal you put on paper with the broker.
IMO

Read that agreement to see if theres a way out. Some times there is.

YMMV
 
What possessed you to go to a broker!? You seemed to be doing all the right things to sell your boat yourself. I think you just needed a bit more patience. I'm in the process of trying to buy, and I'll tell you, I wish brokers were not in the picture. They drive me nuts!

I'd buy your boat, but of course it is out of my price range. Seems to be the story of my life lately.

Shel
 
Oh boy. When I put my boat up for sale, I tried using a broker at first. However, I made sure to sign a non-exclusive contract. So that I could sell the boat myself w/o owing them a penny. A month later I "fired" them since they were doing nothing to sell the boat, in fact they had lied to me about stuff they had supposedly done, and I thought I'd get a different broker. After firing them I decided not to waste my time with any brokers after all, and I decided to sell the boat myself with no help.

Yes many brokers like to have exclusive contracts, but most will allow you the option of a non-exclusive one if it's the only way to get your business. I've seen some that offer different commission rates for the two types of contract, for example there was one that wanted 10% if it was non-exclusive but 8% if it was exclusive.
 
CurrentSea,
You have to remember this is a "buyer's market" (and as a guy who just sold his boat a few months ago, I got tired of that phrase) and with the price of fuel it's going to be hard to sell a "bigger boat" like yours. I started listing (on my own) my Crownline 262cr (cruiser style) in August 2007. I had an agreement with the marina that brokered my boat that if I sold the boat to someone I know, they got nothing BUT if they found a buyer then they got thier 10%. I had one guy interested in my boat back at the Chicago Boat Show (via the broker/marina) and then finally sold it to him at the end of April. It's a long and hard process. And when the boat is bigger, the market (people looking) gets smaller, or so it seems to me that it works that way.

I had looked at another marina (to broker) that had more than 2 locations and thier broker deal was if I sold the boat on my own, they STILL got thier 10% - so obviously I didn't go with them.

Good luck with the sale. She's a great looking boat!
 
Dave-
The broker is a hired agent to do a specific job for you, sell your boat. You are the one with the check book, you are in charge. Write the brokerage agreement the way you are comfortable with it. Just because he has a listing, he does not have total control, depends how you write the agreement. He is entitled to what you agree on, nothing more, nothing less.
Write into the agreement that any buyer or trade in, he has not initiated, he gets nothing. He is not entitled to anything, he didn't do anything.
good luck
 
I believe this has already been said in other words above but I'll reinforce it again.

If you already have a signed agreement with a broker then you are tied to the terms of that agreement. If you have not signed an agreement with a broker do not do so until you have included terms in that agreement that specifically excludes from the agreement those dealers you are talking with. That's what we did when we listed our Silverton but, fortunately, the broker sold the boat in less than a week so the other prospects were not an issue.
 
Dave,
boat brokers function same as real estate brokers. Everything in the agreement is negotiable. Only sign a listing that you feel is fair and on terms that you feel are reasonable and terms that you'd personally agree to if you were in his shoes. I've yet to find a boat broker that is worth a darn whatsoever...wish i had! I know from my real estate brokerage I add a ton of value to my clients but i've yet to meet a boat broker that comes close to that. Good luck.

P.S. I have my boat listed with a broker to get it on yachtworld but they excluded my pre-existing boattrader ad so any lead from there does not result in my having to pay a commission. I obviously am 100% happy to pay a commission to someone who sells the boat but i've done tons more than the broker at this point, unless you count data entry to upload to yachtworld!
 
When you write the contract with the broker list your "exclusions." These are the contacts that you have already made. As already noted a contract can be written any way that you and the broker agree.

G
 
Thanks guys.
He didn't like the idea if I sell or trade on my own, that he gets nothing. He kept saying it was a partnership. Somehow it just bothers me that if 1 week after signing it a friend comes along and says he will buy it and I am stuck paying him $5K for nothing.

Plus he annoyed me becuase he kept trying to get me to list it lower. The more I thought about it, sure he wants it lower. If I list at $100K and it doesn't sell, he gets nothing, if I list it at $70K and it sells right away, he gets a quick $5600 and he may not even have to place a ad.

I think a fairer statement is if I sell it on my own or trade it, I will reimburse him for his costs, which includes any ads he placed. This way if he sells he gets his commission, if I sell, he gets reimbursed for his effort adn placing a ad is not alot of effort.

Like I said, I made this mistake with a house once and I am not doing it again. I signed nothing.
With that said, I realize that if I was going to list with a broker for $95 and he sells it, then I get about $88 after commission, so I guess I should drop it.
 
CurrentSea,

If the broker says that it is a "partnership" then where is his hslf of the money you have invested in the boat?
 
When i sold my silverton there was a time limit with the broker. luckily it only took about a month to sell.
 
CurrentSea,

My advice is to keep looking for a broker you feel comfortable with. The "attitude" of this industy almost makes me happy to see whats happening now. We have been looking to move up and are trying to decide which boat is right. My experience with these guys is limited, but dealing with them from the purchasing side has been anything but satisfying . There seems to be a very lethargic and incompetent atmosphere around the several I have spoke to in getting them to show me boats. (We are looking in the 100 to 150K range, and IMO, thats not small potatoes)

Then we came across a gentleman. He is real and down to earth. He leaves me VM and emails of subjects we might be considering and has offered to show them during off hours. In other words, seems like he is actually WORKING. He has boated all is life, but new to the industry - maybee thats why! LOL We feel comfortable with him enough to list our boat, should that be necessary.

I would also add, the boats offered "by owner" are cleaner, more documented and ussually more accessible than the brokeraged. I would much rather have a private sale - on both ends IMO. Yes, it takes more time, but nobody is going to work harder - or know the boat better than me.

Have you considered taking the commision money and advertising yourself? At least you would know something was getting done and what the expense was producing. Yachtworld is good, but I have seen the same listings in my category for a long time now. I have found Iboats and some others to offer more variety. I also go out of my way to get current issues of Saltydog and Boatrader.
 
Back
Top