VEC specifically Closed Molded Process

Mike V

Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2006
RO Number
22999
Messages
32
Why isn't a closed molded process like VEC more popular and why isn't it considered technically superior to "hand laid"? During aircraft manufacturing processes; closed molded process are required. "Hand Laid" (hand jobs) are completely unacceptable because the resulting composite structure: is not uniform; is subject to voids; has less "strength" (when subject to various tests). Hand laid composites are akin to the old "rags sticks and glue" airplane construction. Why then are hand laid boats better than closed molded IE: VEC?
 
I've been lucky enough to have toured Genmar's VEC facility. The molds are very expensive as is the equipment. It's also a patented process. It is technically superior to "hand laid." When is the last time we heard about delamination or blisters on a Genmar product?
 
The aircraft industry uses prepreg composites, vacuum bagging and autoclave curing to make very strong, very light structures. These processes are very expensive.
 
The process itself is actually cost effective. Genmar can produce a hull much faster than the hand laid process and with consistency. Most small boat manufacturers don't have the money for the investment. It also, as a bonus, releases far fewer toxic emissions.
 
The process is faster and produces a better hull, but the molds and tooling can be cost prohibitive for larger boats. Usually the tooling costs are amortized over the projected production run on a particular design. For the lower priced, higher production, smaller hulls this looks like the way to go. On larger hulls with much lower production, the labor savings may be canceled out by the high tooling investment and if a particular model boat happens to be an Edsel, the company can take a huge hit if they have to dump the molds and tooling. A good compromise may be resin infusion where matched molds are not needed and you achieve similar results to the VEC process.
 
Back
Top